Around 60,000 savers claimed a tax refund in 2023/24 after being overcharged on pension withdrawals, according to figures obtained by financial services firm Royal London.
Many savers were entitled to thousands of pounds, with 11,700 pensioners claiming back £5,000 or more. Around 2,400 claimed back more than £10,000, with some of the largest claims coming to more than £100,000.
MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
HMRC will usually set things straight at the end of the tax year without you having to do anything – however there are steps you can take to get your money back more quickly, or to avoid being overcharged by a large amount in the first place. We take a closer look.
How much emergency tax could you be charged?
Imagine you withdrew £40,000 from your pension. How much emergency tax could you be charged?
If you took the money through an Uncrystallised Funds Pension Lump Sum (UFPLS) arrangement, £10,000 would be tax-free and the remaining £30,000 would be subject to income tax. This is because you are entitled to take up to 25% of your pension pot as tax-free cash.
“If this were treated on an emergency tax basis, this would come to £11,879 in tax,” said Helen Morrissey, head of retirement analysis at Hargreaves Lansdown. As introduced previously, this is because HMRC has assumed you are going to withdraw the same amount every month and is taxing it accordingly.
“As a result, the income tax payment is calculated using 1/12th of your personal allowance, 1/12th of your basic-rate tax allowance and 1/12th of your higher-rate allowance. The remainder is taxed at additional tax rates,” Morrissey said.
Using an emergency tax calculator can help you work out how much you could be charged on your first taxable pension withdrawal.
LCP partner and former pensions minister Steve Webb has called for the whole system to be “simplified and made more predictable” for people drawing on their pensions.
“This is a system designed for the convenience of the tax office, not the taxpayer,” he said. “Given that most people in retirement pay tax at the basic rate, it would not be difficult to have a system which got things right for most people most of the time, rather than making overtaxing people part of business as usual.”
Will HMRC reforms reduce overtaxation?
HMRC updated its system from April this year to move savers onto the correct tax code more quickly. Despite this, limitations mean the changes will only improve things for those taking a regular income. Those who make a one-off withdrawal will continue to be overtaxed.
Some experts believe the changes do not go far enough.
“We have only just blown out the candles on the cake celebrating 10 years of pension freedoms,” said Tom Selby, director of public policy at investment platform AJ Bell. “It is simply unacceptable that after all this time, the government has still not managed to adapt the tax system to cope with the fact Brits are able to access their pensions flexibly from age 55.”
Thankfully, there are some steps savers can take to reduce the impact of a shock tax deduction. For example, experts often recommend making a small withdrawal first. HMRC should then apply a more appropriate tax code to any subsequent larger withdrawals.
Taxpayers who find themselves submitting a reclaim form for a large amount of money may not have been aware of this tip.
For example, some of the savers highlighted by Royal London reclaimed more than £100,000 in overpaid tax in 2023/24. To generate an emergency bill of this size, they would need to have withdrawn more than £300,000 when first accessing their pension.
Savers do ultimately get this money back from HMRC. Even if they don’t actively claim it, things should get settled up automatically at the end of the tax year. Despite this, delays (or alternatively form filling) can be inconvenient and disrupt your immediate plans.
“Suddenly, that large chunk of money which had been earmarked for something special, like a new kitchen or the holiday of a lifetime, has shrunk considerably, and in some cases these plans may have to be postponed or abandoned altogether,” said Clare Moffat, pension expert at Royal London.
“If these withdrawals are being made to help children or grandchildren get a foot on the housing ladder, then the effect can be to derail a home purchase at the last minute when it’s discovered that the money required to complete the purchase has suddenly been eroded.”
How to claim a pension tax refund
If you are taking a regular stream of income through pension drawdown, you shouldn’t need to do anything. HMRC should adjust your tax code throughout the year to ensure you have paid the correct amount of tax overall.
If you make a one-off, ad hoc withdrawal, you can submit a form to reclaim the overpaid tax. This is usually refunded within 30 days. You will need to select one of three forms:
- P55: Choose this one if you have only accessed part of your pension pot.
- P53Z: Choose this one if you have emptied your pension pot, and are still working or receiving benefits.
- P50Z: Choose this one if you have emptied your pot, but are no longer working or receiving benefits.
These forms can be found on the government website.
Otherwise, you can wait for HMRC to set things right at the end of the tax year, when they should automatically refund you any overpayment. It is always worth double-checking this has been done correctly rather than just relying on the taxman.
-
What is the 25x retirement rule and does it work?The 25x retirement rule has been around for decades but many experts question if it is a suitable strategy
-
When is the self-assessment tax return deadline?If you are self-employed, rent out a property or earn income from savings or investments, you may need to complete a self-assessment tax return. We run through the deadlines you need to know about
-
When is the self-assessment tax return deadline?
If you are self-employed, rent out a property or earn income from savings or investments, you may need to complete a self-assessment tax return. We run through the deadlines you need to know about
-
Child Benefit: how it works, eligibility criteria and how to claimChild Benefit is worth hundreds of pounds per year and claiming it can help build up your state pension entitlement. We look at who is eligible and how to get the payment
-
HMRC warning after scammers target 170k taxpayers – how to stay protectedScammers are using increasingly sophisticated methods to trick people into sharing personal details or paying for fake self assessment tax refunds
-
HMRC rewarded tax informants with £850,000 as record fraud tip-offs sent to taxman last yearThe taxman was tipped off about 164,670 cases of alleged fraud last year, but total rewards given to snoops fell in the 2024/5 tax year.
-
Inheritance tax investigations catch out 1200 more families in HMRC crackdownWhere there is a suspicion inheritance tax has been underpaid, HMRC has extensive powers to check the deceased individual’s financial affairs and chase what is owed. Will you pay more?
-
Do you still have to file a tax return if you don’t owe any tax?Even if you do not owe the taxman any money, failure to complete and submit your tax return could result in a penalty costing you up to £1,600.
-
Tax return: HMRC’s payments on account deadline is approaching – here is why it is unfair for the self-employedSelf-assessment taxpayers have just under a week to pay the latest instalment of their tax return, but is the charge fair? Marc Shoffman explains why this is hurting self-employed people
-
HMRC crackdown on workers who earn extra income comes into force - what tax do you need to pay?New rules have come into effect allowing the taxman to get a closer look at the extra income people are making through selling items online or renting out properties on Airbnb. We explain what it may mean for your tax bill.
