One thing stockmarkets are extremely good at is storytelling. Every bubble, every shift in market sentiment, comes with a good yarn. You could even characterise a market as a story competition – the best one gets to provide the framework for the winning investment strategy.
Look closely at the market, and you will see that whatever people say about stockmarket analysis being driven by models and maths isn’t quite true. We were hearing the story of bitcoin – how cryptocurrencies will save us in an age of government overreach and fiat money meltdown – long before the models comparing its market capitalisation to that of gold appeared to justify a forecast price of $500,000.
The same is true of ESG investing (that which has an eye to environmental, social and governance issues). The story goes that if fund managers would only step up and focus on non-monetary issues we could avoid another financial crisis and all make more money too. The problem with this narrative is that for years it had no real statistical basis – before, that is, the growth bubble gave it some happy numbers to work with, largely because most stocks that fit ESG models are also growth stocks.
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Stories can easily turn nonsensical
The same is true of the growth boom itself. Stories tend to come before the models that back them up – I think market participants all know this to be true. But turn to Nature magazine and you get a hint of how it might be the case across many professions. The journal cites a recent academic paper studying theories about the connection between consciousness and neural activity (which are more relevant to markets than you might think, by the way). The paper’s authors observe that most studies “interpret their findings post hoc, rather than a priori testing critical predictions of the theories”. In other words: stories come first.
This is unfortunate in markets (fun, of course, but unfortunate) – because, unconstrained by the absolutism of a models-first environment, we tend to take things to extremes and to extrapolate our stories to the point at which they become nonsensical. And so it has been with the great growth boom over the past decade.
The story started well, with the recognition that the growth potential in technology in particular was undervalued following the financial crisis of 2008. But it turned into both a belief (neatly backed up by academia) that finding the companies with the best potential for growth is all that matters for long-term investing success, and an unnatural division of the market into growth stocks and value stocks.
Those investing in the latter have spent the past decade being derided as losers by the former. And those invested in the former have spent it being derided as optimistic fantasists by the latter. As I say: fun, but unfortunate because, in the end, the difference is less clear cut than it looks.
Traps aren’t just for value investors
A recent note out from Ben Inker at GMO looks at the traps you might find yourself in with both. One of the things growth investors most like to take value investors to task for is the risk that they will end up investing in value traps – that is, stocks that look cheap on a valuation basis but just keep getting cheaper because they have both “disappointed on revenues in the last 12 months and seen . . . future revenue forecast decline as well”.
The criticism is perfectly valid. Inker points out that every year “about 30% of stocks in the MSCI US Value index turn out to be value traps, and they underperform that index by 9% on average”. That said, there is something more common than a value trap: a growth trap.
Every year about 37% of the stocks in the MSCI US Growth Index turn out to disappoint on current and forecast revenues. They underperform by an average of 13%. This might not have mattered much in the go-go years when underperforming still meant making money. But when the base case is losing money (growth stocks have had a horrible year), and when stockmarkets hate uncertainty even more than usual, it does matter.
As Inker points out, value companies are already cheap by definition, so the pain of disappointment often doesn’t mean valuations falling much. But growth stocks are valued purely on the expectation of growth. Without that they are nothing – and so can be expected to fall very dramatically. Which they have. Over the past ten months, growth traps have underperformed the growth universe by 23%. Not long now and they will be value stocks – or for that matter value traps.
There’s a lesson in here: good stories make us forget the one enduring truth of markets: unless you are a very rare trading genius, in the end your returns will not be a function of the stories you believe most, but rather a function of the price you paid in the first place. It is pointless to say don’t hold value traps or, more importantly, growth traps – no one does it on purpose.
A better takeaway is to remember that when reality hits stories, reality wins. There was a rally under way in markets last week. A perfect moment to ditch the definitions (and the derision), rise above the stories and try to wriggle out of the traps.
• This article was first published in the Financial Times
Merryn Somerset Webb started her career in Tokyo at public broadcaster NHK before becoming a Japanese equity broker at what was then Warburgs. She went on to work at SBC and UBS without moving from her desk in Kamiyacho (it was the age of mergers).
After five years in Japan she returned to work in the UK at Paribas. This soon became BNP Paribas. Again, no desk move was required. On leaving the City, Merryn helped The Week magazine with its City pages before becoming the launch editor of MoneyWeek in 2000 and taking on columns first in the Sunday Times and then in 2009 in the Financial Times
Twenty years on, MoneyWeek is the best-selling financial magazine in the UK. Merryn was its Editor in Chief until 2022. She is now a senior columnist at Bloomberg and host of the Merryn Talks Money podcast - but still writes for Moneyweek monthly.
Merryn is also is a non executive director of two investment trusts – BlackRock Throgmorton, and the Murray Income Investment Trust.
December 2023 NS&I Premium Bond winners - check now to see what you’ve won
If you hold money in NS&I Premium Bonds, you can check from today (2 December) to see if you have won in the December prize draw. Here’s how to check.
By Vaishali Varu Published
OpenAI – corporate drama unleashed
OpenAI, the firm behind ChatGPT, was in uproar as its boss was booted out, briefly snapped up by Microsoft and then brought back again.
By Dr Matthew Partridge Published
Halifax: House price slump continues as prices slide for the sixth consecutive month
UK house prices fell again in September as buyers returned, but the slowdown was not as fast as anticipated, latest Halifax data shows. Where are house prices falling the most?
By Kalpana Fitzpatrick Published
Rents hit a record high - but is the opportunity for buy-to-let investors still strong?
UK rent prices have hit a record high with the average hitting over £1,200 a month says Rightmove. Are there still opportunities in buy-to-let?
By Marc Shoffman Published
Pension savers turn to gold investments
Investors are racing to buy gold to protect their pensions from a stock market correction and high inflation, experts say
By Ruth Emery Published
Where to find the best returns from student accommodation
Student accommodation can be a lucrative investment if you know where to look.
By Marc Shoffman Published
Best investing apps
We round up the best investing apps. Looking for an easy-to-use app to help you start investing, keep track of your portfolio or make trades on the go?
By Ruth Emery Last updated
The top funds to invest in - November 2023
Tips Investors are focused on income strategies and FTSE heavyweights. We look at what investors have been adding to their portfolios in the last month
By Vaishali Varu Last updated
The world’s best bargain stocks
Searching for bargain stocks with Alec Cutler of the Orbis Global Balanced Fund, who tells Andrew Van Sickle which sectors are being overlooked.
By Andrew Van Sickle Published
Revealed: the cheapest cities to own a home in Britain
New research reveals the cheapest cities to own a home, taking account of mortgage payments, utility bills and council tax
By Ruth Emery Published