Great frauds in history: Wang Fengyou’s ant-breeding scam

“Model entrepreneur” Wang Fengyou's ant-farming Ponzi scheme pulled in $1.2bn, with investors losing all.

Wang Fengyou was born into poverty in China, but developed an entrepreneurial streak selling potatoes before turning to running a bottling plant, a slaughter-house and a taxi business. In 1999 he founded Yilishen Tianxi Group, which manufactured traditional Chinese remedies, including an aphrodisiac, made from ants. These products were heavily advertised on Chinese television with endorsements from Chinese comedian Zhao Benshan, and Bao Xishun, China’s tallest man. The apparent success of the company won him a stream of awards, including a “model entrepreneur” award from the government, and he was photographed with many prominent officials, including the now disgraced Bo Xilai.

What was the scam?

From 2001 Wang offered “investors”, mainly peasants who had received compensation for losing their land to development, the chance to earn large returns from ant farming. Investors got three boxes of “special” ants from his company for ¥10,000 ($1,600) and, for feeding them until they died, the firm would buy them back for a return of around 32.5% over 14 months. In reality, the firm was never legitimately profitable – it was a Ponzi scheme, with new investors’ money going to pay those who had invested previously. Large amounts were spent on gifts to officials.

What happened next?

In 2004 the US Food and Drug Administration banned Yilishen’s products from America on the basis that they contained active ingredients found in Viagra. This forced the company to abandon plans to float on the Hong Kong stock exchange and sales fell. In response, Wang stepped up recruitment for his scheme, but by 2007 investors’ money had run out, leading to protests involving 200,000 people. The authorities stepped in and arrested Wang. He was made to confess to organising counter-protests and sentenced to death; many of his managers were given prison sentences.

Lessons for investors

Estimates of the numbers of those conned vary, but the scheme may have collected as much as $1.2bn. Despite official promises of compensation, investors got little or no money back and the police harassed and arrested those who complained. Endorsements from local politicians are never a guarantee of a scheme’s trustworthiness, especially in emerging markets where transparency and the rule of law may be limited.

Recommended

Inflation, energy crisis, strikes – have we gone back to the 1970s?
Investment strategy

Inflation, energy crisis, strikes – have we gone back to the 1970s?

Merryn and John talk about rising prices, productivity and the state of the labour market, plus are bond investors really the adults in the room, and …
15 Oct 2021
Why actively managed funds don’t outperform in bear markets
Funds

Why actively managed funds don’t outperform in bear markets

The idea that active funds should outperform in bear markets is logical and compelling. Sadly it’s also wrong
15 Oct 2021
Inflation isn’t transitory – but what does that mean for markets?
Inflation

Inflation isn’t transitory – but what does that mean for markets?

With US inflation at its highest for 13 years and prices rising fast around the world, markets have come to realise that this is no longer “transitory…
14 Oct 2021
Will silver finally realise its potential? I’ve no idea – but I’ve just bought a load
Silver and other precious metals

Will silver finally realise its potential? I’ve no idea – but I’ve just bought a load

For investors, silver is incredibly frustrating. It has more potential than almost any other metal, but that potential is never realised. So why has D…
13 Oct 2021

Most Popular

Why the world’s most important economic data release has unnerved markets
US Economy

Why the world’s most important economic data release has unnerved markets

The US added only 194,000 jobs in September, far shorter than the 500,000 that were expected. John Stepek explains why markets didn't react as they no…
11 Oct 2021
How to invest in SMRs – the future of green energy
Energy

How to invest in SMRs – the future of green energy

The UK’s electricity supply needs to be more robust for days when the wind doesn’t blow. We need nuclear power, says Dominic Frisby. And the future of…
6 Oct 2021
Inflation is still one of the biggest threats to your personal finances
Investment strategy

Inflation is still one of the biggest threats to your personal finances

Central bankers and economists insist inflation will be gone by next year. We're not so sure, says Merryn Somerset Webb. So if you haven’t started to …
1 Oct 2021