Why you should short Tesla, the electric-car maker running on empty

Electric-vehicle maker Tesla is absurdly pricey and faces stiff competition from rivals, says Matthew Partridge. Here’s how to play it.

Electric-vehicle manufacturer Tesla (Nasdaq: TSLA) has epitomised the boom in tech shares. Despite predictions from a range of pundits that the surging stock was about to slump, it has gone from strength to strength, while the group has started turning a profit. Each of my three recommendations that you short it, in March 2017, April 2018 and March 2019, has lost money. Even though Tesla’s shares have fallen after CEO Elon Musk’s foray into bitcoin, they have still risen 17-fold in two years. 

Nevertheless, there are some solid reasons to think that the share-price surge may be overdone. Firstly, the enthusiasm for electric cars among governments around the world, with the UK announcing last November that it planned to ban the sale of petrol and diesel cars from 2030, is a double-edged sword for Elon Musk’s company. This is because the car industry is now pouring billions of dollars into its own models, with General Motors alone announcing at the start of this year that it is going to invest $27bn in electric-vehicle development.

Rivals are catching up

Perhaps the strongest potential competitor is Volkswagen (VW), which is winning plaudits for its new generation of electric vehicles. VW already has ambitious plans to overtake Tesla in the number of electric vehicles that it sells. Meanwhile, car companies are also becoming more environmentally friendly in terms of the amount of carbon that is produced during the manufacturing process. This is important because Tesla currently makes the vast majority of its profits from selling carbon credits to companies such as Stellantis (formed out of the merger between PSA and Fiat Chrysler), which recently announced that it would stop buying credits from Tesla.

Even if Tesla can find someone else to buy its carbon credits, its valuation seems excessive. Its current market capitalisation of £427bn means that it is worth seven times more than General Motors and more than Toyota, Volkswagen, Daimler and Ford put together. Another sign of its overvaluation is a 2022 price/earnings (p/e) ratio of 101 and a multiple of 16 times current sales, figures that would seem excessive for an internet start-up, let alone a capital-intensive car company likely to find it very hard to scale up its production to the levels that would justify such a valuation.

Tesla’s share price has declined by nearly 30% from its peak at the start of this year, which suggests to me that investors are finally beginning to turn sour on the company. So I would recommend going short against Tesla for a fourth time at the current price of $637. However, given Musk’s ability to move markets in both directions, I would suggest that you do so at £3 per $1, and set a stop-loss at $967, which gives you a total downside of $990.

Trading techniques: dividends deliver

Last year was brutal for income investors. More than half of the companies in the FTSE 100 decided to cut, defer, or even cancel their payouts to shareholders. In some cases this was a voluntary measure in order to conserve cash during a time of uncertainty. In others, notably in the banking sector, pressure from regulators prompted companies to act. The outlook has improved, however. Investment platform AJ Bell notes that while a few companies have cut dividends so far this year, all the indications suggest that listed firms will be increasing them by around a fifth in 2022.

But what might this mean for share-price returns? In theory a firm’s decision to increase dividends should have a neutral impact on share returns, since any money that the shareholders receive will be balanced by the fact that a company has less money to pay down debt or put back into the business. 

Some people even argue that it could be a negative sign that the company is running out of ways to reinvest money profitably. However, increasing dividends are usually seen as a positive sign: the company is generating plenty of cash. A study by Jason Turkiela of the University of Oregon in 2014 of a sample of US equities between 2002 and 2012 found that the decision to increase quarterly dividends did lead to a higher share price in the next few days, although most of the rise took place in the first day. Another analysis by Ned Davis Research and Hartford Funds found that between 1973 and 2020, $100 invested in an index of firms that had either increased their dividend or started paying one in the previous year, would have grown to $11,346, compared with $3,764 for the S&P 500. But $100 invested in those who had cut or eliminated their payout would have shrunk to $56.

How my tips have fared

In the past six weeks three of my six long tips have risen. Media group ITV climbed from 122p to 128p, cruise-ship operator Norwegian Cruise Line increased from $27.97 to $31.90 and construction firm Morgan Sindall Group went up from 1,918p to 2,205p. 

However, US housebuilder DR Horton fell from $95.72 to $95.29 and spread-betting firm Plus500 declined from 1,514p to 1,511p. What’s more, while transport group National Express fell from 309p to 304p, it dipped below 290p, the level at which I suggested that you close your position. Overall, then, my long tips (counting National Express) are making a total profit of £6,619, up from £6,380,

My short tips are also a mixed bag, with three appreciating and two falling. Electric-lorry manufacturer Nikola increased from $10.29 to $14.96, cloud-computing specialist Snowflake went up from $230 to $238 and hydrogen-fuel electric-vehicle maker Plug Power increased from $25.24 to $30.70. 

However, online grocery firm Ocado fell from 2,059p to 1,889p. Bitcoin also fell below the $40,000 level at which I suggested that you started shorting it, and is currently at $34,132. In total my shorts are making profits of £2,561, up from £2,380.

I now have five long tips (ITV, Norwegian Cruise Line, Morgan Sindall, DR Horton and Plus500) and five shorts (Nikola, Snowflake, Plug Power, Ocado and bitcoin), which is a good balance, so I don’t recommend closing any more positions. 

However, I would increase the stop-loss on DR Horton to $64 (from $63). I also suggest you reduce the level at which you cover Snowflake to $410 (from $420) and cut the price at which you cover Nikola to $22 (from $23).

Recommended

Share tips of the week – 7 October
Share tips

Share tips of the week – 7 October

MoneyWeek’s comprehensive guide to the best of this week’s share tips from the rest of the UK's financial pages.
6 Oct 2022
China’s economy is heading for a sharp slowdown
Chinese economy

China’s economy is heading for a sharp slowdown

With a slowing property market, Covid lockdowns sapping growth and the CSI 300 stock index down by 22% this year, China’s economy is in trouble.
6 Oct 2022
5 of the world's best stocks
Share tips

5 of the world's best stocks

Concentrating on a few highly profitable companies that excel in their fields can reduce the overall risk in your portfolio, says Rupert Hargreaves. H…
6 Oct 2022
The dangers of derivatives as the “Goldilocks era” ends
Investment strategy

The dangers of derivatives as the “Goldilocks era” ends

That this is no longer a benign environment for investors, says Andrew Van Sickle. But – as the recent pension-fund derivatives blow-up shows – not ev…
6 Oct 2022

Most Popular

Should you take a 25% tax-free pension lump sum in instalments?
Pensions

Should you take a 25% tax-free pension lump sum in instalments?

Taking out a 25% tax-free lump sum sounds appealing but it might not be the best way to manage your pension
30 Sep 2022
Markets may have bounced, but this is not the end of the bear market
Stockmarkets

Markets may have bounced, but this is not the end of the bear market

Stocks are back on the rise, commodities and precious metals prices are up – even the pound has rebounded. But none of this is typical of bull markets…
5 Oct 2022
October’s Premium Bonds: how to check if you are a winner
Savings

October’s Premium Bonds: how to check if you are a winner

NS&I has added almost 110,000 more prizes to October’s Premium Bond draw – are you a winner?
4 Oct 2022