Dark days for value investors

History suggests that cheap, unloved stocks usually have their day. But how long will value investors have to wait?

Value stocks – those that are cheap and unloved – have a long record of outperforming growth stocks – those that are expensive and popular. It’s very easy to make overly simplistic distinctions between “value” and “growth”, and not every “value” investor has had an awful time, just as not every “growth” investor has shot the lights out. But taking a broad view, betting on value rather than growth in the last five years has cost investors in the region of 6% a year, argued Norbert Keimling in a research piece for StarCapital in October. 

That’s a massive gap. So what’s going on? The problem for value stocks today is mean reversion – or the lack of it. Mean reversion refers to the tendency of a given trait or data series to move around a long-run average. If the series rises too far above the average, or falls too far below, it makes sense to bet on a reversal (at some point). Not every series is mean-reverting, but in the financial markets mean reversion is logical.

Subscribe to MoneyWeek

Become a smarter, better informed investor with MoneyWeek.

Company valuations are ultimately based on earnings and profitability. In a society built on free-market capitalism, a company that makes unusually high profits should attract a swarm of entrepreneurs, all competing to offer a better service at a lower cost. This should ensure that outsized profit margins are eroded away. (Similarly, if margins slide due to oversupply, then weaker firms will go out of business, pushing margins higher.) If profit margins revert to the mean, stockmarket valuations should too. 

However, says Keimling, in this cycle “many growth stocks have been able to maintain their above-average growth rates and profitability... much longer than in the past”. Why? Firstly, we’ve seen a major technological shift that has left both regulators and traditional businesses floundering. Secondly, low interest rates enable companies to borrow and raise money cheaply, with a focus on grabbing market share rather than immediate profitability. These two trends have been exacerbated by the flood of money into passive funds, which inevitably favour the biggest, most popular stocks.

Advertisement - Article continues below

The big question is: when might this change? Patience is a vital trait for value investors – but they may not have to wait too much longer. These factors are important, but none is permanent. And technology, the key “growth” sector, is now under pressure from regulators, trade wars, and – out of the blue – the effect of the coronavirus on supply chains. Meanwhile, as Keimling notes, in Europe the gap between the valuation of growth and value has only ever previously been this extreme at the peak of the tech bubble. “A more contrarian trade than value is currently hard to find.” 

I wish I knew what an IPO was, but I’m too embarrassed to ask

An initial public offering (IPO) represents the first time that a company sells shares in itself to institutional investors (such as pension funds) and often also to individuals (retail investors). This process is also known as “floating” or “going public”. Companies go public for a wide range of reasons. They may want to raise funds for expansion and choose to do so by selling part of the company rather than borrowing the money. Alternatively, the current owners – perhaps the original founders, or a private-equity fund – may wish to “exit” (ie, cash in on their investment).

An IPO is underwritten by one or more investment banks, which typically earn large fees from the process. A prospectus with details of the company and the offering is issued to potential buyers. The IPO price is typically based on expected demand from investors. 

If demand outstrips the number of shares on offer (the IPO is “oversubscribed”), then the underwriter will have to decide how to allocate the shares. If there aren’t enough buyers, then the underwriter agrees to purchase the surplus (hence the term “underwriter”). Occasionally – as with the very public disaster that was trendy office rental group WeWork’s attempted IPO last year , an IPO will be pulled due to lack of demand, but this is unusual.

More often, a newly listed company’s share price will enjoy a “bump” on the first day of trading. However, unless you are allocated shares before the company starts trading – which is unlikely with a “hot” stock – then you are unlikely to benefit from this initial jump.

Many studies suggest that IPOs underperform over the long run, although sometimes government privatisations (where the seller has less of an incentive to squeeze as much money as possible out of the buyers, who are, of course, also voters) can represent good opportunities (albeit sometimes only in the short term, as with Royal Mail). 



Share tips

Finding hidden treasure: value investing is back in fashion

Focusing on cheap stocks, historically a highly successful investment strategy, has been a disappointment over the past ten years. But the tide is sta…
28 Nov 2019
Investment strategy

How to be a value investor

Value investing is probably the purest form of contrarian investing out there. John Stepek explains what it is, and how to do it.
30 Jul 2019
Investment strategy

Value investing’s not dead yet

Rumours of the demise of value investing have been exaggerated. John Stepek looks at what could reinvigorate the strategy.
25 Jun 2019
Investment strategy

MoneyWeek's financial glossary

All those financial terms you wished you knew but were too embarrassed to ask about.
27 Mar 2020

Most Popular


What does the coronavirus crisis mean for UK house prices?

With the whole country in lockdown, the UK property market is closed for business. John Stepek looks at what that means for UK house prices, housebuil…
27 Mar 2020
UK Economy

The UK’s bailout of the self employed comes with a hidden catch

The chancellor’s £6.5bn bailout of the self employed is welcome. But it has hidden benefits for the taxman, says Merryn Somerset Webb.
27 Mar 2020

Gold is hard to find right now – so should you be buying?

With demand through the roof and the physical metal hard to find, it's not the best time to buy gold. But right now, says Dominic Frisby, you want to …
25 Mar 2020
Share tips

Share tips of the week

MoneyWeek’s comprehensive guide to the best of this week’s share tips from the rest of the UK's financial pages.
27 Mar 2020