Merryn's Blog

House prices: the government wants them up, you want them down

Merryn Somerset Webb explains why the Help to Buy scheme is looking at Britain's housing problem from the wrong angle.

A month has passed since the second stage of Help to Buy was introduced. You can read more about this in this week'smagazine, or watch the Panorama on the matter tonight (I'm in it, if that makes any difference to whether or not you watch it).

But the stats on month one are quite interesting in themselves. The point of this phase was to raise transactions without raising prices. There have so far been 2,384 applications for houses priced at an average of £163,000.

Subscribe to MoneyWeek

Become a smarter, better informed investor with MoneyWeek.

The average monthly payments of the applicants will come to about 24% of their income, and some three quarters are first-time buyers. 75% are also from outside London and the south east. That's all according to the official press release.

RBS has put out a similar one (no surprise there). One thousand of the applications have gone to it. The average price of the houses applicants want to buy is just over £167,000, and the majority of buyers are first-time buyers under the age of 34.

Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

RBS also stresses that the average joint income of buyers is under £50,000. The idea is to make it clear that it is the young and not very wealthy who are being helped on to the gold-plated property ladder in the UK. And by extension, that Help to Buy is a good thing.

But it isn't that simple. As the FT points out, if 75% are first-time buyers, 25% are not. They already have their foot on the ladder (if not very firmly).

The other point worth noting is that 24% is a pretty high percentage of your income to be spending on your mortgage in historical terms. Neal Hudson of Savills has had a look at this, and notes that whatever the government might like to say on the matter (ie, that 24% is in line with long-term averages and so just fine), the long-term average percentage of their income that first-time buyers have spent on their mortgage payments is more like 20% than 24%.

That's quite a difference, particularly when interest rates are obviously more likely to rise than fall. Still, the key reason we remain suspicious of Help to Buy is because adding new demand to the market is likely to push up house prices (and it has surely already pushed up asking prices, if not transaction prices).

The government seems to think that this is what most people want. We aren't so sure. We did a survey with Ipsos Mori last week in which we asked people if they wanted house prices in their area to rise or fall. Of those asked, 29% said they wanted them to go up, and 39% said they wanted them to go down.

It still seems to us that Help to Buy is looking at the problem from the wrong angle. Surely tighter credit and lower prices are better than looser credit and higher prices?

Advertisement

Recommended

Visit/516758/beyond-the-brexit-talk-the-british-economy-isnt-doing-too-badly
Economy

Beyond the Brexit talk, the British economy isn’t doing too badly

The political Brexit pantomime aside, Britain is in pretty good shape. With near-record employment, strong wage growth and modest inflation, there is …
17 Oct 2019
Visit/economy/uk-economy/600700/the-coming-crisis-at-the-bbc
UK Economy

The coming crisis at the BBC

The BBC’s chief has quit ahead of what promises to be years of turmoil and conflict with a hostile government. Will the licence fee survive?
25 Jan 2020
Visit/economy/uk-economy/600710/the-boris-bounce-might-stop-the-bank-of-england-from-cutting-rates
UK Economy

The Boris Bounce might stop the Bank of England from cutting rates

The latest snapshot of UK economic activity has sparked a bout of inflationary talk, with both manufacturing and service sectors in ruder health than …
24 Jan 2020
Visit/economy/600691/money-minute-friday-24-january-the-key-to-uk-interest-rate-cuts
Economy

Money Minute Friday 24 January: the key to UK interest-rate cuts

Today's Money Minute looks ahead to the release of data that could hold the key to UK interest rates cuts. 
24 Jan 2020

Most Popular

Visit/investments/commodities/gold/600686/gold-and-silver-bull-market-2020
Gold

Want to make money in 2020? Gold and silver are looking like a good bet

If you want to make money from investing, says Dominic Frisby, it’s simple: find a bull market and go long. And in 2020 gold and silver are in a bull …
22 Jan 2020
Visit/economy/600691/money-minute-friday-24-january-the-key-to-uk-interest-rate-cuts
Economy

Money Minute Friday 24 January: the key to UK interest-rate cuts

Today's Money Minute looks ahead to the release of data that could hold the key to UK interest rates cuts. 
24 Jan 2020
Visit/economy/600690/money-minute-thursday-23-january-european-interest-rates
Economy

Money Minute Thursday 23 January: European interest rates

In today's Money Minute we look ahead to Christine Lagarde's second interest-rate-setting meeting at the European Central Bank.
23 Jan 2020
Visit/investments/funds/600697/how-the-boom-in-passive-investing-could-create-better-run-companies
Funds

How the boom in passive investing could create better-run companies

ESG investing, or "ethical investing" as it used to be called, is mostly about the marketing, says John Stepek. But it's not all bad.
24 Jan 2020