Great Frauds in History: Robert Schuyler’s illicit share issue

Robert Schuyler was known as “America’s first railroad king” issued millions of dollars' worth of fraudulent shares in his company, and kept the money, fleeing to France when his scam was exposed.

Robert Schuyler was born in Rhinebeck, New York in 1798, the grandson of American general Phillip Schuyler and nephew of the treasury secretary, Alexander Hamilton. After graduating from Harvard he moved into steamboats, becoming president of the New York and Boston Transportation Company in 1838. In 1846 he founded R. & G. L. Schuyler, which invested in railroads. His career progressed rapidly and he soon became a major figure in the American rail industry: he was president of several railroads and involved with many others. As a result he became known as “America’s first railroad king”.

How did the scam work?

In 1848 he was appointed president of the New York and New Haven Railroad, as well at its sole transfer agent, which meant that he was in charge of keeping the shareholders’ register up to date to reflect share transactions. He took advantage of this to issue 19,540 shares in the group without informing shareholders or the directors. Schuyler then diverted the $2m ($56.9m today) raised in this way from the company’s treasury, instead using it as collateral for loans intended to shore up other parts of his business empire. He then falsified the accounts to conceal his activities.

What happened next?

In 1853 one of the New York and New Haven railroad’s trains crashed into Norwalk Harbour, killing 50 people. Complaints that Schuyler had spread himself too thinly meant that he had to resign several of his presidencies. However, it was not until the summer of 1854 that a sudden plunge in the value of New York and New Haven’s shares finally prompted the board to investigate, prompting Schuyler to flee, eventually to France, and confess his guilt. Schuyler would die in November 1855 from the combined effects of illness and guilt about his own behaviour.

Lessons for investors

After a long legal battle, the US Supreme Court ruled that the company had to honour the shares, costing the company around $1.8m. The wider impact of the scandal resulted in the bankruptcy of several small brokerages, as well as a fall in the share price of other railroads Schuyler had been involved with. These days most major stock exchanges require share transfers to take place through a centralised system, making sales of unauthorised shares practically impossible, although the practice can still occur with shares in small private companies.

Recommended

I wish I knew what contagion was, but I’m too embarrassed to ask
Too embarrassed to ask

I wish I knew what contagion was, but I’m too embarrassed to ask

Most of us probably know what “contagion” is in a biological sense. But it also crops up in financial markets. Here's what it means.
21 Sep 2021
What to invest in to beat soaring energy prices
Investment strategy

What to invest in to beat soaring energy prices

As gas and electricity prices hit the roof, John Stepek explains how to invest to offset higher energy bills.
21 Sep 2021
Are Spacs just for suckers?
Investment strategy

Are Spacs just for suckers?

This year has seen a big boom in activity by special purpose acquisition companies (Spacs) in the US and the Spac craze is spreading to other markets…
21 Sep 2021
The end of the bond bull market, and how to invest for it
Investment strategy

The end of the bond bull market, and how to invest for it

The great bond bull market looks to be over, and you probably don’t want to be holding government bonds, says Merryn Somerset Webb. Here’s what you sh…
21 Sep 2021

Most Popular

The times may be changing, but don’t change how you invest
Small cap stocks

The times may be changing, but don’t change how you invest

We are living in strange times. But the basics of investing remain the same: buy fairly-priced stocks that can provide an income. And there are few be…
13 Sep 2021
Two shipping funds to buy for steady income
Investment trusts

Two shipping funds to buy for steady income

Returns from owning ships are volatile, but these two investment trusts are trying to make the sector less risky.
7 Sep 2021
How to stop recurring subscriptions becoming a drain on your money
Personal finance

How to stop recurring subscriptions becoming a drain on your money

Tracking and pruning subscriptions isn’t as easy as it sounds. Here's how to take charge.
14 Sep 2021