Elizabeth Bigley was born in Ontario, Canada in 1857. In 1879 she was arrested for forgery for passing off worthless cheques to merchants, but was acquitted on grounds of her age and insanity. She later worked in Cleveland, Ohio as a psychic, calling herself Madame Lydia DeVere. In 1889 she was again arrested and this time convicted of forgery and spent several years in prison before being pardoned by the then governor of Ohio (later President) William McKinley in 1893. By 1897 she was back in Cleveland, living under an assumed name, with her new husband Dr Leroy Chadwick. He married her believing her to be the illegitimate daughter of wealthy industrialist Andrew Carnegie.
What was the scam?
The now Mrs Chadwick claimed that Carnegie felt so guilty about not publicly acknowledging her as his daughter that he was willing to give her large amounts of money. After exhausting her husband’s fortune, she persuaded several local banks and wealthy individuals to lend her money. As collateral, she provided promissory notes signed with Carnegie’s name and an unopened package supposedly containing a trust fund of $7.5m ($207m in today’s money) in railroad shares and bonds. In reality, Carnegie was unaware of her existence and the notes were forgeries. The money funded an extravagant lifestyle, which enabled her to borrow even more.
What happened next?
Her generosity with money won her many admirers, but her creditors grew anxious and, by November 1904, banker Herbert Newton sued for repayment of a $190,000 ($5.63m) loan. Carnegie disowned both her and the notes, and her railroad bonds and shares were found to be worthless. Early in 1905 she was arrested carrying $100,000 in cash and sentenced to several years in jail, where she died.
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Lessons for investors
Estimates suggest Chadwick may have borrowed as much as $1.3m ($29.6m) backed by $12m ($355m) in forged Carnegie notes. Her creditors recovered only a fraction of this. The Citizens’ National Bank, which had loaned $240,000 ($7.1m), was forced into liquidation after its depositors withdrew their money, demonstrating the importance of doing proper due diligence. Even if Chadwick had been a genuine heiress, it was an incredibly irresponsible decision to lend a sum that was four times the bank’s actual capital to a single person.
-
Should you invest in UK equities?The FTSE 100 hit a record high this week, but UK equities remain unloved and undervalued compared to their global and US peers. Should you snap them up at a discount?
-
State pension errors: DWP urged to check for mistakes among divorced peopleFormer pensions minister Steve Webb says there are a high number of divorced women on low state pensions. Now MPs want the DWP to check if there were any errors in “potentially underpaying men and women who are divorced”.
-
Should your business invest in a VoIP phone service?Here's what you need to know about VOIP (voice over IP) services before landlines go digital in 2025.
-
The end of China’s boomLike the US, China too got fat on fake money. Now, China's doom is not far away.
-
The many frauds of Dozy Mmobuosi, failed Sheffield United ownerProfile Dozy Mmobuosi was a big-hitter with a fintech empire when he stepped in to rescue a failing Yorkshire football club. But he was not quite the saviour he seemed.
-
What is the future of Royal Mail in the UK?With fewer of us sending letters and parcels, the Royal Mail is finding dealing with the nation’s post is an increasingly unprofitable and costly business.
-
What's the secret of Manolo Blahnik's success?Fashion maestro Manolo Blahnik shows little sign of slowing down at 81, and his company notched up a record financial year in 2022. What is the secret of his success?
-
Michelle Mone's "tough year of pain"Michelle Mone liked to portray herself as a working-class heroine who worked her way to the top through grit and determination. But her pedestal is built on sand.
-
Trevor Milton, the Elon Musk wannabe, is jailed for fraudThe former CEO of Nikola, Trevor Milton, has been found guilty of lying about the development of the company's electric trucks.
-
Directors should think twice before waiving limited liabilityShould small-business directors ever provide a personal guarantee in return for bank finance?
