Is China following Japan's economy and stock market?
China is dealing with deflation and an unappealing stock market. Is it following in the footsteps of Japan?
Chinese markets are stuck in “limbo”, say Abhishek Vishnoi and Winnie Hsu on Bloomberg. Fund managers complain the shares lack both “the vigour of an emerging market and the stability of a developed one”. The benchmark CSI 300 index is down more than 6% this year, leaving it on course for a fourth successive annual loss. Since a 2021 peak, roughly “$6.5 trillion has been wiped out from Chinese and Hong Kong” shares – the value of Japan’s entire stock market.
While much of the world struggles with inflation, China has been battling the opposite problem, says Jacky Wong in The Wall Street Journal. On one measure, the GDP deflator (the gap between nominal and real GDP growth), the world’s second-largest economy has “already been in deflation for five straight quarters”. Falling prices can harm growth, with consumers holding off purchases for hope of cheaper deals ahead.
How is China historically similar to Japan?
Rather than UK-style furlough schemes, stimulus in China during Covid focused on infrastructure and building up new industries such as electric vehicles (EVs) and renewable energy. That might prove a wise long-term move, but the resulting “excess” manufacturing capacity cannot currently be absorbed domestically, triggering a surge in exports, which grew 8.7% in the year to August.
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Why is domestic demand so sluggish? Because local consumer confidence is not far off the historic low it reached in November 2022, says Ralph Jennings in the South China Morning Post. The root cause is a weak property market, say Nomura analysts, who estimate that prices of existing homes have dropped 30% from a 2021 high. When households feel poorer they spend less freely. And with corporate profits coming under pressure, “Chinese consumers have become more frugal”, since they “are worried about the prospects for wage growth and job security”. From “an overreliance on construction” to “a dependence on export markets” and “a rapidly ageing” population, China “shares many similarities” with the deflation-prone Japanese economy of the 1990s and 2000s, says Peter Hannam in The Guardian.
Investors should remember that Japan’s Nikkei 225 took 35 years to regain its 1989 peak after the Japanese bubble burst. Comparisons with Japan are overstated, says Bloomberg News. China still has more scope for urbanisation and “catch-up” growth than Japan had in 1990, by which point the latter was already a high-income economy. A better parallel might be with South Korea.
Following the 1997 Asian financial crisis, Korea seized new opportunities in semiconductors and smartphones. Similarly, China is now emerging as a leader in new green technologies and is already the world’s biggest EV market. Investors are on a global hunt for bargains, but China – where stocks trade on 11 times earnings – is conspicuous by its absence, says Katie Martin in the Financial Times. Whoever wins the US presidency, more tariffs look likely, jeopardising Beijing’s efforts to export its way out of trouble. “No one is interested in buying Chinese assets,” says Vincent Mortier of European asset giant Amundi. “I have never seen such a big pushback among all our clients.”
This article was first published in MoneyWeek's magazine. Enjoy exclusive early access to news, opinion and analysis from our team of financial experts with a MoneyWeek subscription.
Sign up to Money Morning
Our team, led by award winning editors, is dedicated to delivering you the top news, analysis, and guides to help you manage your money, grow your investments and build wealth.
-
Are matchboxes worth collecting?
TikTok is reigniting a spark for matchbox collecting. Is there any value in phillumeny or will it fizzle out?
By Chris Carter Published
-
Inheritance tax receipts continue to soar, up 9% before Budget
Inheritance tax receipts are up 9% on a year ago, the latest data covering April-August shows. Will the tax appear in Reeves’s Budget?
By Katie Williams Published
-
Will Mpox be the new Covid?
Not if Mpox can be contained, says the World Health Organisation. But will it be?
By Simon Wilson Published
-
Mexico passes controversial judicial reform – will it hurt investors?
What will Mexico's new reform mean for investors and the country's economy?
By Alex Rankine Published
-
Has the world conquered inflation?
The Central Bank has tackled inflation around the world – but what was the pay-off?
By Alex Rankine Published
-
Paetongtarn Shinawatra becomes Thailand's youngest-ever PM – will she succeed?
Paetongtarn Shinawatra is joining the family business: both her father and aunt have governed the country. She has promised to “end a cycle of coups”. Can she?
By Jane Lewis Published
-
Why are tourists a problem around the world?
Tourists are good for the economy, but not always for residents, says Alex Rankine
By Alex Rankine Published
-
Ukraine invades Russia – what are the political implications?
Ukraine's surprise invasion into Kursk could change the course of the war politically
By Stuart Watkins Published
-
Indonesia’s new $30 billion capital city is hit by 'delays'
What is causing the delays in Indonesia’s new capital city and when will it be complete?
By Stuart Watkins Published
-
UK stocks have become a global favourite – should you invest?
The world is taking to UK stocks – but how long will it last?
By Alex Rankine Published