Interactive investor launches managed ISA – is it any good?

If you want to invest but don’t know where to start, a managed ISA could be a good solution. Here's a first look at interactive investor’s new product and how it compares to others in terms of fees, investment choice and service.

Trading online stocks and shares
(Image credit: solarseven)

Interactive investor, the UK’s second largest investment platform, has launched a managed ISA service to help investors who are just getting started. If you are keen to open a stocks and shares ISA but don’t know what to include in it, a managed portfolio could be a good solution.

Interactive investor's managed ISA allows you to choose from ten different ready-made portfolios. The investment platform says this service will bring a “whole new dimension of simplicity, convenience, and value to the UK investing landscape”. 

Interactive investor isn’t the only platform to offer a managed ISA product, though. The likes of Hargreaves Lansdown, Vanguard, AJ Bell and Wealthify all offer something similar. 

Subscribe to MoneyWeek

Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE

Get 6 issues free

Sign up to Money Morning

Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter

Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter

Sign up

We look at how interactive investor’s new product holds up in terms of fees, investment choice and service. Plus, is a ready-made ISA a good fit for you, or would you be better off investing your £20,000 tax-free allowance elsewhere?

How does interactive investor’s ready-made ISA work? 

Interactive investor’s new ISA, known as a managed ISA, helps clients get started on their investment journey by matching them with a ready-made portfolio. This is then handed over to investment experts to manage.

For many, a key barrier to investing is a lack of knowledge or confidence. That’s where ready-made, expert-managed products like this one can help. They give first-timers access to the same wealth-building opportunities as more seasoned investors. 

But how does interactive investor’s ready-made ISA work?

Before opening a managed ISA with interactive investor, clients will be required to answer a series of questions. These will address how much they want to invest, and the level of risk they are willing to take. 

Once clients have answered these questions, interactive investor presents them with a portfolio recommendation that they can review. Once they are happy, they can open the account. Investment experts then manage the investments from there. 

Investors can select from five different levels of risk, and two different investment styles (index investing and sustainable investing). There are therefore 10 portfolios in total. 

The index investment style “aims to keep costs low by not making frequent changes to the investments held”, interactive investor explains. It primarily invests in passive funds which track a benchmark. 

The sustainable investment style also invests in passive funds predominantly, but combines them with funds that integrate environmental, social and governance considerations. 

“We are always looking to do more for investors, and our new Managed ISA will be a game-changer for the many who want some support in choosing and managing their investments, or perhaps just want that extra level of convenience,” says Richard Wilson, chief executive at interactive investor.

How does interactive investor’s ISA compare to others on fees? 

There are lots of things to consider when picking an investment platform for your ISA, but fees are one of the main things you should look at. High fees can erode your investment returns over time. 

The below table looks at managed ISA products from five different providers. It compares the fees they charge on a £20,000 investment. 

Interactive investor’s flat fee structure means it is competitively priced on an investment of this size, offering the cheapest deal of the group. 

Investment of £20,000

Swipe to scroll horizontally
ProviderAccount feeInvestment costsTotal annual costs
Interactive investor£4.99 per month0.19%£98
AJ Bell0.25%Typically 0.6-0.8% per year£170-£210, plus a £1.50 charge each time you buy or sell a fund
Hargreaves Lansdown0.45%0.91-0.97%, depending on the investment approach you choose£272-£284

If you have less to invest, however, another provider might prove cheaper. We ran the figures on an investment of £10,000. In this scenario, Vanguard and Wealthify both charge lower fees. 

Investment of £10,000

Swipe to scroll horizontally
ProviderAccount feeInvestment costsTotal annual costs
Interactive investor£4.99 per month0.19%£79
AJ Bell0.25%Typically 0.6-0.8% per year£85-£105
Hargreaves Lansdown0.45%0.91-0.97%, depending on the investment approach you choose£136-£142

Of course, you can continue to top up your investment over time. ISA rules allow you to stash away £20,000 each tax year. 

So, even if you don’t have £20,000 to invest initially, it is possible that you will be able to build your account balance up to this threshold within a few years – at which point a flat fee structure could be more beneficial. What’s more, hopefully your pot will grow as you build investment returns. 

This is something to bear in mind if you don’t want to end up having to switch your provider further down the line. Switching can mean selling your investments at an inopportune time, which can dampen investment returns.

Does interactive investor offer a similar service to other managed ISAs?

Interactive investor’s managed ISA service works in a similar way to others on the market. For example, most start with a series of questions to find out how you feel about risk. 

Most providers also give you some degree of choice in terms of the investment style you want to follow. For example, would you like to integrate sustainability criteria into your portfolio?

Once you have chosen your portfolio, most providers then manage it on your behalf. Let’s look at Vanguard, for example. This provider promises to “monitor your investments regularly and make changes to keep you in the right level of risk”. 

One provider that takes a slightly different approach is AJ Bell with its starter portfolios. These are more of a halfway house between a fully-managed ISA and a DIY account. 

AJ Bell clients can choose from four different portfolios – “cautious”, “balanced”, “adventurous” and “income”. Once clients have selected one, they can adjust the asset allocation and add other funds from the provider’s “favourite funds” list. 

Once the starter portfolio is set up, the AJ Bell client is responsible for managing it themself. 

If interactive investor clients want to enjoy the best of both worlds, combining managed ISA investments with more of a DIY approach, this is also an option. The investment platform allows them to do this at no extra cost, within the same flat subscription fee.

Is a managed ISA right for me?

If you are new to investing or don’t have time to research and manage your investments yourself, then a managed ISA could be a good idea. 

It doesn’t offer the same level of flexibility as a DIY account, though. As such, you might prefer a regular stocks and shares ISA if you already have a good idea about what funds or assets you would like to hold. 

If you opt for the DIY approach, bear in mind that you will also need to set aside time to manage your investments. This will include rebalancing your portfolio to ensure you maintain a decent level of diversification and the right amount of risk. 

Of course, stocks and shares ISAs aren’t the only option on the market. You could also consider a cash ISA if you need your wealth to remain liquid. Likewise, you might prefer a cash ISA if you aren’t willing or able to take on any investment risk. 

Cash ISAs have become increasingly attractive in the last couple of years, thanks to higher interest rates. The best cash ISAs are currently offering savings rates north of 5%. 

However, remember that stocks and shares almost always outperform cash over the long run. What’s more, interest rates have now peaked and the best savings deals are already starting to be pulled. 

Inflation is another important consideration, as it can erode the purchasing power of your money. If interest rates fall below inflation at some point in the future, then you will actually be losing money in real terms. 

Cash was offering negative real returns for over a decade in the aftermath of the global financial crisis. Real cash returns have only turned positive in recent months, as inflation has been slowing but interest rates remain high. 

If you have an investment horizon of three to five years or more, your money is usually better off in the stock market. But you should always keep some cash tucked away in a rainy day fund for emergencies. It is usually a good idea to build enough of a cash buffer to cover six months’ worth of expenses. 

Katie Williams
Staff Writer

Katie has a background in investment writing and is interested in everything to do with personal finance and financial news. 

Before joining MoneyWeek, she worked as a content writer at Invesco, a global asset management firm, which she joined as a graduate in 2019. While there, she enjoyed translating complex topics into “easy to understand” stories. 

She studied English at the University of Cambridge and loves reading, writing and going to the theatre.