Is this vaccine the big Covid-19 breakthrough?

A vaccine that appears so far to be safe and effective is making its way through the final trials before commercialisation. There are reasons to be cheerfully optimistic, says Simon Wilson.

What’s new?

The German drug company BioNTech and its US partner, Pfizer, announced on Monday that their Covid-19 vaccine has been found to be 90% effective. The drug remains in phase-three clinical trials, and there are significant unknowns around the extent of its effectiveness, as well as challenges around scaling up and distribution (the vaccine has to be stored at temperatures around –75˚C). But there is hope. 

What happened in the trial?

In a double-blind global trial involving 43,500 volunteers, who were either taking the trial vaccine or a control-group placebo, 94 people contracted Covid-19. The split between the two groups indicates that the vaccine – which is taken in two doses, three weeks apart – is more than 90% effective. We don’t know yet how many of those 94 had been given the vaccine and got Covid-19 anyway. It’s also not yet known how long vaccinated patients remain immune, or whether the vaccine stops transmission or just the development of the disease. What we do know is that it remains effective 28 days after the second of the doses is taken, and there are no reported safety concerns.  

So this is good news?

Indeed, and not just because there appears to be an effective, safe vaccine, but because this particular virus is susceptible to control by a vaccine at all. Some viruses from the same family, and other pathogens such as HIV and malaria, have defied all efforts to develop a vaccine over many decades. The finding of 90% efficacy is also higher than most people had dared hope for (it’s twice as effective as flu vaccines, for example). BioNTech co-founder and boss Dr Ugur Sahin said he expected his vaccine’s immune response to last for “at least one year” and that the vaccine-induced antibodies were shown to block about 20 different mutations of Sars-Cov-2, the virus that causes Covid-19. All this makes it more likely that other effective vaccines will be developed.

How do vaccines work?

A conventional vaccine works by introducing the deactivated husk of a virus, or proteins from that virus, into the body. That dead virus triggers an immune response that prevents subsequent infection. It’s a very effective and proven approach, but it takes time. This new vaccine is different. It uses mRNA (messenger ribonucleic acid) technology that was originally developed as a cancer therapy. Genetic code wrapped in microscopic droplets of oily liquid is injected into the body. This code instructs cells to make viral proteins that prime the immune system. The idea is that the mRNA “tricks” cells into making fragments of the coronavirus, so that the body learns to spot what it looks like and produce antibodies.

Is this technology new?

Not completely. Such mRNA vaccines have been under development for years, aimed at tackling viruses including influenza, HIV, rabies and Zika. But the arrival of Covid-19 “turbocharged the process”, says Clive Cookson in the Financial Times. The crucial advantage of mRNA vaccines is that they are potentially faster to develop and easier to manufacture – making the technology ideal, if successful, to tackle a novel coronavirus pandemic. Their proponents also say they may be safer than conventional vaccines which may provoke an unwanted reaction from the immune system. BioNTech has led the charge, with backing from Pfizer. They say they will be able to produce a combined 1.35 billion doses by the end of next year. And there are three other mRNA candidate vaccines under development at Moderna in the US, CureVac in Germany and Imperial College London.

What happens next?

Phase-three trials of the Pfizer drug will continue, pending emergency regulatory approval, expected in the coming weeks. The UK has pre-ordered 40 million doses (enough for 20 million people), of which a possible ten million could be available before the end of December. Meanwhile, as more data arrive, scientists will be better placed to answer some of the crucial unknowns about how well this vaccine works. Does it work well in all age groups – and in particular the elderly? Does it prevent transmission as well as illness? If not, it may not get us to herd immunity. Does it prevent all illness or just mild illness? How long does immunity last? More broadly, there is a societal question of whether enough people will be willing to be vaccinated at all; in the UK around one in six say they are firmly opposed. 

What if the vaccine fails in the end?

More are on the way. The UK has made deals to secure more than 350 million vaccine doses from five suppliers in addition to Pfizer. The AstraZeneca-Oxford University team’s vaccine, for example, uses a harmless chimpanzee virus to ferry genetic material from the coronavirus into human cells. It is expected to announce the results of its trials in coming weeks – and crucially its vaccine is already known to stimulate a good immune response in the elderly. Janssen (owned by Johnson & Johnson) is using a similar technique. GSK/Sanofi Pasteur, Novovax and Valneva are the other three potential suppliers with vaccines currently in clinical trials.

But the hype for this vaccine is justified?

More than that, it might even be rather too cautious. Stephen Innes of brokers Axi thinks the markets are putting too much emphasis on the logistical challenges and too little on the fact that this could be a “real game-changer”. Given that we have in months leapt over the hurdles that usually keep a vaccine from market for a decade, the other challenges “will be a snap in comparison”. Brace yourself for “the mother of all economic and reflationary rebounds… once we have made it through what will still be a harsh winter”. This is definitely not the end of the pandemic, but it may well mark the beginning of the end. 

Recommended

When will interest rates go up?
UK Economy

When will interest rates go up?

New interest rates will be announced today (2 February) – we look at what to expect.
2 Feb 2023
Bank of England raises interest rate to 4%
Economy

Bank of England raises interest rate to 4%

The Bank of England raised rates by 0.5%, marking the base rate’s 10th consecutive increase.
2 Feb 2023
RAC: Fuel prices could rise again as forecourts continue to charge higher prices
Personal finance

RAC: Fuel prices could rise again as forecourts continue to charge higher prices

Wholesale fuel prices have slowly risen, but how much will you pay now and how can you save on the costs of driving?
1 Feb 2023
NS&I brings back one-year fixed bonds with highest rates since 2010
Personal finance

NS&I brings back one-year fixed bonds with highest rates since 2010

NS&I’s one-year fixed bonds are back on sale after being pulled off the market in 2019 - but is the rate any good?
1 Feb 2023

Most Popular

Top 10 areas most immune to a house price crash
House prices

Top 10 areas most immune to a house price crash

New research pinpoints the towns, cities and London boroughs most insulated from house price falls this year - and which are the most exposed.
31 Jan 2023
When will interest rates go up?
UK Economy

When will interest rates go up?

New interest rates will be announced today (2 February) – we look at what to expect.
2 Feb 2023
Top 10 up and coming property areas in the UK
Property

Top 10 up and coming property areas in the UK

New research shows rural areas make for the best investment, while London boroughs dominated the bottom 10
31 Jan 2023