How to protect the earnings of the self-employed as well as employees

The government has acted swiftly to protect the earnings of those in employment, But the self-employed deserve help too. Merryn Somerset Webb has a few suggestions of how to do it.

We have a lot of self-employed friends – who we are worried about. Writers, tennis coaches, cleaners, riding instructors, interior designers, hairdressers, caterers and on and on. What happens to them – all five million-odd of them?

There has been much discussion around this over the last few weeks – to say nothing of a lot of horrible stories of workless freelancers. The answers aren’t easy. In this week’s magazine we look at the possibility of a universal basic income – how about we just make it easy and give everyone a grand or so a month to live on forever?

Other possibilities are just to get everyone on to Universal Credit or to remove the income tax personal allowance. But none of these things quite work – the first is insanely expensive (and has massive long term downsides – see the magazine) and the others just aren’t fast enough or are not enough in financial terms. We’ve suggested a government scheme (added to the many others being introduced) that pays freelance workers a (high) percentage of their annual income based on their last year’s tax return.

George Bull of RSM has a similar thought, as do many others – but one involving even less admin. He reckons that the government should implement a system for all workers not protected by the employee furlough scheme. This group should be entitled to claim online the difference between 80% of their typical earnings and their current monthly earnings (computed as four times the last week’s earnings) subject to a maximum of £2,500.

This sort of thing will hopefully be coming in some time today: there is an amendment to the coronavirus bill that proposes the lower of £2,917 a week or 80% of earnings averaged over the last three years, and the chancellor has said that he “hopes to have something to say shortly” – although he also says it is “incredibly complicated.”

But the key thing here is to avoid complication. Who is to know those numbers in a hurry? Ideally, claims would be self-certified in the short term. Expensive? Very – think about £25bn per month. An invitation to fraud? Most definitely. Lots of it. A removal of the incentive to work through the crisis? Yes. But the latter might be part of the point and the former can all be sorted out one way or another later (the numbers are so huge now we know there is huge financial repression coming anyway).

In the meantime it would, as Bull says, “put gig-workers and the self-employed on the same footing as employees who found themselves on furlough.” And that would be kind. More ideas on all this from the Resolution Foundation here.

Recommended

The coronavirus is scary – but it's irrelevant to your investments
Investment strategy

The coronavirus is scary – but it's irrelevant to your investments

The spread of the coronavirus is causing alarm around the world. And, while it could be a serious short-term threat to human health, it’s not somethin…
24 Jan 2020
What to buy as the pandemic’s pent-up demand is finally released
UK Economy

What to buy as the pandemic’s pent-up demand is finally released

As economies reopen, says Merryn Somerset Webb, people are going to start spending again. And when they do, here’s what you want to be holding.
23 Nov 2020
How you will play your part in refinancing the post-Covid economy
UK Economy

How you will play your part in refinancing the post-Covid economy

All this stimulus has to be paid for – whether through inflation, tax rises, or financial repression. It's going to be an uncomfortable experience, sa…
19 Nov 2020
Rishi Sunak's multibillion-pound tax raid
UK Economy

Rishi Sunak's multibillion-pound tax raid

Rishi Sunak is seeking to fill a £300bn-sized hole in the public books. Investors beware, says Emily Hohler
19 Nov 2020

Most Popular

Jim Mellon: the world is on the brink of three major revolutions
Share tips

Jim Mellon: the world is on the brink of three major revolutions

Jim Mellon has been giving MoneyWeek’s readers lucrative ideas ever since our very first issue. He tells Merryn Somerset Webb how he sees the next 20 …
5 Nov 2020
Share tips of the week
Share tips

Share tips of the week

MoneyWeek’s comprehensive guide to the best of this week’s share tips from the rest of the UK's financial pages.
6 Nov 2020
November 2020 update: how the MoneyWeek investment trust portfolio has fared
Investment trust model portfolio

November 2020 update: how the MoneyWeek investment trust portfolio has fared

How have our favourite investment trusts been doing? And what would we change?
6 Nov 2020