US stocks are more expensive than ever after Trump's tariffs
We don’t need to second-guess the effect of Trump's tariffs to think that the rest of the world offers better value
When Donald Trump began unveiling his tariff plans in April, investors feared we were entering a sharp and sudden bear market. Stocks dropped sharply around the world, with the US down 10% in two days. Yet the plunge was short-lived: stocks rallied as abruptly as they had dropped. The US and other major global markets have gone on to new highs. So did investors get rattled too easily – or are they too sanguine now?
On the optimistic side, the deals that the US is striking with trading partners look less damaging than everybody feared in April. Yes, tariffs are unwelcome. They bring complexity and friction to global trade and add costs. Those costs will be borne to varying extents by the entire supply chain between foreign exporters and US consumers. Yet these deals still reduce the risks of a wider and more damaging trade war.
The pessimistic take is that America’s views on the rest of the world have changed. It is backing away from principles that it has championed for decades to become insular and mercantilist. Policymaking is more arbitrary and unpredictable. We can’t even be confident that these deals – which are still broad frameworks – will be honoured, let alone what might come in the next three-and-a-half years and beyond.
MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
US stocks vs the world
So the rest of the world is reacting in a rational way. Countries are striking deals with the US to minimise immediate disruption, but over the longer term they will have to recognise that the world is changing. Trade patterns and alliances will shift. CEOs are also trying to flatter Trump by announcing large investments in the US to avoid being targeted – we are seeing plenty of this from pharma firms in an effort to ward off threats of high tariffs on imported drugs. Yet it remains to be seen how much will be puffing up investment that was already in the pipeline and how much actually materialises.
We will be looking at how all this could play out at Turmoil, Tariffs and Trump 2.0, our next annual MoneyWeek Wealth Summit on 7 November (tickets have just gone on sale at moneyweekwealthsummit.co.uk/2025). However, in stock market terms, there is one obvious idea for managing these risks.
US stocks have so far outstripped the rest of the world over the past 15 years that they now make up 60%-70% of the global market, depending on which index you track. This has been driven by superior earnings growth, but valuations have also diverged much more than many investors realise.
The MSCI USA trades on 23 times forecast earnings, while the MSCI Europe is on 14. Look back to mid 2016 – about the time the divergence accelerated – and the MSCI USA was on 17 times forward earnings, while the MSCI Europe was on 15 times. So striking a better balance between the US and the rest of the world than a typical global tracker fund doesn’t need to be a bet on whether Trump’s policies will ultimately hurt the US. Doing so is increasingly justified by the growing gulf in valuations.
This article was first published in MoneyWeek's magazine. Enjoy exclusive early access to news, opinion and analysis from our team of financial experts with a MoneyWeek subscription.
-
Energy, healthcare and utilities: how to tap into AI in the real economyAI promises to add to the productivity and profitability of much of the economy beyond tech. Here’s two themes to tap into AI in the real economy.
-
How Junior ISAs could help with inheritance tax planningLooming inheritance tax changes will limit how much pension wealth can be passed on but more people may be maxing out their loved ones’ JISA allowance instead
-
Should you sell your Affirm stock?Affirm, a buy-now-pay-later lender, is vulnerable to a downturn. Investors are losing their enthusiasm, says Matthew Partridge
-
Why it might be time to switch your pension strategyYour pension strategy may need tweaking – with many pension experts now arguing that 75 should be the pivotal age in your retirement planning.
-
Beeks – building the infrastructure behind global marketsBeeks Financial Cloud has carved out a lucrative global niche in financial plumbing with smart strategies, says Jamie Ward
-
Saba Capital: the hedge fund doing wonders for shareholder democracyActivist hedge fund Saba Capital isn’t popular, but it has ignited a new age of shareholder engagement, says Rupert Hargreaves
-
Silver has seen a record streak – will it continue?Opinion The outlook for silver remains bullish despite recent huge price rises, says ByteTree’s Charlie Morris
-
Investing in space – finding profits at the final frontierGetting into space has never been cheaper thanks to private firms and reusable technology. That has sparked something of a gold rush in related industries, says Matthew Partridge
-
Star fund managers – an investing style that’s out of fashionStar fund managers such as Terry Smith and Nick Train are at the mercy of wider market trends, says Cris Sholto Heaton
-
Affordable Art Fair: The art fair for beginnersChris Carter talks to the Affordable Art Fair’s Hugo Barclay about how to start collecting art, the dos and don’ts, and more
