“Germany is struggling,” say Kevin Fletcher, Harri Kemp and Galen Sher in an IMF blog. The world’s third-largest economy was the only G7 member to contract last year and looks set to be the group’s slowest-growing economy again this year.
Still, the idea that an economic model built on manufacturing and cheap Russian gas is “irreparably broken” is overstating things. Wholesale gas prices have now returned to 2018 levels. The chemicals, metals and paper industries were hit hard by the energy crisis, but they only account for 4% of the economy. Electric vehicle (EV) exports rose 60% last year – VW and BMW alone account for over 10% of global EV sales.
Germany's economy
Germany is still running a trade surplus equivalent to 4.3% of GDP – above the average of the last two decades and hardly the sign of a declining industrial power. While industries like chemicals decline, high-value-added activities – especially in research and development – aren’t going anywhere, Robin Winkler of Deutsche Bank tells Jonathan Packroff for Euractiv.
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
That said, a “second year of near-recession” is taking its toll, says Packroff. Insolvencies rose 41% in the first half of the year, an unusual trend in a country that rebounded quickly from shocks such as the 2008 crisis. Things should improve as the global trade cycle turns, says Martin Wolf in the Financial Times. But deeper structural problems are becoming a source of concern.
The ageing population will see growth in the German labour force lag other G7 members for the rest of this decade. Deglobalisation raises acute questions for Germany’s export-based economic model and the country is woefully behind in digitalisation. In the UK we complain about creaking infrastructure because public investment has been a measly 3% of GDP in recent years – but in Germany it has been even lower, at 2.5%.
Germany's stock market
Germany’s stock market lacks “breadth” compared with European peers – smaller, family-owned companies tend not to list, leaving Frankfurt the preserve of large-cap multinationals, says Jan Schildbach in a Deutsche Bank Research note. Dax-listed companies earn more than 80% of revenues outside Germany.
But for all the gloom, investors should remember that “European equity performance has been far better than economic performance”. On a total return basis (including dividends), the Dax has returned nearly 6% a year since early 2007, beating the UK and French markets (both 5.5%) over the same period.
That’s thanks to Germany’s slightly higher weighting towards the technology sector. Since 2013, German initial public offerings (IPOs) have raised the most capital of any European market except for London. Often maligned, German stocks are arguably Europe’s “hidden champion”.
This article was first published in MoneyWeek's magazine. Enjoy exclusive early access to news, opinion and analysis from our team of financial experts with a MoneyWeek subscription.
-
Dividends: Reliability in uncertain timesDividends have formed over half of the total return of the UK market over the last 20 years. Dividend strategies have been under-appreciated while investors have focused on US mega cap technology. Income strategies may have more appeal in a tougher investment climate
-
Trump’s tariffs: what is he thinking and how should UK respond?Every right-thinking person knows that free trade is a surer route to the wealth of nations than protectionism, says Stuart Watkins. What is Trump thinking?
-
Will Putin invade Europe? Why investors know Russia is a paper tigerOpinion Markets are right to ignore talk of Putin invading Europe, says Max King.
-
Why French far-right leader Marine Le Pen has been banned from running for officeMarine Le Pen, presidential candidate and leader of France's right-wing National Rally party, has been barred from standing by the country's judges.
-
Five years on: what did Covid cost us?We’re still counting the costs of the global coronavirus pandemic – and governments’ responses. What did we learn?
-
Protests erupt in Turkey after the arrest of president Erdogan's rivalTurkey's president has jailed his main political opponent, Ekrem Imamoglu
-
Can investors stay optimistic about Russian stocks?Investors look to profit from Russia as Trump pushes for peace in Ukraine. But is it worth the risk?
-
Friedrich Merz proposes 'radical' spending package for GermanyGermany's chancellor designate Friedrich Merz wants to scrap restraints on borrowing and allow for much higher defence spending
-
Volodymyr Zelenskyy moves to appease Donald Trump – what happens now?Ukraine’s president Volodymyr Zelenskyy is conceding ground to secure the least-worst deal possible, says Emily Hohler
-
It’s time to start buying Europe again, says Merryn Somerset WebbOpinion Europe's stocks are cheap and the economic backdrop is starting to look cheerier, says Merryn Somerset Webb
