Plenty more Brexit arguments to be settled yet

Many important negotiations remain to be sealed in our deal with the EU. “No deal is better than a bad deal” is the way to play it, says Matthew Lynn

We thought it was all over. After years of wrangling, stand-offs, walk-outs and arguments, the UK and the EU finally reached a trade deal just before Christmas, and with only days remaining before the transitional arrangement expired at the end of the old year. And yet, just when you thought we could safely forget about wrangling with Michel Barnier, it turns out the arguments are set to continue. 

Talks will start this week between the UK and the EU over a deal for financial services. There will inevitably be lots of pressure to make concessions and secure access to the European market for the UK’s banks, insurers and asset managers. That should be resisted. In truth, the same hardball “no deal is better than a bad deal” stance will work as well for the City as it did for the rest of the country. 

Playing hardball makes sense

Over the next couple of months, British officials will have to try and negotiate “equivalence” rules that will allow City firms to sell their services across the EU. That matters a lot. Financial services are one of the UK’s largest exports industries, and one of the most lucrative. The EU market has been hugely important, allowing the City to become the dominant financial centre for the whole of the continent. There can be no argument that losing access to that market would come as a huge blow. 

It is not going to be easy to strike a deal. Plenty of European countries are suspicious of the UK’s role in finance. The French, Germans and, increasingly, the Italians as well, would like a share of that trade. Many of them will be uneasy about the main trading and debt centre for the euro being outside their regulatory control. Plenty of them will calculate they should make life as hard for the UK as possible, not least because it will increase the chances of banks relocating to mainland Europe.  

At the same time, many City banks, lobbyists and asset managers will be desperate to secure access to the single market, and they will be urging the government to make whatever concessions are necessary to secure it. We can expect to see lots of scare stories about the huge losses the UK economy will face if it doesn’t reach a deal. The trouble is, we could easily find our finance industry essentially regulated from Brussels forever. The City should instead back the UK’s negotiators to be robust and ready to walk away without a deal if they have to. Here’s why.

First, the strategy works well. The EU is not as powerful as it pretends to be, or as its more enthusiastic supporters claim. Sure, it is an important market for British financial firms. But it also depends on the City to raise the vast amounts of debt that eurozone governments and companies need. In the main negotiations, the EU became a lot more willing to compromise as soon as the British government made it clear it would walk away without a deal if it had to. The same will be true for financial services. 

Europe is not the only game in town

Second, there are plenty of markets outside the EU where the City can grow instead. The eurozone accounts for 16% of the global economy, and with slower growth, and accelerating development in Asia and Africa, that is getting smaller all the time. The City has always done best as a global finance hub rather than as merely a domestic or regional one. It might well lose some business over the next few years to Paris, Frankfurt and Amsterdam. But it can more than make up for that by expanding across the rest of the world. As an offshore, lightly regulated hub straddling time zones, and connecting Europe to the rest of the world, it might well find it can do a lot better than it ever did inside the EU.

It is important that the City gets these negotiations right. The City is one of the most important sectors of the British economy. The last thing we need is to commit ourselves to an EU rule book that will be hostile to artificial intelligence, robot trading, app-based insurance and banking, and all the other new technologies that should turbocharge the finance industry over the next decade. 

Recommended

Who is the richest person in the world?
Entrepreneurs

Who is the richest person in the world?

Jeff Bezos, Bill Gates and Elon Musk are among the richest people in the world, but the top spot belongs to someone else.
7 Jun 2023
The building blocks for an income strategy: resilience, growth and diversification
Advertisement Feature

The building blocks for an income strategy: resilience, growth and diversification

Iain Pyle, Investment Manager, Shires Income plc
7 Jun 2023
Saving vs investing: which is better to help you make more money?
Personal finance

Saving vs investing: which is better to help you make more money?

Saving has become a more attractive option with interest rates hitting the highest levels seen in years, but if you’re prepared to take some risk inve…
7 Jun 2023
Look beyond familiar stockmarkets for reliable returns in rough times
Share tips

Look beyond familiar stockmarkets for reliable returns in rough times

A professional investor tells us where he’d put his money. This week: Giles Parkinson, managing director of global funds at Close Brothers Asset Manag…
7 Jun 2023

Most Popular

Best savings accounts – June 2023
Savings

Best savings accounts – June 2023

Interest rates have been creeping up - we look at the best savings accounts on the market right now.
6 Jun 2023
Nationwide to give £100 cash boost to customers
Personal finance

Nationwide to give £100 cash boost to customers

Nationwide Building Society is giving customers £100 as it reinvests profits. Dubbed the Nationwide Fairer Share scheme, we look at who is eligible.
22 May 2023
How much will it cost you to retire early?
Pensions

How much will it cost you to retire early?

The pre-state pension income gap means couples may need an extra £136,000 if they want to retire at 60 – can you afford to retire early?
6 Jun 2023