Cancelling cash: let's hope India isn't giving the Bank of England any ideas
In a bid to remove counterfeit notes and force transactions into the legal economy, India has banned 500 and 1,000 rupee notes. Let’s hope our own central bankers aren’t taking notes, says Merryn Somerset Webb.
Tough stuff from India's prime minister, Narendra Modi. Yesterday he announced that, with immediate effect all Rs500 (about £6) and Rs1,000 (£12) notes were to be cancelled. Four hours after the announcement, the cash turned into what all fiat money is at heart just bits of paper. Indians can still deposit them at banks until the end of the year and use them in hospitals and pharmacies. But that's it. They are no longer a medium of general exchange: 86% of India's paper money just isn't money any more.
At the same time, rules have been introduced to restrict people from drawing more than Rs2,000 a day from ATMs (rising to Rs4,000 on 19 November). The plan here is twofold or so says the Reserve Bank of India. The first part is to get the huge numbers of counterfeit notes out of circulation. And the second is to force transactions into the legal economy by stopping cash transactions. This should squash the black economy and of course boost tax revenues.
Wanting all this stuff makes sense: less than 2% of people in India currently pay income tax (working in cash and avoiding tax is normal), many property purchases are done in cash, and, of course, having a system heavily skewed to cash makes bribery and general corruption easier than it would otherwise be.
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
But will cancelling notes in this way help? It could make a start.
Clearly, those with large amounts of cash are now going to have to figure out how to legitimise it (although those with very large amounts are highly unlikely to be holding it in Rs1,000 notes). They will either have to open bank accounts and deposit them or sell them at a discount to those who will.
And the scheme will push more people into opening bank accounts which will at least get them inside the financial system and more likely to be taxable (and controllable via monetary policy) in the future.
Critics will say that this has been done twice before (1946 and 1978) and that there was no noticeable reduction in India's cash economy or corruption. But today is different. 30 years ago bank accounts weren't straightforward to open or use and the idea that cash wasn't required on a daily basis was obviously absurd (transferring took days, ATMs and debit cards barely existed, etc). That's not the case any more.
With that in mind, the key change here might not be the cancellation of the notes themselves (the state intends to produce new Rs500 and Rs2,000 notes soon ) but the limit on ATM withdrawals, something that will force those who spend more than £50-odd a day to start working within rather than outside the banking system (50% of Indians don't have a bank account).
"I have a family. There is no way that is going to be enough," restaurant owner Hussain Petiwala said of the Rs4,000 day limit in the Wall Street Journal. "How do you survive?"
The Reserve Bank of India's answer to that is likely to be a simple one: stop using cash. Go digital.
I also suspect that the rest of the world's central bankers are looking longingly at India today: the US Federal Reserve, the Bank of England and the European Central Bank would all love to be able to get up in the morning and ban all high-denomination banknotes (although for them it is less about the black market and more about making negative interest rates work). Let's hope India's move doesn't give them any ideas.
Sign up to Money Morning
Our team, led by award winning editors, is dedicated to delivering you the top news, analysis, and guides to help you manage your money, grow your investments and build wealth.
Merryn Somerset Webb started her career in Tokyo at public broadcaster NHK before becoming a Japanese equity broker at what was then Warburgs. She went on to work at SBC and UBS without moving from her desk in Kamiyacho (it was the age of mergers).
After five years in Japan she returned to work in the UK at Paribas. This soon became BNP Paribas. Again, no desk move was required. On leaving the City, Merryn helped The Week magazine with its City pages before becoming the launch editor of MoneyWeek in 2000 and taking on columns first in the Sunday Times and then in 2009 in the Financial Times
Twenty years on, MoneyWeek is the best-selling financial magazine in the UK. Merryn was its Editor in Chief until 2022. She is now a senior columnist at Bloomberg and host of the Merryn Talks Money podcast - but still writes for Moneyweek monthly.
Merryn is also is a non executive director of two investment trusts – BlackRock Throgmorton, and the Murray Income Investment Trust.
-
Will a Santa Rally bring festive cheer to investor portfolios this year?
Investors will be hoping for a seasonal stock market boost in December
By Marc Shoffman Published
-
ChatGPT turns two: how has it impacted markets?
Two years on from ChatGPT’s explosive launch into the public sphere, we assess the impact that it has had on stock markets and the world of technology
By Dan McEvoy Published
-
Beating inflation takes more luck than skill – but are we about to get lucky?
Opinion The US Federal Reserve managed to beat inflation in the 1980s. But much of that was down to pure luck. Thankfully, says Merryn Somerset Webb, the Bank of England may be about to get lucky.
By Merryn Somerset Webb Published
-
Rishi Sunak can’t fix all our problems – so why try?
Opinion Rishi Sunak’s Spring Statement is an attempt to plaster over problems the chancellor can’t fix. So should he even bother trying, asks Merryn Somerset Webb?
By Merryn Somerset Webb Published
-
Young people are becoming a scarce resource – we should value them more highly
Opinion In the last two years adults have been bizarrely unkind to children and young people. That doesn’t bode well for the future, says Merryn Somerset Webb.
By Merryn Somerset Webb Published
-
Ask for a pay rise – everyone else is
Opinion As inflation bites and the labour market remains tight, many of the nation's employees are asking for a pay rise. Merryn Somerset Webb explains why you should do that too.
By Merryn Somerset Webb Published
-
Why central banks should stick to controlling inflation
Opinion The world’s central bankers are stepping out of their traditional roles and becoming much more political. That’s a mistake, says Merryn Somerset Webb.
By Merryn Somerset Webb Published
-
How St Ives became St Tropez as the recovery drives prices sky high
Opinion Merryn Somerset Webb finds herself at the epicentre of Britain’s V-shaped recovery as pent-up demand flows straight into Cornwall’s restaurants and beaches.
By Merryn Somerset Webb Published
-
The real problem of Universal Basic Income (UBI)
Merryn's Blog April employment numbers showed 75 per cent fewer people in the US returned to employment compared to expectations. Merryn Somerset-Webb explains how excessive government support is causing a shortage of labour.
By Merryn Somerset Webb Published
-
Why an ageing population is not necessarily the disaster many people think it is
Opinion We’ve got used to the idea that an ageing population is a bad thing. But that’s not necessarily true, says Merryn Somerset Webb.
By Merryn Somerset Webb Published