Why Isas are safer from the government than pensions

Governments are not above appropriating private pension pots 'for the public good'. But Isas are seen differently. Merryn Somerset Webb explains why.

I wrote earlier this week that it seemed to me to be a good idea to concentrate on building up Isa savings over pension savings. One of the reasons I often give for this view is political risk.

Governments endlessly fiddle with pensions. They cut allowances, change the tax breaks at will, and, more often than most people notice, annex what you consider to be private funds for public use. What easier way to improve public finances than to announce that, henceforth, all pension assets are state assets, or that they are at least to be used to buy public debt?

Subscribe to MoneyWeek

Become a smarter, better informed investor with MoneyWeek.

Look at it like that and it seems to me that you shouldn't save much more than the amount needed for a very basic income into a pension. But here's the question people keep asking me: why do I think that pensions are more at risk from government interference/theft than Isas surely as they are both wrappers set up under the UK tax regime, they are equally at risk?

I don't think they are. First, look at how the tax treatment works on them. The money you put into a pension goes in tax free - no tax has been paid on it at all. As far as the government is concerned, that makes it fair game what they have given they can easily take away. In the minds of HMRC, they still 'own' the tax-relieved portion of your fund; its just a matter of figuring out how to get it back without you noticing.

Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

There is also a lack of immediacy about pensions that means that there is less complaint about changes to them. Look how few people made a fuss about changes to dividend tax treatment under Gordon Brown and how little outcry there has been about the shifting of annual and lifetime allowances under George Osborne. Most people don't understand pensions and it's a lot easier to take away benefits people aren't fully aware that they have than those they already cherish.

Isas are seen entirely differently. The tax on any money that goes into an Isa has already been paid. It goes in net of tax. That means that neither the Isa holder nor the government has quite the same sense that the state has given anything, or that anything is owed by investor to government. Isas are also very simple and very well understood (you put your money in a wrapper, they can't get at it, and that's that).

What's more, over 20 million Britons have them already. Who'd be fool enough to mess with something that popular?

Pensions aren't as easy to have a go at as they used to be (today's ageing population is pretty clued up), but attacking them has still got to be a lot easier than having a go at Isas.

You can read previous posts on this endlessly fascinating subject (to me anyway) hereand here.

Advertisement

Recommended

Visit/513684/companies-cut-back-on-their-pensions-bills
Personal finance

Companies cut back on their pensions bills

Britvic is the latest firm hoping a cheaper inflation index will cut pension costs. David Prosser reports.
28 Aug 2019
Visit/509683/good-news-for-savers
Pensions

Good news for pensions savers from HMRC

HMRC has withdrawn its appeal over breaches of the pensions lifetime allowance.
28 Jun 2019
Visit/502738/dont-miss-the-pensions-deadline
Personal finance

Don’t miss the pensions deadline

There are just five weeks left in the 2018-2019 tax year, so make sure you’ve made full use of your allowances.
6 Mar 2019
Visit/personal-finance/pensions/state-pensions/600781/how-much-extra-state-pension-you-will-get-if-you
State pensions

How much extra state pension you will get if you delay claiming it

If you delay claiming your state pension by a year or two you could end up much better off in retirement.
13 Feb 2020

Most Popular

Visit/investments/investment-strategy/600804/the-secret-to-avoiding-being-panicked-out-of-your-portfolio
Investment strategy

The secret to avoiding being panicked out of your portfolio

With the coronavirus continuing to occupy headlines, investors still aren’t sure how to react. But the one thing you mustn’t do is panic. Tim Price ex…
11 Feb 2020
Visit/investments/commodities/silver-other-precious-metals/600812/buy-silver
Silver and other precious metals

You should all own some silver. Just don’t expect it to make you rich

Silver is cool, beautiful and immensely useful. But for investors it's the most frustrating of metals. Dominic Frisby explains why you should own some…
12 Feb 2020
Visit/investments/investment-strategy/600772/just-five-assets-matter-for-investors-portfolio-asset-allocation
Investment strategy

Just five assets matter for investors. Here's what they are

Every investor’s needs are different – but most can be met by the right combination of five investments
11 Feb 2020
Visit/investments/commodities/600729/the-rare-earth-metal-that-wont-be-a-secret-for-long
Sponsored

The rare earth metal that won't be a secret for long

SPONSORED CONTENT – You can’t keep a good thing hidden forever; now is the time to consider Pensana Rare Earths and the rare earth metals NdPr.
31 Jan 2020