We are beginning to wonder rather about pensions freedom. When Chancellor George Osborne first introduced the idea that the obligation for UK pension savers to buy annuities with their money was to go in its entirety, we were impressed. We knew he had been pushed into it by the super-low interest rates that were slamming annuity rates pensions freedom was just another consequence of the crisis.
Were also concerned that retirees would have trouble managing their own money throughout retirement: not everyone wants that sort of responsibility. Still, we love the idea of everyone making their own decisions about their money, and we figured the financial industry would find ways to offer savers a degree of security and flexibility.
But here's the problem: pensions freedom isn't much good if a) you are prevented from saving a meaningful amount and b) endless government and central bank policy mistakes mean you are misled as to the long-term value of your investments. To see what I mean on the second point, just look at markets: some of the distorting effects of the series of great global credit bubbles are finally coming back to bite stockmarkets.
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
I very much doubt that the first generation of retirees entering drawdown had taken into account the possibility that they could lose 10% of the value of their equity investments in two weeks. The Lifetime Allowance and the changes to the annual allowance both mean it has become increasingly hard for the well paid (and even the averagely paid) to build up good pension pots over a full working life.
The changes we expect in the next budget will make things even worse: if you are a 40% or 45% taxpayer now and expect to be in retirement, why would you save if you are offered not full tax relief, but only a flat rate back of 30p in the pound? It makes no sense. Pensions are set to become the preserve of lower-rate taxpayers alone.
Spare a thought for the nation's fund managers. They live on "ad valorems": so the more money they have under management, the more they make. Collapsing stockmarkets cut their take. But collapsing subsidies do too. And what is pension tax relief but a vast subsidy to the fund management industry?
The Centre for Policy Studies says around 50% of the £35bn of annual tax relief goes to those on more than £50,000-plus. Say £25bn of this ends up with fund managers one way or another. Then let's say higher-rate taxpayers save less as a result of all the change. Half perhaps. That means £12bn-£13bn less flowing from HMRC into fund manager accounts every year (to be charged at, say, 0.7%) than is the case today. There are, I think, an awful lot of people beginning to wish that Osborne had never started down the path of reform.
-
Tycoon Truong My Lan on death row over world’s biggest bank fraudProperty tycoon Truong My Lan has been found guilty of a corruption scandal that dwarfs Malaysia’s 1MDB fraud and Sam Bankman-Fried’s crypto scam
-
Why undersea cables are under threat – and how to protect themUndersea cables power the internet and are vital to modern economies. They are now vulnerable
-
The myth of hypothecated taxesEditor's letter The government wants to add a penny on our National Insurance contributions to pay for social care. But it won’t, says Merryn Somerset Webb. It will just vanish into the black hole of our public finances.
-
Should capital gains tax be higher or lower?Editor's letter Capital gains tax is up for review. There are plenty of long-term arguments to be had about this. But in the short term, Merryn Somerset Webb has a few ideas for the government should it want a little cash inflow.
-
The best thing you can do for your children is to secure your own financesEditor's letter The "Bank of Mum and Dad" is now the 11th-largest mortgage lender in the UK. But giving your children money may not be the best way to help them, says Merryn Somerset Webb.
-
Inheritance tax: just abolish the entire thingEditor's letter Why not abolish inheritance tax and replace it with a gift tax on the recipients of unearned cash – wherever it comes from?
-
Save into your pension while you canEditor's letter Fiddling with pension tax relief could be a nice little earner for a government hungry for cash, says Merryn Somerset Webb. Save what you can while you can.
-
Good news for defined-benefits pensionsEditor's letter A rate rise or two could make the defined-benefits pensions deficit simply disappear, says Merryn Somerset Webb. In the meantime, there are a couple of things pension fund managers could do to help things along.
-
Don't get too relaxed about your pensionEditor's letter George Osborne might leave pensions alone for now, says Merryn Somerset Webb. But don't count on it staying that way.
-
Three pension traps for the unwary
Editor's letter Pensions Freedom Day is almost upon us and you're right to be excited, says Merryn Somerset Webb. Just watch out for these three pitfalls.
