“A wave of fear over Chinese economic growth swept through global markets on Monday,” say Narayanan Somasundaram and Jack Stone Truitt on Nikkei Asia. Markets dropped in Asia, Europe and the US, where the Dow Jones Industrial Average at one point fell 972 points (almost 3%) before paring losses to 1.8% before the close. Behind the bout of jitters lay the fate of Evergrande, China’s most indebted property developer, which is teetering on the brink of default.
An Evergrande bankruptcy would “amount to a financial tsunami”, says Caixin. The firm has ¥2trn (£227bn) in known liabilities (about 2% of China’s GDP), plus unknown amounts of off-book ones. Some analysts say it could be “China’s Lehman Brothers”, referring to the 2008 collapse of the US investment bank that helped trigger the global financial crisis.
Risks are manageable
That’s an exaggeration, say analysts at Barclays. Evergrande is big and there will be consequences for China’s real-estate sector. “But a true ‘Lehman moment’ is a crisis of a very different magnitude.” It would entail a “lenders strike” across the financial system, a “sharp increase in credit distress” outside real estate and banks not being willing to lend to each other in the interbank market.
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Evergrande won’t cause that. First, its financial-system liabilities are much smaller than its headline liabilities (more than half the total is what it owes to suppliers) – it has around ¥227bn in bank loans and about ¥158bn in offshore and onshore bonds. Second, China has “navigated successfully through a number of defaults and restructurings” lately, including the financial conglomerate Huarong, which had about ¥1.4trn in liabilities. There’s no reason to expect policymakers to mess up this time. Third, Evergrande – and other Chinese property firms – aren’t at the mercy of wholesale funding markets, as Lehman was. “In an extreme scenario where capital markets are shut to all Chinese property firms … which is not occurring … regulators could direct banks to lend to such firms, keeping then afloat.”
Unpredictable consequences
The crisis is not a Lehman moment, concurs Bill Bishop in his Sinocism newsletter. “But it is ugly and will get uglier.” It’s rash to assume policymakers “have a full understanding of all the Evergrande liabilities and interconnections with other firms” Some form of bailout will happen, but “the lack of guidance from regulators seems to be spooking investors”.
This “is far from being a well-managed process”, agrees The Economist – hence bonds from other developers such as R&F, Fantasia and Sinic have slumped over fears they may be next. The underlying issue is that Xi Jinping, China’s president, is cracking down on excess debt in real estate as “one of several campaigns [he] is using to remould the country”. So the contagion risks aren’t just about markets. Real estate accounts for 20%-25% of GDP, thus “an extended campaign against developer debt could significantly lower China’s growth prospects... and lead to greater economic and financial turmoil down the road”.
-
Scottish Mortgage: why we’re turning to private companies and China for exceptional returnsWhen it comes to delivering growth, Scottish Mortgage will stop at no end in its hunt for exceptional long-term returns - this includes China, unicorn companies and sectors such as space exploration
-
Homeowning pensioners splurge early in retirementPensioners who own their own home are front-loading their retirement spending, before spending less in later life. How much will you need?
-
Why Chinese stocks are so far out of favourThere’s little appetite for Chinese stocks despite low valuations.
-
Chinese stocks slump on first trading day of 2025Chinese stocks suffered in the new year from their worst first day of trading since 2016, despite a state stimulus package
-
Cash in on China’s long-term growth with three competitive stocksDale Nicholls, portfolio manager of the Fidelity China Special Situations Trust, highlights three Chinese companies with scalable growth potential
-
Chinese stocks rally – can it continue?Chinese stocks surged after the politburo, led by President Xi Jinping, vowed to ramp up fiscal support for the world's second-largest economy. Should investors be cautious?
-
China’s post-covid investment boom off to a slow start. Should you still invest in China?Advice Investors are no longer bullish on the China shop but the gloomy consensus on Beijing’s economy might be unfair. Should you invest in China?
-
Chinese stocks are cheap – but for good reasonsNews Chinese stocks are trading at an “undeniably cheap” 11.9 times earnings. But they are cheap for good reasons, and this may not be the buying opportunity it appears to be.
-
The fallout from Alibaba’s huge data breachNews Chinese tech giant Alibaba is at the centre of a huge data-breach scandal – and the clampdown on the sector could now intensify.
-
Chinese stocks rally as crackdowns easeNews China’s CSI 300 benchmark stockmarket index has rallied 13% since a low early last month as conditions improve for investors.
