Hong Kong investors threaten legal action as UK banks drop their dividends

Retail investors in Hong Kong have threatened legal action against HSBC after UK regulators persuaded it to cancel its dividend, says the Financial Times. HSBC was one of five UK-based lenders that last week “bowed to pressure” from the UK’s Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA) to withhold its annual payments to shareholders. However, although the bank is headquartered in London, a third of its shares are owned by individual investors in Hong Kong, many of whom rely on the bank’s dividends for income. The decision has “reignited the debate”over whether HSBC’s headquarters should move to Asia.

You can see why HSBC’s shareholders and executives are cross, says Alec Macfarlane on Breakingviews. But not only does the agitation “lack class”, it is also short-sighted given that HSBC is also the “biggest provider of credit cards and mortgages” in Hong Kong and a “big lender” to small businesses, many of which are “under strain” thanks to the crisis. In any case, not only is the law very clear that HSBC can withdraw payouts “as and when it pleases”, but it’s also clear that “flying in the face” of HSBC’s regulators would harm shareholders even more.

Political showboating?

HSBC’s shareholders are not the only ones to feel angry, as the ban on dividends has been a “blow” to other banks’ shareholders too, says The Times. They “range from pension funds to private investors”. In the day after the move was announced, Standard Chartered’s share were off by 7.%, Barclays slid 12%, while Lloyds fell by 11.7% and RBS by 5.2%. The matter is also complicated by the fact that while investors have now been deprived of their final dividends for the lenders’ performance in 2019, top bankers “will already have been paid some of their cash bonuses”, which will be “difficult” to claw back.

Subscribe to MoneyWeek

Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE

Get 6 issues free

Sign up to Money Morning

Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter

Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter

Sign up

Banning bank dividends will hurt many of the “same savers and pension funds whose income has been ravaged by coronavirus”, says Ben Marlow in The Daily Telegraph. What’s more, the fact that even the PRA admits that current capital buffers are “more than sufficient” to cope with the impact of “severe global recessions” and market shocks means that the ban smacks of “political showboating”. Nevertheless, the huge amount of uncertainty about the impact and length of the crisis means that halting dividends “is absolutely the prudent thing to do”. It will also give banks additional capital to lend to the small and medium-sized firms that are the “beating heart” of the economy.

Shareholders on the other side of the Atlantic may soon be in the same boat. JPMorgan’s CEO Jamie Dimon says Wall Street’s largest bank may have to suspend its dividend, says Rob Davies in The Guardian. Dimon expects that even in the best case scenario, financial institutions will have to deal with the effects of a nasty downturn creating “financial pressures reminiscent of the banking crash more than a decade ago”.