Spread betting: five tips for would-be traders

Spread betting stocks can be tempting – but for many, it’s ruinous. Michael Taylor of Shifting Shares looks at how to avoid the pitfalls.

The sort of volatility we’ve seen during the coronavirus outbreak tends to draw new traders to the stockmarket like moths to a flame. Spread-betting firm IG Index recently reported an influx of 22,500 clients in just 36 days. The problem is, most new traders are ill-prepared to cope with the realities of trading. Understanding the five concepts in this article won’t turn you into a stockmarket wizard overnight, but it might help you to avoid being the proverbial moth – and give you a better idea of whether trading would suit you or not. 

1. Position sizing: don’t bet the house on one stock

The two most important concepts to understand before trading are “position sizing” and “risk management”. The size of your positions determines your level of risk – your potential capital loss. Many new traders pile in with a large percentage of their portfolio, which is their first mistake. They then see those positions gradually eroded, because new traders aren’t prepared to cut their losses. This is their second mistake. “The first cut is the cheapest” is one of the best-known market mantras for a reason. Of the traders I know who have blown their accounts, every single instance was due to having either too much exposure to one position, a failure to cut losses early, or both.

The goal when position sizing is to make your position big enough to mean something, but not large enough to do serious damage. You will inevitably get hurt when trading. Avoiding overexposure to any one position is the only way to significantly mitigate the very real risk of blowing your account. I never put more than 10% of my total account into a single stock – not even for a short-term trade. For example, many traders piled in after seeing the directors of beer, wine and spirits supplier Conviviality buying the stock in March 2018 in the wake of a profit warning– yet just four days later the listing was suspended and eventually the share price was written down to 0p. The total loss of 10% of a portfolio is painful – but it’s not fatal. 

A further trick with position sizing is to scale your positions. When you’re winning consistently, you want to be gradually increasing your position sizes in order to compound your account faster. For example, if your overall portfolio grows by 10%, you can increase your position sizing by 10% too. Remember, however – this is even more critical when losing. By scaling down your accounts when losing, you increase the number of trades you can place before you blow your account. Remember: capital preservation is key in this business. Downside risk must always come first. 

2. Risk management: always know the downside

The size of your positions may vary depending on the placement of your stop-loss (the point at which you will exit the trade if it is going against you), but you should aim to keep the risk per trade a consistent size. If you are not consistent about how much money you can lose on any one trade, then how can you expect to make consistent profits? Losing isn’t a choice – but the amount you lose is always a choice. If you can keep your nicks and cuts small, and minimise your risk each time, then you give yourself the opportunity to stay in business. 

Here’s an example. Say we have two trading positions of £2,000 and £4,000, with a 10% stop on each. In trade one we will lose £200, and in trade two we’ll lose £400. However, in some positions, a looser stop will be required. If “support” (a technical analysis term referring to a level at which the share price has historically rebounded) is 15% away and we are running a 10% stop, then it’s likely we’ll be flushed out of the position. 

To adjust our position size for risk, we first take our monetary risk on the trade (the amount that we are prepared to lose on the position) and divide this by the difference between our entry price and intended exit price (or stop loss). This gives us the number of shares that we need to buy. 

So say we wanted to buy shares in Sammy’s Sandwiches at 20p and if it falls to 16p, we’ll cut our losses. This would give us 4p risk per share (the difference between the entry and exit). Now say we want to risk a maximum of £500 on the trade. Our calculation would be £500 / 4p = 12,500 shares to buy. Using this calculation, you can keep your risk constant, while adjusting your position sizes for better entries. 

3. Be consistent 

One of the most poorly understood aspects of trading is this: you need to be consistent in order to be successful. Many get-rich-quick marketers push the idea that traders can work whenever they want, wherever they want (I discussed this in my previous MoneyWeek article looking at scam artists promoting binary options “signal” schemes). However, while the market gives potential traders unlimited freedom and creativity of expression – which is one of its most attractive features – the reality is that you are restricted. You must focus your creativity in certain areas. The best traders follow the same routine, day in, day out, and they’ll trade the same set-ups over and over again. Many spread-betting providers have flashing lights all over their platforms, designed to entice you into taking a position. But trading is about working outside of market hours and the mechanical execution of the strategy you have already mapped out. 

One trick I use to remain consistent is to create checklists and reminders on my laptop. A simple reminder that the opening auction is starting means I’m less likely to miss it because I was too absorbed in a piece of news. Human beings are terrible at multitasking – the brain can hold only a few pieces of information in its working memory at any one time. Having a checklist of questions such as “does this trade meet my criteria?” and “is this trade a part of my strategy?”, will help you resist impulsive “boredom trades” and ensure you are trading in line with your goals. 

4. Keep a trade journal 

If you don’t get into the habit of journalling or tracking your progress, you’ll struggle to improve. It is very hard, if not impossible, to identify the consistent failures in your trading if you are not logging them – you can’t fix a problem if you don’t know that you have one. Noting small successes as well as areas for improvement will give you tangible opportunities to improve. Trading can also be an emotional sport. A journal will help keep you accountable for your mistakes. By keeping yourself in check, you avoid the risk of trading on “tilt” – that is, trading on emotional reactions rather than logical judgement. Many accounts have been blown by traders who were no longer thinking straight for extended periods.  

One trick to avoid becoming too emotional is to think of the money in your account as points, not pounds. I also write down notes about what’s going on in the world and how it may be possible to profit from the various scenarios. When Covid-19 started ravaging Italy and it was clear this was a serious global threat, I began to look for stocks that would suffer in order to short them. It’s also useful to think of, and write down, three trading ideas to explore. If you can consistently create fresh ideas, some of these will eventually move from being intangible thoughts in your journal to becoming tangible profits in your account.

5. Don’t pay up for a good story

As any good salesperson knows, stories sell. Firms often attract investors using a good story, typically involving a bold claim about owning world-changing technology, for example. The technology may exist – it may even work – but owning a working technology and commercialising it are two different things. However, as with any good story, there are usually plenty of keen listeners to be found. Fever can strike any stock and bring hordes of delirious punters bidding it up to stratospheric levels. Riding this fever can be profitable to trade – but don’t get left holding the baby when it comes back down to earth. Focusing on your strategy will give you a much greater chance of success than listening to the siren stories of the stockmarket. 

The key points to remember

Trading isn’t easy, but proper preparation raises your odds of success. If you are tempted to dabble in trading stocks, only do it with money you’re fully prepared to lose, and remember these six key practical tips.

Never risk more than 10% of your account in a single position, but be prepared to lose 100% of every position you trade – because one day you will. 

Scale position-sizing up when you are winning and down when you are losing.

Keep your risk levels constant – use the equation “monetary risk/risk per share” to work out how many shares you need to buy.

Use checklists and alerts or reminders to keep a consistent routine and to avoid relying on working memory – this decreases decision fatigue.

Keep a trading journal for accountability and generating trade ideas.

Know how to spot a good story but never fall in love with a stock – don’t overstay your welcome.

For more from Michael, visit shiftingshares.com

Recommended

Big tech smashes expectations with bumper profits
Tech stocks

Big tech smashes expectations with bumper profits

Big tech companies have reported profits far in excess of expectations, with Apple, Alphabet and Microsoft generating a combined $56.8bn. Saloni Sarda…
28 Jul 2021
Oil is taking a well-earned rest. But the bull market isn’t done yet
Oil

Oil is taking a well-earned rest. But the bull market isn’t done yet

The oil price has more than doubled in the last five years. It’s come off the boil recently, but in the longer term, things are still looking good. Do…
28 Jul 2021
Why you should treat whole-life insurance policies with extreme caution
Personal finance

Why you should treat whole-life insurance policies with extreme caution

Whole-life insurance policies are often marketed to people in their 50s and over. But there are significant drawbacks and you could end up with nothin…
28 Jul 2021
I wish I knew what an index was, but I’m too embarrassed to ask
Too embarrassed to ask

I wish I knew what an index was, but I’m too embarrassed to ask

The FTSE 100 is probably the best-known stockmarket index in the UK. But what exactly is an index?
27 Jul 2021

Most Popular

The MoneyWeek Podcast: Asia, financial repression and the nature of capitalism
Economy

The MoneyWeek Podcast: Asia, financial repression and the nature of capitalism

Russell Napier talks to Merryn about financial repression – or "stealing money from old people slowly" – plus how Asian capitalism is taking over in t…
16 Jul 2021
Why the UK's 2.5% inflation is a big deal
Inflation

Why the UK's 2.5% inflation is a big deal

After years of inflation being a financial-assets problem, it is now an “ordinary things” problem too, says Merryn Somerset Webb. But central banks st…
16 Jul 2021
Three companies that are reaping the rewards of investment
Share tips

Three companies that are reaping the rewards of investment

Professional investor Edward Wielechowski of the Odyssean Investment Trust highlights three stocks that have have invested well – and are able to deal…
19 Jul 2021