Inheritance tax: just abolish the entire thing

Why not abolish inheritance tax and replace it with a gift tax on the recipients of unearned cash – wherever it comes from?

Two faaarmers and zum cows © Alamy
Agricultural land: should it really be free of inheritance tax?

Two faaarmers and zum cows © Alamy

Almost everyone hates inheritance tax. It is seen to be the worst of all the double taxations (all money is taxed over and over). It piles needless administration on to grief. It's needlessly complicated (the newish residence nil-rate band being the last straw for many). It comes with enough loopholes that anyone who doesn't find a way to avoid it feels like they aren't trying hard enough to protect their wealth for their children, which keeps them up at night. It isn't particularly fair. But possibly worst of all, the existence of inheritance tax creates a friction that slows the passage of money, businesses and land through the generations.

Advertisement - Article continues below

Those with money don't understand the annual inheritance tax free gifting system £250 here, £1,000 here and maybe no limit if your gifts are out of income. So they give less than they might. Those with businesses that aren't liable to inheritance tax are given an incentive to hold on until death (to avoid paying capital-gains tax if they transfer when they are alive). It's a mess especially given that one thing the UK could really do with is a trickle down of wealth between the generations.

Good news then that the Office of Tax Simplification has produced a new report on how the inheritance tax system might be simplified. There are useful things in it. The idea that one simple (hopefully high!) annual allowance could replace all the silly little ones and possibly the gifts out of income exemption is sensible. A thought on dumping the seven-year rule and the taper within it (tapers are always a nightmare see our blog at for more on the chaos the pensions taper is causing) would work. The plan to look at the huge exemptions from inheritance tax for agricultural property and businesses is good too if we want firms constantly to renew and rejuvenate, the current incentives aren't quite right.

Advertisement - Article continues below

(One aside here for those who invest in Aim stocks with a view to avoiding inheritance tax, be careful. Right now if you hold an eligible Aim-listed stock for two years, it passes on inheritance tax free. This review will consider how the relief works. If it looks like it might be dropped or curtailed the [high] valuations of currently eligible stocks will fall fast.)

But here's the thing: all these things are just tinkering. Not awful tinkering but really no more than tinkering. The UK needs more than that. In an ideal world we'd get a root-and-branch reform of the entire tax system. That's not going to happen. But given that inheritance tax brings in only 1% of the total tax take, we could go for a full reboot, without really risking our tax base.

So why not abolish the entire thing and replace it with a gift tax on the recipients of unearned cash wherever it comes from? It would be fair, progressive, unavoidable and, possibly best of all, low stress for the elderly (the tax becomes the recipient's problem rather than theirs). Perfect. There's more on this at However, you might also turn to our cover story. The rise of personalised medicine is about to revolutionise healthcare and your ideas about how long you will live. Dying with enough cash that our estates are liable for IHT might not turn out to be much of a problem for most of us.

And lastly, a reminder tickets for the MoneyWeek event on 22 November are now on sale. Don't miss it snap up your seat at



Personal finance

Pass on your pension without paying inheritance tax

The 2015 pension reforms make it easier for you to ensure your heirs avoid inheritance tax when you die
29 Jan 2020

What are the best ways of raising more money in tax?

Given that whoever wins next week's election will be going on a massive spending spree, we're going to need to raise at least some of that money throu…
5 Dec 2019
Investment strategy

What are the biggest mistakes investors make when it comes to tax?

The tax implications of an investment are something we rarely consider until after the event. That could prove to be an expensive mistake, says Domini…
27 Nov 2019

How tax has shaped the course of human history

Taxation is as old as civilisation itself. But how much is too much? Dominic Frisby looks at how taxation, war and society have evolved together over …
16 Oct 2019

Most Popular

Investment strategy

How John Maynard Keynes learned the folly of market timing

In an extract from his book The Sceptical Investor, John Stepek explains how the great economist John Maynard Keynes came a cropper when he first star…
25 May 2020
Investment strategy

Are you a permabear? Three red flags to watch out for

Contrarian investors are often seen as bearish because the market tends to go up over time. But if that bearishness goes too deep, you risk seriously …
26 May 2020
Industrial metals

Governments’ money-printing mania bodes well for base metals

Money is being printed like there is no tomorrow. Much of it will be used to pay for infrastructure projects – and that will be good for metals, says …
27 May 2020