Germany’s chancellor-in-waiting, Friedrich Merz, is under fire from opposition politicians over his “radical proposals” to relax the so-called debt brake to boost the economy and allow for higher defence spending, says Kate Connolly in The Guardian. The CDU/CSU leader’s proposals, agreed with his potential coalition partners, the Social Democrats, have variously been described as a “bazooka” and an “extremely risky bet”. Merz says they are vital “in light of the threats to our freedom and peace”.
Merz, who is in coalition talks to form a new government, which are expected to run until 24 March, wants to get his plans through the current parliament, where the conservatives and SPD have the necessary two-thirds majority together with the Greens. The far-right AfD, which will have 152 seats in the new parliament, is opposed and has already said it will challenge the decision in court. “A number of other parties have political incentives to push the vote to the brink,” says Deutsche Bank Research. It’s “far from a done deal”.
What does it mean for Germany's economy?
If Merz does succeed, it would be a “big step forward” – for Germany, Europe and the world, says Bloomberg. Introduced by former CDU leader Angela Merkel in 2009, the debt brake was “much more than a mere budget rule”. It reflected Germans’ “deep-seated aversion to borrowing and to the burden-sharing required for a viable European Union”. It has also proved to be “economically disastrous, gutting the kind of productive investment desperately needed to restart growth” in the face of higher energy prices and Chinese competition. The “geopolitical chaos” unleashed by Donald Trump has forced Germany’s hand. Faced with the withdrawal of US military support and threat of US tariffs, Merz has come up with an “ambitious fiscal agenda”. Adjustments to the debt brake will allow for much higher defence spending and another €500 billion will be dedicated to a decadal-long fund to invest in the country’s infrastructure.
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Using the outgoing German parliament to lead the country into “debt bondage” disregards the will of voters and will “accelerate Germany’s economic decline”, says Joachim Nikolaus Steinhöfel in Euronews. It will expand the money supply, “drastically worsen Germany’s credit rating” and encourage other countries in the eurozone to abandon “fiscal discipline” with a knock-on effect on bond markets and interest rates. Short-term, it might stimulate growth, but private investment will be crowded out while the state’s inefficient procurement system will waste billions. Defence spending won’t grow the economy.
On the contrary, many economists would argue that Merz’s spending spree is “just what Germany needs to get itself out of its low-growth malaise”, says Jeremy Warner in The Telegraph. The bigger, long-term question is whether a rearmed Germany will galvanise the country’s “reemergence as an over-mighty, political and economic hegemon at the heart of Europe”. Re-empowering the historic enemy is “surely not” what Vladimir Putin had in mind when he sent his tanks into Ukraine. “Yet this could all too easily be the ultimate outcome.”
This article was first published in MoneyWeek's magazine. Enjoy exclusive early access to news, opinion and analysis from our team of financial experts with a MoneyWeek subscription.
-
These British stocks are a bargain – should you buy?From high street favourites such as Sainsbury’s and Greggs to healthcare firms, these stocks are trading at a heavy discount
-
Ofcom ranks the worst and best companies for broadband and phone servicesBroadband and mobile phone costs were part of the ‘awful April’ bill hikes - but are you getting the most for your money? Ofcom has released its list of the worst and best companies for broadband and mobile phone customer services
-
'Rachel Reeves' plan to force pension funds into UK assets won't work'Opinion Hustling pension fund cash into British assets sounds like a good idea. It would be better to make Britain an attractive place to invest, says Matthew Lynn
-
Supersonic travel: How China could 'leapfrog' US and Europe's commercial aviation industryOpinion Innovation in commercial aviation has been stuck for 60 years. A commercial supersonic jet might be back on the market soon, but will China get there first?
-
How British businesses can tackle Trump's tariffsThe majority of British businesses are likely to take a hit from the chaos caused by Trump’s tariffs to reorder global trade. Companies in the firing line face some difficult decisions, says David Prosser
-
Trump wants to colonise Mars – will it happen?Donald Trump wants to plant the US flag on Mars. Could humans really live there?
-
Why are energy bills so expensive in the UK?Electricity bills in the UK are higher than in any comparable rich country. Some blame the net-zero zealotry of the government for that. What is really to blame for high energy bills?
-
Will Putin invade Europe? Why investors know Russia is a paper tigerOpinion Markets are right to ignore talk of Putin invading Europe, says Max King.
-
Why French far-right leader Marine Le Pen has been banned from running for officeMarine Le Pen, presidential candidate and leader of France's right-wing National Rally party, has been barred from standing by the country's judges.
-
Five years on: what did Covid cost us?We’re still counting the costs of the global coronavirus pandemic – and governments’ responses. What did we learn?
