The Dow Jones and S&P 500 are diverging

America's Dow and S&P stocks indices are displaying different Elliott wave patterns. John C Burford explains why that matters to traders.

Although my favourite stock index for trading is the Dow, I do keep a close eye on the S&P 500 (and the Nasdaq), because sometimes they display slightly differing Elliott wave patterns.

And this is exactly what has happened in the S&P since the 14 May highs. So today, I will tell you why this is such a significant development.

Subscribe to MoneyWeek

Become a smarter, better informed investor with MoneyWeek.

The Dow and S&P part ways

my 16 May post


The wave 3 appeared correct, because it was long and strong, which is the normal quality for a third wave. It is usually the strongest (in terms of momentum) of the three waves that move in the overall direction of trend.

Advertisement - Article continues below

I was then waiting for the wave 4 to top out before the market descended once again to a new low in the final fifth wave.

But the S&P chart offered a slightly different interpretation. Here is the hourly chart as of this morning:


I have a shorter wave 3 and a long and strong fifth wave. These are called extended fifths and although not common, they do appear more often in the stock indexes than in any other type of market that I follow.

This is an acceptable way to label the big move down. At the wave 5 low, the selling had been overdone and the market started a normal relief rally.

This is a textbook rally

First, it has an A-B-C form with wA equal in height to wC. This is a typical Fibonacci wave relationship between the corrective A and C waves. That is textbook behaviour and illustrates the equality rule of the A and C waves.

In fact, when you see this equality, it adds confidence to your interpretation that this is indeed a relief rally and to expect a resumption of the main down trend.

Advertisement - Article continues below

Second, wave C terminated precisely at the Fibonacci 62% retracement of the entire move down. This is the most common level where C waves turn around. And the hit was made on a pigtail, or spike, on the high bar. Again, all of this is straight out of the textbook.

And yesterday the market fell hard off the C wave high. So now I can place new Elliott wave labels for the larger pattern:


My new wave 1 is the 15 May low and wave 2 is yesterday's C wave high. To confirm this picture, I will need to see a new low below the wave 1 low and out of the congestion zone.

Note the large congestion zone (marked in pink) whose upper limit was breached in the buying exhaustion thrust to the 1900 level. But that was a false breakout and the market soon plunged to test the lower limit of the zone. That is entirely normal behaviour.

And the upper limit of resistance was tested yesterday and was successful in turning the market back with force.

Why were investors flocking to the Dow?


The pattern is very similar, but the Dow has already made a new low below the wave 1 low. This means we are very likely already in the third wave down.

Advertisement - Article continues below

Note how much weaker the Dow is now compared with the S&P. The Dow C wave high terminated only at the Fibonacci 38% level compared with the higher 62% level in the S&P. And now we have a new low in the Dow and not in the S&P.

This is a turn-around from the recent pattern. The Dow has recently seen a flow of funds as investors seek solid dividend-paying companies in a flight from the riskier S&P shares. I believe this is a significant development.

Keeping an eye on the bigger picture


I can draw a lovely wedge, and this morning the market is testing the lower line. A solid break of this line would confirm not only the top, but that we are in the third wave down, which should be long and strong.

This could get very interesting!



Spread betting

Boeing's share price plummets: here's how to play it

Boeing shares have fallen by a third this year. But there could be worse to come. Matthew Partridge explains how traders should play it
10 Feb 2020
Share tips

How my 2019 spreadbetting tips fared

Matthew Partridge reviews performance of his 2019 spreadbetting tips. This year’s winners include Bellway, JD Sports and Taylor Wimpey.
17 Dec 2019
Spread betting

Betting on politics: some safe Labour bets

Matthew Partridge outlines a few flutters on what should be safe Labour seats in the general election.
10 Dec 2019
Spread betting

DS Smith will deliver: here's how to play the share price

Packaging group DS Smith is profiting from the online retail boom. Matthew Partridge explains how traders can play the share price.
3 Dec 2019

Most Popular


Gold is at its highest level in years – here’s how to invest

Gold's rise at a time when the dollar is unnervingly strong isn't unheard of – but it is curious. John Stepek explains what's going on, and what it me…
21 Feb 2020
Stocks and shares

Do you own shares in Sirius Minerals? Here’s what you need to do now

Mining giant Anglo American has proposed a cash takeover of Yorkshire-based minnow Sirius Minerals. Unhappy shareholders must decide whether to accept…
20 Feb 2020
Global Economy

The charts that matter: it’s starting to look a little unhinged out there

Things aren't normal in the markets right now, says John Stepek. Here, he looks at the charts that matter most to the global economy for clues to what…
22 Feb 2020

Why investors shouldn’t overlook Europe

SPONSORED CONTENT - Ollie Beckett, manager of the TR European Growth Trust, tackles investor questions around Europe’s economic outlook and the conseq…
6 Nov 2019