Gold to hit $5,000? Is now the time to buy gold?

Dominic Frisby explains why the gold price could be set up for a major rally as sentiment towards the yellow metal shifts. Is it time to buy gold?

A selection of various weighted gold bars and coins
(Image credit: © Bloomberg)

Gold had an epic bull market in the noughties - I still remember the key numbers like it was yesterday.

There was the low in 1999 at $250/oz, marked for all eternity by Chancellor of the Exchequer, Gordon Brown, as he sold off two-thirds of British gold at the bottom of the market when there were no compelling reasons to do so.

That low was re-tested in 2001 and we got a classic double bottom, followed by six years of a bull market, which ended in May 2006 at $720/oz.

Subscribe to MoneyWeek

Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE

Get 6 issues free
https://cdn.mos.cms.futurecdn.net/flexiimages/mw70aro6gl1676370748.jpg

Sign up to Money Morning

Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter

Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter

Sign up

There was a pullback, some sideways action, then the bull marched on to $1,030/oz.

Then the Global Financial Crisis came along. Gold plummeted along with everything else, and it was back below $700/oz.

An unstoppable bull market lasting three more years followed.

First, the gold price broke out to new highs above $1,030. On it marched until it eventually peaked, with the Greek debt crisis, at $1,920/oz.

Then came the bear market. Five brutal years of pain. It went all the way back to $1,040/oz.

The period between 2018 and 2020 saw gold rally again, heading north of $2,000/oz, albeit briefly.

But here we are in early 2023. And guess what? As I write, gold sits at $1,920/oz - the same price as it was back in 2011.

What’s next for the gold price?

Will it pull back from here? Probably.

It has rallied $300/oz in barely two months. It’s overbought. Neither silver nor the miners are leading. That’s usually not a good sign.

Charlie Morris says gold is trading above fair value. Charlie Morris is usually right.

You can get cute and try and trade it, but no one knows what is going to happen. It’s a precious metal and it’s a market. If they can throw you, they will.

But then again, gold usually does well when trust in financial markets is low. I’d say that’s the case now. Do you risk your position in the hope that you can get back in lower? What if it goes up instead?

Or you can take the longer-term view. Like the famed trader, Old Partridge, in Edwin Lefevre’s Reminiscences of a Stock Operator, who never wanted to lose his position in a bull market, a view since echoed by a memed typo, you can just hodl on.

We must each make our own choices, learn from them and live with them.

What happens to the gold price if everyone starts buying?

Here’s a nice little thought experiment.

I’ve heard it before - but I’d forgotten it, and it was brought to my attention again by Winston Miles of Canadian investment house Eight Capital.

There was a presentation by strategist Grant Williams in 2016 called “What If?” when he asked what would happen if pension funds, which currently had a 0.15% weighting to gold, increased that allocation. Miles decided to run that scenario in today’s marketplace.

“According to the OECD’s most recent data, global pension assets are $56 trillion. I could easily see pension funds getting up to 1% of their portfolio in precious metals on average. But let’s be a bit more conservative and go with two-thirds of 1%, or 66bps… which is $373,903,924,800.

“That amount of money … could buy every single company that makes up the Philadelphia Gold and Silver Index… which would set them back a cool $297 billion. Then they could buy every share of GLD, even taking delivery of all that gold if they wanted, as it’s all sitting in a vault somewhere. That would cost another $56 billion. Then with the scraps left over, they could buy every share of the GDX… GDXJ… SIL… AND the SILJ.” (Those are the gold and silver mining ETFs).

In short, there’s a lot of money out there. On a relative basis, there isn’t a lot of tradeable gold, and there aren’t that many gold mining companies. A small shift in the narrative could send the gold and silver markets a long way higher.

“It’s an environment,” says Miles, “where almost no major pensions have a portfolio manager focused on metals and mining. The infrastructure is totally gone. It’s hard to add supply, the mines are old, it takes ten+ years to build new ones, these are really long lead time projects.”

You can conduct the same thought experiments with oil, gas and coal. Very little allocation (largely because of ESG), and very little investment leading to tight supply and long lead times.

You can conduct the same experiments with bitcoin. What happens to the bitcoin price, if bitcoin were to become a core, mainstream portfolio holding?

They all go a lot higher.

You can’t say the same about tech, the S&P 500, or government bonds.

The narratives may not change, but if they do, look out above.

On this note, here is the S&P500 relative to gold since 2000. When the chart is rising, gold is rising relative to the stock market and vice versa.

Chart showing gold price

At $1,920/oz gold is a lot cheaper today than it was when it was $1,920/oz back in 2011. It’s a third of the price.

To get back to those equivalent levels, assuming no change in the price of the S&P500, gold would have to triple. I like the sound of $5,700/oz gold!

Here are the gold miners relative to gold.

With the plethora of new ways that opened up to get exposure to gold - ETFs, online bullion dealers, CFDs, spread bets and all the rest of it - investors stopped bothering with miners, and who can blame them?

Too much incompetence, too many frauds, too much political and environmental risk - and all the rest of it.

They’ve been falling since 2003.

Chart showing the price of HUI

But they stopped falling in 2015. Since then they’ve gone sideways. They are, as the technicians say, “building cause”.

I reckon the low is in. It came in 2015. And we re-tested it last year.

What do you think?

Dominic Frisby

Dominic Frisby (“mercurially witty” – the Spectator) is, we think, the world’s only financial writer and comedian. He is the author of the popular newsletter the Flying Frisby and is MoneyWeek’s main commentator on gold, commodities, currencies and cryptocurrencies. 

His books are Daylight Robbery - How Tax Changed our Past and Will Shape our Future; Bitcoin: the Future of Money? and Life After the State - Why We Don't Need Government. 

Dominic was educated at St Paul's School, Manchester University and the Webber-Douglas Academy Of Dramatic Art. You can follow him on X @dominicfrisby