Fertiliser is back in demand – here’s how to profit

Farming is not a business you normally associate with the pinstripe-suited cut and thrust of international mergers and acquisitions.

Yet one of the busiest areas for takeover deals this year so far has been the fertiliser sector. Already around $10bn worth of deals have “been thrashed out in the fertiliser market,” reports the FT’s Lex column. The latest is Norwegian group Yara International’s $4.1bn purchase of US rival Terra Industries.

So why is this happening now? And more importantly, how can you profit from it?

The fertiliser market is booming

Yara International is the world’s largest listed fertiliser maker. And it’s about to get bigger after taking over US rival Terra Industries. One reason that Yara wants Terra is to secure its access to US natural gas supplies. Natural gas is one of the key ingredients of nitrogen fertiliser. With everyone getting excited about America’s reserves of shale gas, having access to the area’s reserves makes sense.

But it’s just one of many deals done in the sector since the start of this year. Mining giant Vale is buying $3.8bn-worth of Brazilian assets from US group Bunge. And BHP Billiton has spent $320m on potash assets in Canada, and looks set to spend $3bn more over the next ten years, reckons Lex.

We’ve been fans of fertiliser companies for a while. We most recently wrote about the subject in a MoneyWeek magazine cover story on farming: Grow your profits on a farm. (If you’re not already a subscriber to the magazine, subscribe to MoneyWeek magazine.) Why? Because the agricultural commodities story has very strong fundamentals. As Lex points out, by the middle of this century “the world will probably have an extra 3bn mouths to feed.” That’s a lot of extra demand for food. And supply will be hard-pushed to keep up. In the short-term, that’s likely to push up food and crop prices.

A potential short-term play

You could play this by betting directly on soft commodities. As well as spreadbetting, you can trade softs using various exchange-traded commodities (ETCs), issued by providers such as ETF Securities. These track the prices of commodities from grains to cotton. But you must understand how commodity ETFs work. They aren’t straightforward instruments. If the words contango, backwardation and roll yield are foreign territory to you, you should study the products before trying to use them. We wrote about some of the complexities of commodity ETFs in a recent cover story on exchange-traded funds: All you need to know about exchange-traded funds.


Special FREE report from MoneyWeek magazine: When will house prices bottom out – and how will you know?

  • Why UK property prices are going to fall 50%
  • When it will be time to get back in and buy up half price property

In any case, betting directly on commodity prices can only ever be a short-term play. As we’ve noted in the past, high commodity prices cannot last indefinitely. A solution must be found to high food prices. If the supply of food is so restricted that people can’t eat, then they’ll starve. That provides a pretty serious incentive to deal with food shortages.

So what are the potential solutions? Finding new land isn’t as easy as it might sound. As Lex points out, “environmental concerns will limit the clearing of new farm land, so increasing yields from existing fields is critical.” There are all sorts of innovations in the pipeline such as vertical farming and urban farming (which forms the latest plan to regenerate Detroit, as we noted in the current issue of MoneyWeek: Can farming save Detroit?). But these are way off in the future, and may come to nothing.

Why you should be backing fertilisers

So the best bet is to back the companies that can help farmers make better, more productive use of the land we do have, such as fertiliser firms. Fertiliser companies had a tough time in 2009 when overcapacity and lower demand pushed down fertiliser prices. But now it looks as though demand is recovering.

Seasonally, the early part of the year has also often proved to be a good time to buy fertiliser stocks in the past. Broadpoint AmTech analyst Edlain Rodriguez tells Reuters: “We are in the sweet spot of owning fertiliser stocks as we head into the seasonally strong spring season.” One of our favourite stocks, fertiliser giant Potash Corp (TSX: POT) has outperformed the S&P 500 by an average 12 percentage points between January and April over the past six years, he points out.

There’s also likely to be more merger activity in the fertiliser sector. The enlarged Yara will still only account for 8% of the world ammonia market. So there’s plenty of room for more deals to be done. But picking and choosing which companies will be targets and which will be predators isn’t easy. What we’d suggest is sticking with any fertiliser companies you already hold and don’t worry about second-guessing who’ll be trying to do deals with who.

One interesting alternative play could be a company which supplies the fertiliser producers – Canada-listed Chemtrade (TSX: CHE.UN). The group is one of the world’s biggest suppliers of sulphuric acid, which is a key raw material in phosphate fertilisers. We first tipped it back in May 2009. It’s recovered sharply since then, rebounding 74%. However, it’s still well below its 2008 high. With demand in the sector set to remain solid long term, it’s a hold if you’ve got it, and worth getting into if you haven’t.

Our recommended article for today

How a weak euro could derail China

The problems in Greece and other indebted countries of the eurozone don’t bode well for the euro. But the trouble won’t end there, says Merryn Somerset Webb. China’s much-trumpeted growth could also be under threat from a weakened euro. Here, she explains why.

  • doctorfu

    I note your comments on Commodity ETF’s / Contango and Canadian Potash mining outfits and wondered whether there is a better way to play this and similar commodities via a fund / ETF which invests primarily in the producers of the comodity, rather than the comodity itself.

    Is there any chance that you wizards at Moneyweek could investigate this ? Doctorfu

  • Alex

    Just taken a look at the 5 year chart for POT. Looks good.

    Also being $ denominated there might be some nice FX upside if the £ continues to weaken versus the $.

  • Roger

    To Doctorfu,

    Apart from POT, there is also CMP, being a pure American salt/fertilizer company, it performed much better than POT in the last 6 months.

    Tell you a simple observation, in term of resources, Australia, US and Russian companies perform much better than Canadians. For unknown reason, Canadian companies recently have that air of laggards written all over their face, mysterious, maybe because of currency movements?

  • Bernard CYT

    What about fertilizers players in China? Like China Blue Chem, Sinofert, and XLX Fertilizers? Will they do better by any chance since they are located in the worlds most populated country?

  • Michael Lewis

    “which invests primarily in the producers of the comodity, rather than the comodity itself.”

    There is an Agri business ETF AGRP.L by ETF Securities. Monsanto, POT, K&S, Syngenta, et al…

  • Adrian Shiner

    Chemtrade has a very good yield of over 9% paid monthly. The bad news is that Chemtrade is NOT traded on the Crest system in the UK and thus inaccessable to UK residents so far as I understand it.

  • John

    why not access the commodities direct through the futures markest? I dont understand why this is never recommended… instead people recommend vehicles which invest in commodities. Cut out the middleman and all the downside that goes along with etfs.

    For example, you can buy cotton 8 months out at a price of 75 cents vs. the current price of 82 cents if you use the futures markets…

66% off newsstand price

12 issues (and much more) for just £12

That’s right. We’ll give you 12 issues of MoneyWeek magazine, complete access to our exclusive web articles, our latest wealth building reports and videos as well as our subscriber-only email… for just £12.

That’s just £1 per week for Britain’s best-selling financial magazine.

Click here to take advantage of our offer

Britain is leaving the European Union. Donald Trump is reducing America’s role in global markets. Both will have profound consequences for you as an investor.

MoneyWeek analyses the critical issues facing British investors on a weekly basis. And, unlike other publications, we provide you with the solutions to help you turn a situation to your financial advantage.

Take up our offer today, and we’ll send you three of our most important investment reports:

All three of these reports are yours when you take up our 12 issues for £12 offer today.

MoneyWeek has been advising private British investors on what to do with their money since 2000. Our calls over that period have enabled our readers to both make and save a great deal of money – hence our position as the UK’s most-trusted investment publication.

Click here to subscribe for just £12