Chinese shares rose 15% in 2024 for their first annual gain since 2020, says Bloomberg News. But “sentiment remains fragile”, with the CSI 300 index enduring its worst first trading day of a new year since 2016. Most of last year’s equity gains came following a “late September stimulus blitz”. Yet since then trading has been “range-bound” as investors wait for official announcements of more economic stimulus.
Why are Chinese stocks tumbling?
Stock markets have been cheered by a $1.4 trillion package of support for indebted local governments and promises of easier monetary policy, but bonds are telling “a bleaker story”, says Jacky Wong in The Wall Street Journal. Local bond yields have been falling – suggesting investors anticipate low inflation and weaker growth.
China’s 30-year bond yield traded at more than 4% in 2018, but recently fell below 2%, less than the equivalent in deflation-prone Japan. Japan learnt the hard way that “it takes strong, overwhelming stimulus to exit a deflationary spiral”. Markets aren’t convinced help on that scale is in the pipeline in China.
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
State stimulus certainly moves markets in the short term, says Nicholas Spiro in the South China Morning Post. This autumn’s announcements saw the CSI 300 rocket 32.5% between September 23 and October 8. Yet despite continued measures aimed at stabilising the property market and helping consumption, trading has turned “volatile” in recent months. “The size... of the stimulus package” may be “less consequential than previously assumed”.
Economists are also concerned about deeper “structural challenges, including heavily indebted local governments, an ageing population” and “excessive dependence on exports” says Reshma Kapadia in Barron’s. But stimulus is part of the picture and we may be in line for more – especially if Beijing is pressed into extra spending this year to offset Trump’s planned “volley of increased tariffs on Chinese imports”.
The bulls haven’t been routed. Goldman Sachs notes that government spending “has historically had a stronger impact on Chinese equity returns than monetary easing”, says Cao Li in the South China Morning Post. Goldman argues the stimulus policy puts a “floor” on the Chinese equity market. Moreover, says Hudson Lockett for Breakingviews, firms are “undervalued” and boast “higher cash flow and profitability relative to global peers”.
Yet sentiment is “precarious”. Tech giant Tencent’s shares sold off 7% in Hong Kong on 7 December after it was added to a US list of “Chinese military companies”. The classification carries “no material consequences” but shows that “perception” is important, too. Fund managers who bought into “last year’s rally” may start to conclude that “buying into the bull case is more trouble than it’s worth”.
This article was first published in MoneyWeek's magazine. Enjoy exclusive early access to news, opinion and analysis from our team of financial experts with a MoneyWeek subscription.
-
Is now a good time to buy UK housebuilders?Recent share price falls could make UK housebuilder stocks undervalued, though there is a great deal of market uncertainty to contend with
-
Teachers’ Pensions: will legal action be taken over the transfer value delays?Teachers are facing long delays in obtaining pension transfer values needed for divorce proceedings. Is a law firm about to submit a group claim, and what else can pension savers do in this situation?
-
Cash in on China’s long-term growth with three competitive stocksDale Nicholls, portfolio manager of the Fidelity China Special Situations Trust, highlights three Chinese companies with scalable growth potential
-
Chinese stocks rally – can it continue?Chinese stocks surged after the politburo, led by President Xi Jinping, vowed to ramp up fiscal support for the world's second-largest economy. Should investors be cautious?
-
China tries to calm its stockmarketsNews After Chinese tech stocks plunged, the government said it would introduce policies that would benefit the markets – sending stocks soaring.
-
China's stockmarket gets ready to roarNews Chinese stockmarkets had a terrible 2021, but with China's central bank easing monetary policy, 2022 could be much better.
-
The three key risks for investors in China, and how to tackle themCover Story Xi Jinping’s vision for the future of China is very different to the past. Stricter social control and the slow struggle to tackle problems in the economy may not be good news for markets, says Cris Sholto Heaton.
-
Evergrande: Chinese property giant spooks global marketsNews Global markets fell this week as investors worried about the fate of Evergrande, China’s most indebted property developer, which is teetering on the brink of default.
-
China’s new small-cap stockmarketNews China has announced plans to establish a new stock exchange in Beijing that will be aimed at small and medium-sized firms.
-
Investors must think again about ChinaBriefings Under Xi Jinping, China is becoming increasingly hostile to business. Foreigners pouring money in might do well to reconsider.
