Daniel Hilton
A new cash ISA limit is not expected to be announced in the chancellor’s Spring Statement, in welcome news for savers.
Reforms to the ISA allowance had been expected to be introduced, but Rachel Reeves reportedly plans to delay her decision until at least after the statement on 26 March.
Speaking to the Financial Times, one official in Reeves’ camp said: “We are not looking at any changes to ISAs in the Spring Statement. We recognise the range of views around the current ISA system and want to ensure it strikes the right balance between cash and equities.
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
“We want to continue to support cash savings whilst earning better returns for savers, boosting the culture of retail investment and supporting the growth mission.”
It follows weeks of speculation that savers could face an ISA overhaul as part of efforts by the Treasury to boost investment in UK stocks.
Chancellor Rachel Reeves has been meeting with the financial industry to gather ideas on boosting the UK economy and one solution could be reforming the ISA market.
It comes as the UK stock market remains unloved compared to its peers in the US and many companies are even favouring the New York Stock Exchange over London.
Critics have highlighted rising taxes in the UK make it a less attractive environment for companies to operate in.
Reeves is trying to encourage growth in the UK economy and plans include creating pension megafunds that will back British infrastructure projects.
The news that the decision will likely be delayed has been tentatively welcomed by some groups, including Nottingham Building Society.
Harriet Guevara, the building society’s chief savings officer, said they “welcome the fact that the government has heard the concerns of the industry and the public around potential changes to the cash ISA allowance”.
Nottingham Building Society remains committed that “the [cash ISA] allowance should stay as is” rather than being lowered because of a “real concern that it will simply lead to people saving less”.
Meanwhile, Chris Rudden, head of investment consultants at investment platform Moneyfarm, said that while they were alive to criticisms that people put too much of their savings in cash and should be encouraged to invest, “allowing individuals to keep a portion of their savings in cash for the short-term remains an important element of any investment strategy”.
He added: “If the government wants to take away this precious allowance in order to find a way to boost UK growth, they need to come up with a solid framework for how people can invest their money into growth projects, without taking undue risk.”
Are ISAs being scrapped?
Currently, the annual ISA allowance is £20,000.
This can be used across cash ISAs and stocks and shares tax wrappers.
According to reports, financial lobbyists have suggested that the Treasury should overhaul the savings market and either lower the cash allowance to £4,000, scrap cash ISAs or just create a new tax-free product that encourages investment in the UK stock market.
The argument is that this would free up the £294 billion currently held in cash ISAs to be put to better use backing British brands.
There is currently £456 billion invested in stocks and shares ISAs.
There is of course no guarantee that encouraging more into stocks and shares ISAs would benefit UK stocks though, especially as the government has already scrapped plans for a British ISA.
When questioned over the potential allowance cut, Reeves said: “It’s really important that we support people to save to achieve their aspirations.
“At the moment, there is a £20,000 limit on what you can put into either cash or equities [ISAs], but we want to get that balance right.
“I do want to create more of a culture in the UK of retail investing like what you have in the US, to earn better returns for savers.”
The pros and cons of a cash ISA
Higher interest rates have made cash ISAs more attractive in recent years. Savers get the security of fixed return and it is tax-free.
But they could lose their appeal as interest rates continue to drop.
They also may struggle to beat inflation, unlike investing in the stock market.
Even without an ISA, savers benefit from a personal savings allowance at £1,000 per year for basic rate taxpayers and £500 for higher earners.
Research by Quilter suggests many savers are losing money in real terms by keeping funds in a cash ISA.
Someone who invested £10,000 in a cash ISA in December 2012 would currently have £11,955. Adjusted for inflation, this is just £7,918, according to research by the wealth manager.
In contrast, a £10,000 investment in the IA Global Equity index over the same period would be worth £33,526 or £22,221 after inflation.
Holly Tomlinson, financial planner at Quilter, said: “Following a relatively rare period of cash ISAs delivering above inflation returns, we are now back to people losing money in real terms by keeping their money in cash.
“Rumours have been swirling that the government might scrap or scale back cash ISAs, which would be a clear push to shift the UK’s savings culture towards investment.
“That’s not necessarily a bad thing as too much wealth sits in low-yielding cash when long-term investing could deliver better returns and fuel economic growth.
“While this data shows that cash ISAs are not the best place to save to get the best returns, these types of accounts still have their place. Your saving goal might be in the short-term meaning you can’t take on the inherent risk that comes with investing.”
Rob Morgan, chief investment analyst at Charles Stanley, said many people hold too much in cash and not enough in investments, which is a “missed opportunity to drive long term wealth creation".
He added: “This reticence has negative ramifications for the success of the UK stock market and the wider economy too.
“While cash is exactly what is needed for building short term financial resilience through an emergency fund and saving for shorter term goals, it fails to drive household wealth meaningfully forward over the longer term.”
If cash ISAs were axed or limited in some way in favour of stocks and shares ISAs, Morgan suggests those wanting cash-like returns in exchange for little risk could mitigate the move by investing in areas such as short-dated gilts or money market funds.
He added: “That would require some level of knowledge, or perhaps advice or guidance, to achieve the desired objectives, but it could undermine the objective of incentivising greater long-term investment in the stock market specifically."
Tomlinson suggests the approach to the cash ISA should be reform, not removal.
She said: “Capping tax-free cash savings or improving incentives for investment ISAs could strike the right balance. The UK does need to boost its investment culture, but that shouldn’t come at the expense of savers who rely on cash for stability.”
-
Childcare costs drop 56% - but not for everyoneChildcare costs for under-threes have halved following the introduction of free childcare support last year - but some people still face higher costs
-
Could Labour introduce a 2% wealth tax?As the chancellor puts the final touches to next week’s Spring Statement, there are growing calls for a 2% wealth tax to be introduced. Campaigners say it would tackle economic inequality and raise billions of pounds in revenue
