“Make your mind up, Glencore,” says Alistair Osborne in The Times. The FTSE 100 commodities giant, which is the world’s biggest listed coal producer, has scrapped plans to spin off its coal business. “One day coal is a filthy commodity” that harms a blue-chip’s environmental, social and governance (ESG) credentials, the next it is declared “a delightful mineral”, cash-generative and with a role to play in the energy transition.
Many energy companies and miners announced plans to step away from fossil fuels amid the 2021 ESG “frenzy”, say Harry Dempsey and Emma Dunkley in the Financial Times. Most greenhouse gas emissions come from fuels burnt for energy and heating, and coal accounts for more than any other source.
Over the past 12 months, however, some big investors have concluded that ESG was a “fad”. Why? Money talks and coal is still a cash spinner. Bank RBC estimates the fuel will net Glencore about $6 billion in 2024, roughly a third of total earnings, notes Karen Kwok on Breakingviews.
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Is coal back in business?
The energy crisis that followed Russia’s 2022 invasion of Ukraine prompted investors to re-evaluate fossil fuels. A “war premium” and surging costs for natural gas (coal’s main competitor) saw thermal coal benchmarks top $400 a tonne two years ago, says a report from the International Energy Agency. Prices have since slipped about two-thirds from those highs. Newcastle coal futures, the Asian benchmark, are currently trading above $145 a tonne. Greater use of green alternatives should see coal demand first “plateau” and then gradually decline. “Global coal consumption in 2026 is set to be 2.3% lower than in 2023.”
Waning consumption comes as coal production hits new highs, says Megha Mandavia in The Wall Street Journal. Top producers Indonesia and Australia ramped up exports last year, with global output increasing 1.8% to a record 8.7 billion tonnes in 2023. “Coal’s glow has somewhat dimmed” as the resulting glut depresses prices.
Rich countries are rapidly decarbonising – both the US and EU slashed coal consumption by more than a fifth in 2023, says The Economist. But prices are still higher than they were before the 2022 energy crisis. Developing countries are replacing demand lost in the rich world. China, India and Southeast Asia consume three-quarters of global supply, compared with a third in 2000. Emerging economies are also transitioning away from coal, but supply looks set to contract before demand does. ESG concerns have deterred banks from financing new mines and “acquiring permits... is hellish”. With demand and supply in a volatile race to the bottom, some speculators spy an opportunity to turn a profit. But trading coal over the next few years will be a risky game.
This article was first published in MoneyWeek's magazine. Enjoy exclusive early access to news, opinion and analysis from our team of financial experts with a MoneyWeek subscription.
-
Fund flows rose in April but did investors sell in May?ISA season prompted the highest level of inflows into investment funds during April but the mood may have changed in May
-
Pension Schemes Bill: what’s changing and what it means for youThe government’s latest reforms to pensions are designed to make saving for retirement easier and better value for money – but will they leave you better off?
-
Why are energy bills so expensive in the UK?Electricity bills in the UK are higher than in any comparable rich country. Some blame the net-zero zealotry of the government for that. What is really to blame for high energy bills?
-
Solar investing: is it too risky?NextEnergy Solar Fund’s steep discount reflects doubts about high debts and the sustainability of its dividend. What does it mean for solar investors?
-
Why undersea cables are under threat – and how to protect themUndersea cables power the internet and are vital to modern economies. They are now vulnerable
-
Woodside Energy: an undervalued energy playWoodside Energy offers a cheap way to invest in the growth of the global LNG market. Should you invest?
-
How businesses can cut energy costs and boost efficiencyHere's how small businesses can monitor energy costs even though they don't benefit from the Ofgem energy price cap.
-
The nobbling of Britain’s nuclear energy sectorThe UK once led the world in atomic power, but now it’s a has-been. The malaise is due to the left’s opposition to the sector and decisions taken by the Blair government.
-
Look to space to fix the energy crisisSolar energy from space and a type of helium on the Moon look promising.
-
Will the gas market keep inflating?Analysis Energy prices are exploding in value, and the European market has been particularly hit hard. Alex Rankine explains whether gas prices will still march higher or fall soon.
