What is a robo-adviser and which is the best one for me?

If you're looking for the best investment platform then one of the options you may be considering is a robo-adviser. 

The two main routes of investing are traditionally using a financial adviser or doing it yourself.

A financial adviser can help formulate a plan for your money based on your goals that you can review regularly.

Subscribe to MoneyWeek

Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE

Get 6 issues free

Sign up to Money Morning

Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter

Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter

Sign up

In contrast, you can open an online account with a DIY investment platform and select the funds and stocks you want in your portfolio. 

You are on your own though.

Everything from fund selection to monitoring and rebalancing is down to you, though there may be some tools and guides to help you.

The DIY route can be cheaper than financial advice and you have ultimate control over your investments. But it does take some work and you do need some knowledge and confidence.

But there is a third way – trusting a robot.

Digital wealth managers provide a middle ground between paying for and trusting a financial adviser with your money or the DIY approach.

A robo-adviser is an automated online investment platform that tailors a portfolio to reflect your goals and risk appetite.

Most will ask you to complete a short online questionnaire to determine your attitude to risk.

You may also be asked how much you are willing to invest and your investment target and timeframe.

The platform will then allocate you one of a number of portfolios with differing levels of risk and potential return.

Its algorithms select the investments in each portfolio, monitoring and adjusting them in response to changing market conditions.

Users then typically pay an annual platform fee and for underlying fund charges.

Most build the portfolios using exchange-traded funds (ETFs), although some select individual securities.

Using ETFs helps keep the cost of investing down, so using a robo-platform can also be cheaper than a financial adviser and some DIY platforms depending which one you use and the investments you make.

Be aware, though, that while robo-advisers may have very clever algorithms, they are not infallible and investment returns are not guaranteed. As with all investing, the value of any investment can go down as well as up and you may end up with less money than you started with.

The best robo-advisers 

Nutmeg

Nutmeg is one of the oldest robo-advisers in the UK, founded in 2011, and has won a number of awards over the years. Its fees depend on the investing style you select.

Its fixed allocation product has a fee of 0.45% up to £100,000 ad then 0.25% beyond, rising to 0.75% on the first £100,000 in its socially responsible, smart alpha and fully managed products and 0.35% beyond.

This is before fund costs, which start from 0.20% for its fixed allocation and fully managed portfolios.

It has ten portfolios each in the fully managed and socially responsible categories and five smart alpha or fixed allocation portfolios, which Nutmeg defines as “globally diversified portfolios of ETFs designed to align with your risk preference and goals”.

The minimum investment is £500 for its ISA, general investment and pension products or just £100 for its Lifetime ISA and Junior ISA.

Moneyfarm

Moneyfarm was founded in 2012 with the mission of making investing more simple. 

There are fourteen globally diversified risk-rated portfolios on offer for investors to choose from, seven full managed classic portfolios and seven fully managed sustainable portfolios. Moneyfarm is actively managed and requires a minimum investment of £500. It has a tiered fee model structure, which means you pay lower fees the more you invest. Moneyfarm charges fees on a sliding scale from 0.75% on accounts with capital up to £10,000 to 0.35% for accounts of more than £500,000. There is a cheaper fixed allocation version where your portfolio isn’t actively managed but is just rebalanced once a year. The pricing is also tiered and goes from 0.45% between £500 and £100,000 to 0.25% on more than £500,000. Its average fund fee is 0.20%.

InvestEngine

InvestEngine has ten growth portfolios and three income portfolios, investing in a choice of 500 ETFs. It provides two main ways to invest depending on your risk appetite. Novice investors can choose a managed portfolio which involves InvestEngine making day to day decisions for a fee of 0.25%. There is no fee for investors who choose to build the portfolios themselves. This makes InvestEngine one of the cheapest robo advisers on the market.

InvestEngine requires a minimum investment of £100 to create a portfolio.

Chip

Chip, well known for savings, has launched investment portfolios, managed by asset management giant BlackRock. It allows you to choose from three funds: Adventurous, Cautious and Balanced. Its basic account has an annual fee of 0.5% on invested money (you can also hold cash) and its “Chip X” plan which gives access to the full range of investments (and is necessary if you want to open a stocks and shares Isa) and costs £5.99 a month or £65.05 annually. This means you don’t pay any platform charges but fund fees still apply. A minimum deposit of £1 is required. 

Wealthify

Wealthify allows you to invest in three main plans: general investment account, Wealthify Stocks and Shares investment ISA, a Wealthify Pension and Wealthify Junior Stocks and Shares ISA. The options are all also available as ethical plans if you choose to invest ethically.

Wealthify charges a flat fee of 0.6% irrespective of whether you are investing £1,000 or £100,000 plus around 0.16% in investment charges. So it is a good option if you have a smaller amount to invest, especially as Wealthify requires a minimum investment of £1. 

The pros and cons of robo-advisers

Pros

Low cost. This is one of the biggest reasons why people opt for using a robo-adviser compared to a traditional discretionary wealth manager. ETFs tend to be cheaper than active funds that financial advisers may opt for.

Advisers charge an average of 2.4% for initial advice and 0.8% for ongoing monitoring and support, according to the Financial Conduct Authority.

That can save you money on a large investment portfolio each year, particularly over the long-term. For example, the annual fee on a £100,000 portfolio would be £800 when using the average advice figures but that would be almost halved to £450 when paying 0.45% with a robo-adviser. Additionally, the average advised customer has more than £150,000 of assets under advice, according to the FCA whereas you can start with as little as £1 on a robo platform.

Greater variety. Robo-advisers’ offerings are often considered to be more diverse as they tend to invest in ETFs covering a broad range of asset classes including stocks and bonds, with the exact allocation depending on your risk appetite. You may be able to invest in ETFs on a DIY platform but the range could be more limited. 

Cons

A lack of individualisation. While prospective customers fill in a questionnaire to ascertain their investment preferences, customers can still be placed in a very broad category. 

Not good for short-term investments or trading. Robo-advisers are better suited for longer-term investments. While portfolios run by robo-advisers are usually considered to be quite diverse, they aren’t immune from usual fluctuations that can occur in any portfolio and are more suited to those investors who have longer investing time horizons.

No ongoing support: A financial adviser can build a plan that fits in with your whole lifestyle and other expenses and can track how close you are to your target based on all your income and expenses. A robo-adviser may only provide an idea of how your portfolio on its platform is performing and it can be hard to get context of how this fits into your wider plan. Plus, you can’t ring a robot if you are worried about the markets and the impact on your portfolio whereas an adviser could provide reassurances and stop you taking too much money out and even putting too much in.