Tens of thousands of savers with large pensions are making withdrawals at such rapid rates that they risk running out of cash in retirement, new data from the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), the City regulator, reveals.
The statistics suggest that while people with larger pension funds are less likely to be making substantial withdrawals, a significant number of savers are still taking out more than 6% of their money each year – and many are taking out 8% or more. But the data on withdrawals from pension funds, which became far easier to make following the 2015 pension freedom reforms, has long been a source of dispute.
Critics of the reforms point out that many people are taking far more than is sustainable out of their pensions early in retirement and so are at risk of financial hardship later in life.
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
However, the FCA’s data does not provide a consolidated view of savers’ finances: the assumption has always been that a significant proportion of those making substantial withdrawals from small portfolios of pension money also have larger plans to fall back on – and that they are being more restrained with these. The regulator’s latest figures, however, suggest this assumption may be optimistic. The figures show that while large withdrawals are more common with smaller pensions, many large ones are also being depleted rapidly.
Of pension portfolios where savers are applying an 8% withdrawal rate or higher, 67% were valued below £100,000; but in 24% of cases, the overall pension was larger. This equates to more than 30,000 savers who are taking 8% of their pension money out each year.
Always take advice
Pension experts describe withdrawals of this size as highly unlikely to be sustainable. While the amount that savers can take out of their pensions each year without running out of money later in life will depend on a variety of factors – including investment returns and charges – most experts think a withdrawal rate of no more than 3% a year is more realistic. To add to the mounting concern over the issue, the FCA’s data also reveals an increase in the number of people who do not take financial advice before entering into income drawdown contracts that allow them to make this sort of withdrawal. More than a third of savers are starting drawdown plans without getting professional financial advice, the regulator’s statistics reveals.
Another worry to keep in mind is that watchdogs have begun to notice a marked increase in the number of scammers targeting pension savers with drawdown plans since the beginning of the Covid-19 pandemic.
Action Fraud has warned that with more people now conducting all their financial affairs online or by phone, the potential for fraud has increased substantially.
-
Spot the Dog: £67bn in underperforming funds revealedAround 137 funds consistently underperformed their benchmark, BestInvest's Spot the Dog report finds. Which funds are in the dog house?
-
What does a BP and Shell merger mean for the UK oil industry?BP’s struggles have made it vulnerable to a takeover. Could it merge with Shell to create a British behemoth?
-
Should you switch your pension fund?Many pension fund options are poor performers, thanks partly to high charges. Is it worth switching?
-
What pension providers don't tell you about your retirement moneyCheck the small print from your pension provider or risk losing thousands.
-
Are lifestyle funds still fit for purpose?Lifestyle funds have failed to do what they were supposed to do – shield savers from risk in the run-up to retirement.
-
State pension triple lock at risk as cost balloonsThe cost of the state pension triple lock could be far higher than expected due to record wage growth. Will the government keep the policy in place in 2024?
-
Midlife MOT: what is it and who can get one?The government has launched an online midlife MOT to help older workers with financial planning, health guidance and career skills. But how does it work, who can get one and would you pass it?
-
Small pension pots to be consolidated, says DWPWorkplace pension schemes worth less than £1,000 that become “deferred” when a saver changes jobs will be consolidated under a new system
-
Retiring abroad: What to consider, from tax to pensionsThe high cost of living makes many people consider retiring abroad. We look at what you need to consider, including tax and pensions.
-
7 pension mistakes to avoid before you retireThese are the 7 pensions mistakes you could be making - and how to avoid them
