Merryn's Blog

Are women really better investors?

Studies seem to show that female investors outperform their male counterparts by quite a bit. Merryn Somerset Webb isn’t so sure that’s true.

141125-trader-b

In the FT last weekend John Authers wrote about the many studies that show female investors outperforming male investors, both in ordinary life and in the professional world. He pointed particularly to a Barclay's report looking at the five years to March 2011.

During that period, hedge funds run by women and minorities returned an average of 82.4% while "non diverse funds" (those run by white men, presumably) returned only 51%. These numbers, says Authers, make it something of a shame that a mere 3.3% of hedge funds were run by "women or minorities" at the time of the study.

Subscribe to MoneyWeek

Become a smarter, better informed investor with MoneyWeek.

I'm not so sure.

It makes sense to add diversity into most things (homogeneity of thinking leads to the overconfidence that gives us bubbles) and money management is no different, a point Authers makes well.

Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

But my guess is that the more women you get into hedge fund management the more their returns will converge with those of the men. The women who make it to the top of hedge-fund-land at the moment are the best and the most dedicated there are.

It isn't particularly easy working your way up in finance (the hours are long and the work is intense) and more men stick at it than women (it's all about children and alpha couples. see past blogs). So it makes sense that the women who make it outperform they are just better.

Make the industry so different that 50% of managers were women and 50% were men, and that might no longer be the case.

Advertisement

Most Popular

Visit/520478/central-banks-what-really-matters-for-markets-in-2020
Stock markets

Here’s what really matters for markets in 2020

The current geopolitical turmoil is making headlines. But it isn’t particularly significant for investors, says John Stepek. What matters more is how …
10 Jan 2020
Visit/520406/mindfulness-and-wellbeing-the-relentless-creepy-rise-of-the-enforced-happiness-industry
Investments

Mindfulness and wellbeing: the relentless, creepy rise of the enforced happiness industry

The evidence suggests we’ve never been richer or healthier, yet we are always being told how stressed and discontented we are. Jonathan Compton assess…
9 Jan 2020
Visit/520422/the-state-of-irans-feeble-economy
Economy

A look at the state of Iran’s feeble economy

The Islamic Republic is a big player in regional geopolitics, but its economy is weak, its people in revolt and its enemies growing bolder. Simon Wils…
11 Jan 2020
Visit/520113/uk-property-prices-are-in-the-doldrums
Property

UK property prices are in the doldrums

House prices barely rose in 2019. Good news, says Nicole Garcia Merida.
9 Jan 2020