Under the swashbuckling leadership of its founder Merck Mercuriadis, Hipgnosis was one of the dazzling successes of the London stockmarket over the last decade, and proof, if you wished to look at it that way, that for all its current problems, the City was still good at financial innovation.
A hugely successful former music industry executive, Mercuriadis teamed up with songwriter and performer Nile Rodgers – one of the leaders of Chic, and a collaborator with David Bowie and Madonna – to raise a fund that would acquire the rights to song catalogues.
With an initial £300m, over the next few years, Hipgnosis raised more than £1bn from investors and used the money to buy the catalogues of Fleetwood Mac stars Mick Fleetwood and Christine McVie, Blondie, 10cc, the Red Hot Chilli Peppers and many more. Along the way, it created a whole new asset class, with several rival music funds competing with each other to snap up the most valuable catalogues. Bruce Springsteen seems to have called the top of the market when he sold his songs to Sony for a reported $500m. It seems they don’t call him “The Boss” for nothing.
MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
So, why is Hipgnosis in trouble?
And yet right now Hipgnosis is imploding. A plan to sell a big chunk of its catalogue to Blackstone was blocked by shareholders. Its founder has now launched legal action against the fund. It is searching for new auditors after PwC refused to reapply for the role, a development that hardly inspires confidence in the state of its accounts. There are questions about the way that Hipgnosis royalties are calculated. The shares are down by 21% so far this year as investors steadily lose confidence in the entire market.
True, there are always individual businesses within any sector that run into trouble, and Hipgnosis may well be able to get itself back on track over the next year. And yet the very survival of the asset class is now open to question.
There were two big problems with the song funds. First, they relied on very low interest rates. When rates were at 0.5%, or even lower, as they were for most of the last decade, investors were desperate for income. Generating 5% or 6% on a collection of old songs looked pretty good. Now that you can get 5% just by parking your money in the bank, or buying government bonds, it looks a lot less attractive. Second, the funds depended critically on the idea that revenues would keep on growing. That turned out not to be the case. The music streaming market is now more or less saturated, and the likes of Spotify are finding it very hard to force through price rises, even with high rates of inflation. And there are only so many TV shows that want the rights to old Fleetwood Mac songs.
In a bull market, financial engineers are always looking for clever new ways to make money. In the 1980s and 1990s, it was junk bonds. In the 2000s it was subprime mortgages. We may well have seen it in the 2010s with the idea that old music catalogues were an asset that could be traded and monetised on an industrial scale.
There are never really any new ways of making lots of easy money. It always blows up eventually – it is just a question of when.
This article was first published in MoneyWeek's magazine. Enjoy exclusive early access to news, opinion and analysis from our team of financial experts with a MoneyWeek subscription.
Related articles
- Merck Mercuriadis: the mogul shaking up the music business
- Music royalties fund Hipgnosis strikes a discordant note
- Artists demand a fair share of the music industry pie
- Grab a piece of art – or music – with fractional ownership
- How Taylor Swift is boosting the economy
-
What is the 25x retirement rule and does it work?The 25x retirement rule has been around for decades but many experts question if it is a suitable strategy
-
When is the self-assessment tax return deadline?If you are self-employed, rent out a property or earn income from savings or investments, you may need to complete a self-assessment tax return. We run through the deadlines you need to know about
-
Are wealthy whisky enthusiasts leaving Britain?Collectables Wealthy whisky enthusiasts are heading to tax-friendly countries such as Dubai, where there is more disposable income to spend on collectable luxuries like rare whisky.
-
'The rise and fall of Kodak is a lesson for the tech giants'Opinion The long decline of Kodak – a once-dominant company – shows why no business is safe from disruption, says Matthew Lynn
-
8 of the best properties for sale with kitchen gardensThe best properties for sale with kitchen gardens – from a 17th-century timber-framed hall house in Norfolk, to an Arts & Crafts house in West Sussex designed by Charles Voysey with a garden by Gertrude Jekyll
-
Why investors can no longer trust traditional statistical indicatorsOpinion The statistical indicators and data investors have relied on for decades are no longer fit for purpose. It's time to move on, says Helen Thomas
-
Investors rediscover the virtue of value investing over growthGrowth investing, betting on rapidly expanding companies, has proved successful since 2008. But now the other main investment style seems to be coming back into fashion.
-
8 of the best properties for sale with shooting estatesThe best properties for sale with shooting estates – from an estate in a designated Dark Sky area in Ayrshire, Scotland, to a hunting estate in Tuscany with a wild boar, mouflon, deer and hare shoot
-
The most likely outcome of the AI boom is a big fallOpinion Like the dotcom boom of the late 1990s, AI is not paying off – despite huge investments being made in the hope of creating AI-based wealth
-
What we can learn from Britain’s "Dashing Dozen" stocksStocks that consistently outperform the market are clearly doing something right. What can we learn from the UK's top performers and which ones are still buys?
