Following Putin’s invasion of Ukraine at the beginning of 2022, gas prices in Europe jumped as the region’s energy supply became a major casualty of the conflict. When European leaders scrambled to find alternative supplies – to reduce dependence on Russia – Putin started to turn off the taps. After reducing flows during the summer, Russia cut off gas supplies through Nord Stream 1 – the largest single supply route for Russian gas to Europe – at the end of August.
Prices surged following the move by Putin to strangle Europe’s energy supplies. UK natural gas futures hit 670p a therm in the fourth week of August, up 460% in a year. TTF, Europe's wholesale gas price, jumped above €330 per megawatt-hour in the fourth week of August, up 650%.
Over the last few weeks, natural gas prices across Europe have slumped
Gas prices have fallen rapidly since the summer peaks. At the time of writing the European gas benchmark is back below €100 – the lowest level since June – while the UK’s benchmark sits around 180p.
Start your trial of MoneyWeek today
Get unparalleled financial insight, analysis and expert opinion you can profit from.
Start your trial
Sign up for MoneyWeek’s free twice-daily newsletter.
Join more than 165,000 subscribers and keep yourself informed with latest financial news, insights and expert analysis to help you understand what really matters when it comes to your finances.
Join more than 165,000 subscribers and keep yourself informed with latest financial news, insights and expert analysis to help you understand what really matters when it comes to your finances.
This slump in prices is due to the expectation that Europe will manage to avoid the worst this winter. While 80% of Russian gas supplies to the block are now offline (some gas is still flowing to Europe via the pipelines that transit Ukraine and Turkey) traders have managed to fill the gap with LNG (liquefied natural gas) imports.
Latest Videos FromMoneyWeek
The Lex column in the Financial Times has put some numbers on the scale of the shift. Russian supplies are down 80bn cubic metres this year, but Europe has managed to secure 50bn cubic meters of LNG imports. On top of this, demand is expected to fall by an equivalent of 60bn cubic meters. That gives 30bn cubic meters of headroom.
European leaders have done a pretty good job of encouraging users to reduce demand (high prices have also helped). Milder-than-expected weather has also played a roll in reducing demand this year.
As a result, Europe now actually has too much gas – its storage tanks have reached planned capacity weeks ahead of target (in fact the region’s storage facilities are almost full). But, and this is a big but, there is no guarantee this will continue. A cold winter could push up demand, something the region can ill afford right now. The FT estimates that a cold winter will lead to an additional 30bn cubic meters of demand, which will eat into that headroom.
Gas prices could jump again in 2023
Next year is a different case altogether. Supply to the region is likely to fall a further 40bn cubic metres next year even if the pipelines through Ukraine and Turkey remain operational. Filling this gap will be a tough ask.
The LNG market is already very competitive and there’s no guarantee that Europe will be able to muscle out deeper-pocketed Asian buyers. There’s also an infrastructure challenge. Europe lacks the infrastructure to turn LNG from a liquid back into a gas and move it across the continent, although Germany is spending billions to try and change this.
On top of these challenges, France’s ageing nuclear fleet can no longer provide a backstop to Europe’s power market that it has done in the past. This places more pressure on other power providers (mainly gas power plants) to fill the gap.
All of these factors suggest that while wholesale natural gas prices might be falling in Europe today, there’s no guarantee this trend will continue.
The market is still very volatile and uncertainty will persist throughout 2023. It does not look as if consumers and businesses will see any relief from sky-high energy prices any time soon. It could be 2024 before the market returns to some sort of normality or longer if we have two successive cold winters.
