Would you trust a computer with your money? That was the question posed on the cover of The Statist magazine in 1966. It seems like a silly question now, but don’t forget how enormously times have changed.
The same magazine also wondered if it was a good idea to pay workers with cheques. Sure, it saved on the hours spent collecting cash from the bank, guarding it, checking it, sorting it and putting it in wage packets, but, in the UK at least, it came with legal problems: the 1831 Truck Act, designed to prevent payment in “scrip”, demanded that all workers were paid with the “coin of the realm”. And not all workers were mad for it, as it transferred the work of cash collection from the bank to them.
It would only work, said The Statist, if bank accounts became widely used, adding: “Perhaps the womenfolk will have some influence on this.”
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
The shift to passive investing has huge consequences
Back to your money and computers. The article was written as 200 financial analysts gathered at a conference in Noordwijk in the Netherlands to discuss the huge computers they had left behind in their offices and the extent to which those machines might be better at picking portfolios than people. Not everyone was having it: naysayers pointed out that there was no way to program the “attributes of an agile human mind into a computer”.
In the 50-plus years since, the naysayers have comprehensively lost the argument. Almost all investors trust computers with at least some of their savings; a good 40% of US assets are now passively managed. Most evidence suggests the agile human mind is not required: after fees, the average passively run fund tends to outperform the average actively-run fund.
You can fiddle around with numbers and regions and find data to blur this a little: active investment works better outside the US and ordinary investors tend to congregate in the better-performing active funds. But whatever you might think of it, the shift has had huge consequences. It has made investing simple and cheap for many millions of people – and that’s a good thing – but it also has given immense power to the big passive managers. In the US, one of BlackRock, Vanguard or State Street is the largest single shareholder in the majority of big companies. That might not be so good.
Does passive investing drive inflation?
There is also a chance that the rise of passive investing is one of the many factors driving a new bias to inflation globally.
This could happen in two ways. First, it might reduce competitive pressure in the market. Active investors aim to pick winners; if they want to hold an airline, for example, they will look for the one they think is the best and root for it to outperform others.
Passive investors make no such decision; they will hold all the airlines in an index and, rather than wanting one to do particularly well, they’ll want them all to do just fine. That’s not exactly the kind of attitude that encourages the competitive pressures that keep prices down.
But there’s also a second possibility here – passive investing is effectively momentum investing (as things get more expensive, the computers automatically buy more of them).
This creates an odd dynamic where expensive stocks get more expensive and cheap ones just stay cheap. That matters to value investors (they like to buy low and sell high, not buy low and hold low indefinitely), but it might also make a difference to prices.
In a letter to investors last year, David Einhorn of Greenlight Capital suggested that the low valuations of industrial companies might in themselves be inflationary. If traditional industrial companies have low valuations, and hence an implicitly high cost of equity, it makes sense for holders of the stock to demand that dividend payouts and share buybacks take priority over capacity expansion: if the market attributes little value to your business, why expand it?
That leads to continued under-investment and, due to lack of new supply, to “sustained higher prices in a number of industries”, wrote Einhorn. If prices stay high for a long time – so long that even the world’s central banks have to accept that inflation is not “transitory” – that dynamic will change – but it hasn’t yet.
Mining is the classic here – and copper in particular. At the time of Einhorn writing the letter, Greenlight held Canadian miner Teck Resources. It takes eight to ten years to develop a copper mine, and while there are a couple of new ones coming on in the next few years, supply will be shrinking by the middle of the decade – and that’s at a time when the demand for the green revolution to move faster and faster is turbocharging demand for copper, and other metals such as lithium. Expect prices to rise for some time.
There is a similar dynamic in US housebuilding, in air freight and all manner of commodities.
What to buy
There are two messages here. One is that we should buy companies in this situation; the cash they throw off will always be welcome and the remaining active investors in the fund management sector will eventually notice, particularly as the inflation numbers continue to surprise them. And when the tide turns, it will turn fast.
For metals you might look to Amati’s Strategic Metals Fund which covers the theme pretty well. I’ve also chatted to Spencer Adair, co-manager of the Monks Investment Trust (LSE: MNKS) (which I hold) along these lines recently: he has invested in aggregates business Martin Marietta for similar reasons. You can listen to that here on the MoneyWeek Podcast here.
Finally, don’t forget big oil: there’s a reason the Biden administration has asked China, India and Japan to coordinate the release of some of their strategic stockpiles of oil with the US – supply is a bit short.
The second message is less straightforward: perhaps we should not have trusted computers with quite so much of our money. There is still something to be said for the agile human mind.
• This article was first published in the Financial Times
Merryn Somerset Webb started her career in Tokyo at public broadcaster NHK before becoming a Japanese equity broker at what was then Warburgs. She went on to work at SBC and UBS without moving from her desk in Kamiyacho (it was the age of mergers).
After five years in Japan she returned to work in the UK at Paribas. This soon became BNP Paribas. Again, no desk move was required. On leaving the City, Merryn helped The Week magazine with its City pages before becoming the launch editor of MoneyWeek in 2000 and taking on columns first in the Sunday Times and then in 2009 in the Financial Times
Twenty years on, MoneyWeek is the best-selling financial magazine in the UK. Merryn was its Editor in Chief until 2022. She is now a senior columnist at Bloomberg and host of the Merryn Talks Money podcast - but still writes for Moneyweek monthly.
Merryn is also is a non executive director of two investment trusts – BlackRock Throgmorton, and the Murray Income Investment Trust.
In the doghouse: hundreds of investment funds are underperforming - is it time to sell?
News The latest Spot The Dog research from Bestinvest reveals 151 funds are failing to beat their benchmark. We reveal the worst performers
By Marc Shoffman Published
Nationwide: House prices creep up for the first time in over a year
Nationwide’s latest house price index reveals property prices are finally rising. Will this pattern continue in 2024?
By Vaishali Varu Published
Halifax: House price slump continues as prices slide for the sixth consecutive month
UK house prices fell again in September as buyers returned, but the slowdown was not as fast as anticipated, latest Halifax data shows. Where are house prices falling the most?
By Kalpana Fitzpatrick Published
Rents hit a record high - but is the opportunity for buy-to-let investors still strong?
UK rent prices have hit a record high with the average hitting over £1,200 a month says Rightmove. Are there still opportunities in buy-to-let?
By Marc Shoffman Published
Pension savers turn to gold investments
Investors are racing to buy gold to protect their pensions from a stock market correction and high inflation, experts say
By Ruth Emery Published
Where to find the best returns from student accommodation
Student accommodation can be a lucrative investment if you know where to look.
By Marc Shoffman Published
Best investing apps
We round up the best investing apps. Looking for an easy-to-use app to help you start investing, keep track of your portfolio or make trades on the go?
By Ruth Emery Last updated
The top funds to invest in
Tips Tech-focused funds are continuing to attract private investors and Scottish Mortgage falls back into favour - we look at the top fund, trusts and stocks investors are pumping their money into in the last month
By Vaishali Varu Last updated
The world’s best bargain stocks
Searching for bargain stocks with Alec Cutler of the Orbis Global Balanced Fund, who tells Andrew Van Sickle which sectors are being overlooked.
By Andrew Van Sickle Published
Revealed: the cheapest cities to own a home in Britain
New research reveals the cheapest cities to own a home, taking account of mortgage payments, utility bills and council tax
By Ruth Emery Published