Think Tesla is a bubble? This might be the best way to bet on it bursting

The huge rise in Tesla’s share price means that, by market value, it’s now the sixth-largest company in the US and and the world’s biggest car-maker. Shorting it is a dangerous game. But there are other ways to bet on the bubble bursting. John Stepek explains how.

Quick reminder – Merryn will be interviewing Charles Plowden of Baillie Gifford on Thursday. If you haven’t already registered to watch it, make sure you don’t miss out!

Back to this morning – I saw a very striking chart on Twitter the other day. Dylan Grice of Calderwood Capital (an occasional MoneyWeek contributor) noted that electric car-maker Tesla is now valued at roughly the same amount as the entire S&P 500 oil sector.

“The equity market seems to be saying that oil has no future, and that energy transition is basically here. I feel like that’s jumping the gun.” Needless to say, I agree.

A future of self-driving hover-cars

One day our cars will all be electric. One day they will all run on batteries with incredibly long life expectancies. One day said batteries will all be charged up via the wind and the rain and the sun. 

In short, we will drive (or rather, be driven) to and from our destinations in weather-powered vehicles, and the only environmental impact will be the bits of our cars’ tyres that rub off on the roads, which will no doubt then become the next big headline enemy we have to deal with, at which point we’ll finally get the hover-cars we’ve all been waiting for since the 1950s (or the 1980s, if Back to the Future is more your era).

That all sounds lovely and I can’t wait, but it isn’t happening today. And it isn’t happening tomorrow. It may take a while longer and, in the meantime, as one Robert Burns once put it, “the best laid schemes o’ mice an’ men gang aft agley”. In other words, the market should probably be pricing in a little bit of uncertainty, given that, as Grice points out, the energy transition hasn’t actually arrived yet. 

Yet, things still seem heavily weighted towards the Tesla end of the argument. There are some utterly extraordinary statistics in John Authers’ Bloomberg newsletter this morning: Tesla is now the sixth-largest company in the US by market value; it is the world’s largest car maker on the same measure. 

Not only that, when it joined the S&P 500 index last month, it single-handedly rendered “Wall Street’s estimates for five-year earnings growth more optimistic than they had ever been”. In other words, analysts expect Tesla’s earnings to grow so rapidly that its inclusion in the S&P 500 has distorted estimates for the entire index.

Anyway. Is it a tech bubble? Is it a green bubble? Is it just a Tesla bubble? Who knows? Shorting Tesla (or anything in its vicinity) feels about as sensible as running out in front of one of its cars just after the driver has decided to stick the autopilot on and snatch 40 winks.

A better way to express and profit from scepticism on the Tesla bubble is to look for “anti-bubbles”. And the most obvious one here is not so much in the other car makers (though they might be worth looking at), but in the old-fashioned energy sector.

How to invest in oil

Markets are starting to wake up to the fact that the death of oil might have been over-exaggerated. When the price of a vital commodity turns negative (as oil did briefly in April last year) then even the most gloomy of oil analysts had to feel that something of a bottom might have been reached.

Since then, we’ve had ongoing abstention by producers, with Saudi Arabia springing a surprise production cut on markets earlier this month. The oil majors are focusing on grabbing headlines for their “clean” investments. Just this morning, Shell has bought Ubitricity, which owns the biggest public electric vehicle charging network in the UK.

And yet, life is returning to oil markets, even as the price steadily recovers from the tough days. As Justin Jacobs in the FT reports, the number of rigs for drilling oil and gas in the US has risen for nine weeks in a row and is now about 40% higher than at its low point in summer 2020. Oil services companies have been reporting better than expected fourth-quarter earnings, as activity starts to pick up.

As ever, the market has anticipated the rebound, with the S&P oil and gas equipment and services sector up about 60% in the last three months alone. And yet, the industry really is recovering from an extremely low ebb – oil producers are not keen to splash the cash yet. As Jacobs notes, the biggest driver of the industry in recent years has been desperately-expanding US shale producers – and those days are over now. Shale players, having been told off by their investors, are “now consolidating and shifting to an emphasis on profits over production growth”.

That in turn indicates that supply of oil will recover more slowly than demand for oil. So while in the long run, oil may well be doomed in favour of electricity, I suspect there’s at least one more boom-and-bust cycle to squeeze some juice out of here.

What does it all suggest? You can invest in oil in a number of different ways. My colleague Dominic has always viewed BHP Billiton as the best bet (yes, it’s best known as a miner but it gets a lot of its money from the sector and appears to be a better play on the oil price than BP or Shell).

That’s just one idea. We’ll have more in MoneyWeek magazine as we look more into the burgeoning new commodities supercycle in coming issues. If you’re not already a subscriber, get your first six issues free here.

Recommended

What you should do if your energy provider goes bust
Personal finance

What you should do if your energy provider goes bust

At least four energy firms have gone under in recent days as the price of gas and electricity soars. Saloni Sardana looks at what to do if your energy…
20 Sep 2021
China’s property woes are coming to a head – so what happens now?
China stockmarkets

China’s property woes are coming to a head – so what happens now?

Chinese property giant Evergrande is in big trouble. And with no bailout plan yet, markets are getting nervy. John Stepek looks at how things might go…
20 Sep 2021
Three strong Asian stocks trading at bargain prices
Share tips

Three strong Asian stocks trading at bargain prices

Professional investor Nitin Bajaj of the Fidelity Asian Values investment trust picks three stocks that dominate their industries, earn good returns o…
20 Sep 2021
Iris Apfel: an inspiration to young fashionistas
People

Iris Apfel: an inspiration to young fashionistas

Iris Apfel made her name as a high-society interior designer before a show at the New York Met turned her into a fashion influencer. At 100 years old,…
19 Sep 2021

Most Popular

The times may be changing, but don’t change how you invest
Small cap stocks

The times may be changing, but don’t change how you invest

We are living in strange times. But the basics of investing remain the same: buy fairly-priced stocks that can provide an income. And there are few be…
13 Sep 2021
Two shipping funds to buy for steady income
Investment trusts

Two shipping funds to buy for steady income

Returns from owning ships are volatile, but these two investment trusts are trying to make the sector less risky.
7 Sep 2021
Should investors be worried about stagflation?
US Economy

Should investors be worried about stagflation?

The latest US employment data has raised the ugly spectre of “stagflation” – weak growth and high inflation. John Stepek looks at what’s going on and …
6 Sep 2021