Merryn's Blog

Is buying a property really cheaper than renting? Don’t be so sure

Contrary to popular belief, buying property in the UK is not necessarily cheaper than renting - at least not in the long run. Here's why.

Two weeks ago a small building in Wincanton went to auction. It cost its buyer £186,000 ten years ago. At the peak of the bubble, several agents valued it at £300,000 plus.

It had been on the market for two years. Offers had been made at prices ranging from £200,000 to £250,000. All had been accepted. None had made it to exchange: none of the would-be buyers had managed to actually come up with the cash.

Subscribe to MoneyWeek

Become a smarter, better informed investor with MoneyWeek.

At auction it fetched £190,000 and only after a very significant effort from the auctioneer to get it to its reserve. That's a peak-to-sale-price drop of 37%.

I popped this nugget of information up on Twitter (I'm @merrynsw) to show those who think that house prices have dropped 10% or so at most and have now stabilised, that they did not and have not.

Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

One of the Twitter replies said that this is not the case. He would, he said, "hang his hat" on the sale I mention having been something to do with either mortgage fraud or a repossession. It wasn't. And not only was it not, but nor were many of the others there.

The fact is that what is really happening in the lower part of the market is being covered up by the low volumes and high quality of conventional sales. Pick an area of the country and follow the sales in it on PrimeLocation.com or some such for a while. You will see that the occasional perfect house comes up. If it is on at a reasonable price it sells fast. Anything else does not most sellers aren't desperate enough to cut their prices to levels where ordinary buyers will buy.

So the only place that you are seeing clearing prices is at auction where desperate sellers meet savvy cashed-up bargain hunters.And there, if the price you get is 40% below the price you might have got in 2007, you go away thinking you got pretty lucky.

That's a house price crash so much so it may even be that whoever bought the Wincanton flats has got himself a bargain.

However, the key point for the rest of us to takefrom this is that the wider market very often follows auction prices down. That's something that generation rent' might want to bear in mind when they are told that they should buy as soon as possible, given that, in most UK cities, buying is now "cheaper than renting" - according to Zoopla, that's the case in 45 out of 50 cities in the UK.

Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

Capital Economics have had a good look at this and I think pretty much debunked the idea that buying is a better idea than renting for would-be first-time buyers (FTBs) at the moment. They've used the example of someone with a 20% deposit looking at a £140,000 house, and assumed buying costs of £2,450. So the upfront capital needed is £30,450 (£28,000 of that is the deposit).

They assume a typical FTB mortgage of 3.29%, rising to 4.99% in two years' time, making the monthly payments first £548, and then £647. The maintenance and insurance costs of owning are estimated at £65 a month rising at 2.5% a year.

Capital then compare that to renting a similar house at a rent of £595 a month (based on the current consensus rental yield of 5.1%). Under these assumptions, it is the case that over a five-year period, it costs around £3,000 less to rent than to buy. But this is "not the whole story".

Let's say house prices stay stable. By repaying some principle along the way, our buyer will have amassed equity of £13,943 to add to the initial deposit of £28,000. If he sells he'll pay fees. So he'll probably end up with a gain of £9,000 or so in hand, for a total of £39,493.

On to our renter. He's kept the near-£30,000 deposit he could have used to buy a house in the bank, on a fixed rate of 4% (3.4% post tax). So he has interest of £5,092. He pays the difference between rent and a mortgage into the account too, getting an interest rate of 2.4%. That gets him another £3,224. So he ends up with £38,719. He is worse off by £729.

However given the tiny margin here, if house prices don't stay stable if they fall a few percent or even 5-10% - it won't be the tenant that will be worst off in five years, it will be the buyer. By a long way.

Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below
Advertisement

Recommended

Visit/516758/beyond-the-brexit-talk-the-british-economy-isnt-doing-too-badly
Economy

Beyond the Brexit talk, the British economy isn’t doing too badly

The political Brexit pantomime aside, Britain is in pretty good shape. With near-record employment, strong wage growth and modest inflation, there is …
17 Oct 2019
Visit/investments/property/buy-to-let/600849/come-back-buy-to-letters-all-is-forgiven
Buy to let

Come back buy-to-letters, all is forgiven

The government is winning its war against small private buy-to-let landlords. But who benefits?
23 Feb 2020
Visit/economy/people/600864/rishi-sunak-the-maharaja-of-the-yorkshire-dales
People

Rishi Sunak: the maharaja of the Yorkshire Dales

Rishi Sunak is taking the reins of the world’s fifth-largest economy at a crucial juncture. The unflashy but likeable youngster may be just the man fo…
20 Feb 2020
Visit/economy/uk-economy/600857/what-is-britains-new-economic-policy
UK Economy

What is Britain’s new economic policy?

At the moment, Britain doesn’t seem to have an economic policy. But radical-seeming announcements and the surprise ousting of the chancellor portend m…
20 Feb 2020

Most Popular

Visit/investments/stockmarkets/600909/will-coronavirus-kill-off-the-bull-market
Stockmarkets

Will coronavirus kill off the bull market?

It seems clear now the coronavirus will at some point go global. And when it does, will it bring down the stockmarket’s bull market? John Stepek looks…
27 Feb 2020
Visit/investments/commodities/gold/600887/gold-price-coronavirus-cost-of-face-masks
Gold

Gold, coronavirus, and the high cost of face masks in northern Italy

The price of gold is spiking – as it always does in a global panic. But this bull market predates the coronavirus epidemic, says Dominic Frisby, and w…
26 Feb 2020
Visit/personal-finance/pensions/pension-tax/600877/why-it-makes-sense-to-scrap-higher-rate-pensions-tax
Pension tax

Why it makes sense to scrap higher-rate pensions tax relief

The point of pensions tax relief is to keep you out of the means-tested benefits system. The current system is ridiculously generous, says Merryn Some…
24 Feb 2020
Visit/517625/tr-european-growth-trust-why-investors-shouldnt-overlook-europe
Sponsored

Why investors shouldn’t overlook Europe

SPONSORED CONTENT - Ollie Beckett, manager of the TR European Growth Trust, tackles investor questions around Europe’s economic outlook and the conseq…
6 Nov 2019