Two of the largest UK supermarkets appear to have shaken off competition from discount rivals after reporting bumper Christmas results in a boost for investors.
Many shoppers have turned to lower-cost supermarket brands such a Aldi and Lidl amid high inflation and the cost of living crisis but Tesco and Sainsbury’s have bucked the trend over Christmas as households splashed out during the festive period.
Both brands have reported their “biggest ever Christmas".
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Tesco said like-for like-sales rose 3.8% over Christmas, with sales of food up by 4.7%, accompanied by a hike of 15.5% in its Finest range.
The supermarket giant has issued full-year guidance for adjusted operating profits of £2.9 billion.
Meanwhile, Sainsbury’s posted a 2.8% rise in underlying sales for its third quarter to 4 January, with grocery sales up 4.1%. The supermarket brand said this was driven by strong demand for party food, Champagne and sparkling wine.
However, general merchandise and clothing sales in Sainsbury's stores fell 0.1% and were down 1.4% for its Argos business.
It is predicting profits of £1.01 billion to £1.06 billion during 2025 and has even given staff a 5% pay rise.
This is echoed by data company Kantar which reported that household spending on take-home groceries hit a record high this Christmas at £460 on average.
Tesco was dubbed the supermarket winner, with growth across its convenience, superstore and online channels contributing to a 5% increase in sales over the 12 weeks to 29 December. Its 0.8 percentage point share gain was the biggest of any supermarket, taking its hold of the market to 28.5%, Kantar said.
Sainsbury’s achieved its highest market share since December 2019 at 16% after sales of 3.5%.
Despite these boosts, the share price of both supermarket brands remain down as they continue to battle market competition and economic uncertainty as well as tax rises such as higher employer national insurance rates.
“The UK economy’s broader concerns still loom large,” says Mark Crouch, market analyst at investment platform eToro.
“Despite strong Christmas numbers, investors remain cautious, wary of the ongoing cost of living crisis and the potential economic slowdown.”
Despite share price pressure, the dividend yields are attractive at 3.47% for Tesco and 5.13% for Sainsbury’s, giving investors plenty of food for thought.
Should investors add supermarkets to their portfolio?
UK supermarkets such as Tesco and Sainsbury’s are FTSE 100 stalwarts.
You may not get massive share price growth but they pay regular dividends, which can help boost an investment portfolio.
However, their recent share price performance highlights volatility in the retail sector amid rising costs and pressure from discount rivals.
The Tesco share price is down 2.41 per cent year to date but up 21 per cent annually.
Sainsbury’s share price is down 6.92% year-to-date and by 10 per cent annually.
Lucy Rumbold, equity research analyst at Quilter Cheviot says that while the top-line Christmas numbers for Tesco and Sainsbury’s may seem impressive, investors remain cautious about the outlook for the sector.
“The key challenge for listed supermarkets lies in the mounting cost pressures they face. Wage increases and higher National Insurance contributions are eating into profits,” she says.
“For example, its expected Tesco will see around £400 million in additional costs from these factors alone, effectively neutralising much of its £500 million annual cost-saving programme.
"Despite reiterating its profit guidance of £2.9 billion, the market had hoped for an upgrade, and this lack of optimism is weighing on sentiment."
Rumbold says the broader economic uncertainty also poses risks.
She adds: “The retail sector, especially supermarkets, is heavily exposed to UK-centric factors, including inflation, consumer confidence, and the potential for further tax increases. This makes investors wary of committing to stocks that rely so heavily on domestic spending.”
One factor on the side of brands such as Tesco and Sainsbury’s is that higher-income households are better positioned to absorb inflationary pressures and continue spending, Rumbold suggests, whereas budget retailers are feeling the pinch from their customer base being more heavily impacted by rising costs.
She adds: “For investors, Tesco and Sainsbury's remain well-managed businesses. Tesco, in particular, has demonstrated its ability to stabilise performance through operational efficiencies and strong Christmas trading.
"However, with rising costs and a lack of significant growth catalysts, these stocks may feel like they are running hard just to stand still.”
-
Fund flows flip positive in NovemberData from the Investment Association shows that two months of negative fund flows were reversed during the month of November as index trackers remain strong
-
The prime London property hotspots for homebuyer demandWe look at the areas in London which saw the largest increase in quarterly demand in the prime property market
