Earnings estimates are a rigged game – especially in the US
The number of US stocks beating earnings estimates tells us only that guidance has deliberately been set too low


Of all the things that Donald Trump could claim are “rigged” against him, the number of jobs being added in the US economy is one of the oddest. Yes, there are real problems with statistics in many countries, and the situation has got worse since the pandemic. Firing the head of the statistics agency, as Trump did last week, is unlikely to fix that, especially if the replacement is picked for loyalty to him. However, the 258,000 cut to the estimated jobs added in May and June is completely in line with what you’d expect once in a while.
Data like these are prone to big revisions, sometimes long after they are first reported. One difficulty in trying to spot turning points in the economy using trends from past data is that the revised numbers we have now can sometimes be quite different from those reported at the time. Much of the information that statistics agencies collect is important in trying to understand long-term trends. But they are not reliable real-time signals. Investors, like Trump, could afford to take each release a little less seriously.
Earnings estimates are transparently biased
In fact, the prize for the most manipulated statistic in markets surely goes not to a government department, but to the private sector. Earnings estimates – and the ability of companies to beat them – are transparently a rigged game, especially in the US. If analysts’ estimates were an unbiased forecast of earnings, you’d expect companies to beat them 50% of the time and miss 50% of them. This doesn’t happen – on average, companies beat estimates significantly more often.
MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE

Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
The reason is that company management – most blatantly in the US – guide analysts to lower forecasts as the reporting date approaches. They can then report earnings that beat the forecasts, and the positive surprise buoys the share price. However, if you compare reported net income for each quarter to forecasts made further in advance (three months before the quarter), “these ‘surprises’ are somewhat less impressive or not there at all”, says Andrew Lapthorne of Société Générale – see chart above.
Of course, earnings growth matters. Europe or emerging markets look better long-term value than America – but not if S&P 500 earnings keep growing much faster than the rest of the world. If the US continues to excel (which the chart suggests is increasingly a bet on the Magnificent Seven), the S&P 500 might yet come out ahead. But that has little to do with whether companies can beat short-term forecasts that they’ve carefully talked down.
So when the headlines say – as they doing right now – that more than 80% of S&P 500 companies are beating estimates, it is wise to be a bit sceptical. Does this mean that the corporate sector and the US economy is doing even better than expected; or does it suggest that the upheaval as Trump brought in his tariffs in April proved an excellent opportunity to guide down earnings aggressively and ensure a solid surprise?
This article was first published in MoneyWeek's magazine. Enjoy exclusive early access to news, opinion and analysis from our team of financial experts with a MoneyWeek subscription.
Get the latest financial news, insights and expert analysis from our award-winning MoneyWeek team, to help you understand what really matters when it comes to your finances.
Cris Sholto Heaton is an investment analyst and writer who has been contributing to MoneyWeek since 2006 and was managing editor of the magazine between 2016 and 2018. He is especially interested in international investing, believing many investors still focus too much on their home markets and that it pays to take advantage of all the opportunities the world offers. He often writes about Asian equities, international income and global asset allocation.
Cris began his career in financial services consultancy at PwC and Lane Clark & Peacock, before an abrupt change of direction into oil, gas and energy at Petroleum Economist and Platts and subsequently into investment research and writing. In addition to his articles for MoneyWeek, he also works with a number of asset managers, consultancies and financial information providers.
He holds the Chartered Financial Analyst designation and the Investment Management Certificate, as well as degrees in finance and mathematics. He has also studied acting, film-making and photography, and strongly suspects that an awareness of what makes a compelling story is just as important for understanding markets as any amount of qualifications.
-
112 funds that financial experts are backing for success
Wealth manager Evelyn Partners has identified the top funds for each region to help investors protect their wealth from the chancellor ahead of the Autumn Budget
-
The rise of the drones
Unmanned aerial systems, or drones, are regarded as central to modern and future warfare, and soaring defence spending is set to double demand.
-
The rise of the drones
Unmanned aerial systems, or drones, are regarded as central to modern and future warfare, and soaring defence spending is set to double demand.
-
Investors can tap into juicy yields in overlooked companies’ debt and equity
Opinion Ian “Franco” Francis, fund manager, Manulife CQS New City High Yield Fund tells MoneyWeek where he’d put his money
-
Domino’s Pizza Group: A global brand going cheap
Opinion The troubles at Domino’s Pizza Group look cyclical rather than structural, says Rupert Hargreaves
-
Three poor deals for trust investors
Opinion Small shareholders need protection in related-party deals, says Bruce Packard
-
The challenge with currency hedging
A weaker dollar will make currency hedges more appealing, but volatile rates may complicate the results
-
Prabowo Subianto: Indonesia’s Deng Xiaoping
Prabowo Subianto, like his Chinese hero, is taking power in his 70s with big ambitions for his country. Yet many view his return to politics with dread
-
8 of the best properties for sale with orangeries
From a converted Victorian Catholic school with a chapel in Kingston Upon Thames to a 12-acre country estate with mature gardens and a lake in Nantwich, Cheshire, we look at some of the best properties for sale with orangeries
-
Should you invest in Hansa Investment Company?
William Salomon has finally brought the two trusts he controls together. Should investors buy in?