Why negative interest rates are a lousy idea

The Bank of England’s governor says negative interest rates can encourage investment rather than having cash stashed in the bank. But is that really true?

The economy is relapsing, says The Observer. The Bank of England has pumped £300bn of quantitative easing into the system this year, but as the second wave of Covid-19 gathers pace all the signs are that it is not enough. UK consumer price inflation was just 0.2% in August and banks have tightened lending criteria. 

That means that it’s time for negative interest rates. The Bank’s governor, Andrew Bailey, says evidence from Europe shows negative rates can encourage corporations to invest rather than just stashing cash in the bank. Right now, the economy “needs all the help it can get”. UK interest rates currently sit at 0.1%, with financial markets pricing in a shift into negative territory next year. The Bank of England is conducting preparatory work, with Bailey describing the policy as being in the “toolbox”.  

The Bank would use the rate to penalise commercial banks that deposit excess reserves with the central bank, says The Times. It wants them to lend the money instead. Banks would probably avoid passing on negative rates directly to depositors and those with mortgages should not anticipate a payday. The policy would “probably be a mistake”. Lenders want their money back and in a steep downturn there are fewer creditworthy borrowers around. When the economy is weak no amount of interest-rate prodding will make the banks lend more. 

Negative interest rates punish the thrifty 

These are bad times to be a saver, says The Economist. America’s one-year Treasury bill, a traditional way of storing cash, yields just 0.13%. “It would take more than 530 years” to double your money by reinvesting that interest. Today’s savers have three options: save less and spend more; save more to compensate for lower returns; or put their cash into riskier investments, such as shares. Central bankers generally assume that lower interest rates cause the first reaction, but the data is much less clear. As is “already happening in Japan”, the old increasingly “risk running out of money before they die”.  

Negative interest rates are a “terrible idea, smacking of desperation”, says Liam Halligan in The Daily Telegraph. They are also “deeply counter-productive”. Pension funds are forced into “risky, speculative investments” in a desperate hunt for yield. The experience on the continent shows that banks avoid cutting interest rates on deposits, thus weakening their balance sheets and making the whole financial system more fragile. The winners are those with a vested interest in seeing “massively bloated” stock and bond markets surge even higher. The economy is already in a “ghastly situation”, we don’t need to make it “even worse”.

(• Listen to our podcast on negative interest rates here).

Recommended

I wish I knew what negative interest rates were, but I’m too embarrassed to ask
Too embarrassed to ask

I wish I knew what negative interest rates were, but I’m too embarrassed to ask

There’s been a lot of talk from the Bank of England recently about introducing “negative interest rates”. So what on earth are they, and what would th…
20 Oct 2020
Negative interest rates and the end of free bank accounts
Bank accounts

Negative interest rates and the end of free bank accounts

Negative interest rates are likely to mean the introduction of fees for current accounts and other banking products. But that might make the UK bankin…
19 Oct 2020
How to prepare your business for Brexit
Small business

How to prepare your business for Brexit

Whether we have a Brexit deal or not, new procedures for importers and exporters will apply from 1 January. Get your business ready now.
27 Nov 2020
Are central banks about to start targeting house prices?
House prices

Are central banks about to start targeting house prices?

New Zealand’s finance minister has suggested expanding the remit of its central bank to include an oversight of house prices. John Stepek explains why…
27 Nov 2020

Most Popular

The next 20 years: five new technologies on the horizon
Global Economy

The next 20 years: five new technologies on the horizon

What will everyday life be like in two decades’ time? Matthew Partridge peers into his crystal ball.
12 Nov 2020
This week’s rally in value stocks is just the beginning
Value investing

This week’s rally in value stocks is just the beginning

The arrival of a vaccine this week saw huge gains in the markets and investors switching out of big-tech growth stocks and into “value” stocks in more…
13 Nov 2020
Share tips of the week
Share tips

Share tips of the week

MoneyWeek’s comprehensive guide to the best of this week’s share tips from the rest of the UK's financial pages.
13 Nov 2020