Merryn's Blog

Now the government wants to mess with your Isa

Individual savings accounts work well, and are used and understood by millions. So why on earth would the government want to mess with them?

Only last week I wrote a post explaining why I think money saved into ISAs is safer from the government than money saved into pensions.It sounds perfectly sensible, but all it actually does is prove how even someone as consistently cynical as I am can underestimate the idiocy of governments.

According to the Sunday Telegraph, the Treasury has been doing a few of the things I anticipated last week. It has for example been "gauging opinion" on slashing the amount of tax free cash people can take from their pensions. But it has also been discussing dealing with what the paper calls the "concerns" about ISA millionaires, with a cap on the total amount one can save into an ISA of £100,000.

Subscribe to MoneyWeek

Become a smarter, better informed investor with MoneyWeek.

I can see how this might make sense from a numbers point of view. It must be maddening for HMRC to see people withdrawing capital and income from their ISAs entirely tax free (the tax on the money having been paid in full before they entered the wrapper) and it also fits nicely with the new trend for demonising anyone you can tag as remotely rich.

But it is still a very bad idea. Why? Because everyone loves ISAs. Tens of millions of people save into them, understand them and trust them. Why would any government want to mess with a savings vehicle that works that well? If only they could just sometimes let a good thing alone.

Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

PS I also wonder what's up the idea with capping of totals, rather than contributions. If you wanted to reduce the amount of money in ISAs (which you probably shouldn't) you'd surely be better to cap the amount going in (cutting the annual allowance or some such). Trying to cap the final outcome which is dependent on investment returns just leads to confusion and uncertainty. Just ask anyone trying to figure out the lifetime allowance system for pensions.

Advertisement

Recommended

Visit/517999/beware-of-cash-isa-scams
Personal finance

Beware of cash Isa scams

Fraudsters have been targeting savers by offering unrealistically high interest rates on cash Isas.
19 Nov 2019
Visit/516335/child-trust-funds-where-is-your-childs-cash
Personal finance

Child Trust Funds: where is your child’s cash?

Your offspring may have a child trust fund tucked away. If so, their money is being consumed by fees
15 Oct 2019
Visit/505257/stocks-beat-cash-and-bonds-over-the-long-term
Isas

Stocks beat cash and bonds over the long term

Far more cash Isas are set up than stocks and shares Isas, says Marina Gerner. That's odd given the higher returns from stocks in the long run.
19 Apr 2019
Visit/503324/should-you-get-your-child-a-jisa
Isas

Should you get your child a Jisa?

If you have any money left over once you’ve used up your tax-free allowances, you could consider a junior Isa for your children. But keep an eye on no…
15 Mar 2019

Most Popular

Visit/currencies/600665/currency-corner-new-zealand-dollar-kiwi-vs-us-dollar
Currencies

Currency Corner: how is the New Zealand dollar doing against its US counterpart?

The New Zealand dollar has been doing well against the US dollar in recent months, but has started to wobble a little. Is it still a buy? Dominic Fris…
20 Jan 2020
Visit/investments/stocks-and-shares/share-tips/600653/indias-small-and-mid-cap-stocks-are-set-for-big
Share tips

India’s small and mid-cap stocks are set for big gains – here are three to buy now

Each week, a professional investor tells us where he’d put his money. This week: David Cornell of the India Capital Growth Fund highlights three favou…
20 Jan 2020
Visit/investments/stocks-and-shares/share-tips/600636/class-acts-going-cheap-buy-into-europes-best
Share tips

Class acts going cheap: buy into Europe’s best bargains

Value investing appears to be making a comeback, while shares on this side of the Atlantic are more appealing on metrics such as price/earnings ratios…
16 Jan 2020
Visit/investments/stocks-and-shares/share-tips/600641/share-tips-of-the-week
Share tips

Share tips of the week

MoneyWeek’s comprehensive guide to the best of this week’s share tips from the rest of the UK's financial pages.
17 Jan 2020