Great frauds in history: Helmut Kiener, Germany’s mini-Madoff

The performance of Helmut Kiener’s fund of funds, which invested money from institutions and private investors into hedge funds, seemed too good to be true. It was.

Helmut Kiener (pictured) was born in the German town of Wernberg in 1959. After studying statistics at a local technical college, and doing his national service, he studied at various universities, eventually graduating with a diploma in psychology. After briefly working as a social researcher, in 1988 he set up an investment fund, Kiener Company (later named K1 Group), with his friend Dieter Frerichs. This “fund of funds” used money raised from institutional and private investors to invest in other hedge funds, based on their past performance.

What was the scam?

Kiener claimed that his investment criteria would enable K1 to select funds that would continue to beat the market. In reality, most of the funds that he selected were shell companies, with the money either returning to the main fund in order to pay off past investors, or used to enable Kiener to buy luxury homes and aircraft. Some of the cash was siphoned off into overseas bank accounts. To convince investors to stick with the fund, he falsely claimed the fund had posted a cumulative return of 855% between 1996 and 2009.

What happened next?

As early as 2002, German regulators were demanding that the fund be shut down due to a lack of official documentation. In response, Kiener simply re-registered the fund in the British Virgin Islands. In the summer of 2008, however, his major institutional investors started to demand the return of their money. In 2009 investigators at JPMorgan, who had taken over Bear Stearns, one of Kiener’s investors, spotted irregularities and complained to the authorities, who shut him down. Despite claiming that he was immune from prosecution as a diplomat for the African country of Guinea-Bissau, Kiener was eventually sentenced to more than ten years in jail.

Lessons for investors

At the fund’s peak in 2008, Kiener claimed that the fund had assets of around $900m, though actual investor losses have been put at around $500m. He was dubbed “Germany’s mini-Madoff” by the press. Amazingly, much of the money flowed after the original attempts to shut the fund down were widely reported in the media. As with Bernie Madoff’s Ponzi scheme, the stability of the fund’s performance should have been a big red flag. It had reported only a handful of losing months between December 2002 and August 2009.

Most Popular

The MoneyWeek Podcast: Asia, financial repression and the nature of capitalism
Economy

The MoneyWeek Podcast: Asia, financial repression and the nature of capitalism

Russell Napier talks to Merryn about financial repression – or "stealing money from old people slowly" – plus how Asian capitalism is taking over in t…
16 Jul 2021
The future belongs to emerging markets – three EM stocks to buy now
Share tips

The future belongs to emerging markets – three EM stocks to buy now

Professional investor Carlos von Hardenberg of Mobius Capital Partners picks three of his favourite emerging-market stocks.
5 Jul 2021
Three companies that are reaping the rewards of investment
Share tips

Three companies that are reaping the rewards of investment

Professional investor Edward Wielechowski of the Odyssean Investment Trust highlights three stocks that have have invested well – and are able to deal…
19 Jul 2021