What is a jubilee?
It is literally a trumpet, blasting out the news that it’s time to forgive all debt to protect the long-term interests of the whole community and polity. In the Jewish and Christian traditions, a jubilee (the word comes from “yobel”, the Hebrew for “trumpet”) was blown every 50 years to signal the Year of the Lord, in which all personal debts were cancelled.
According to the Mosaic Law – ie, the law given to Moses by God as set out in the Pentateuch or Written Torah – in each jubilee year each household should recover its absent members; foreclosed land be returned to its former owners; indentured slaves set free and debts written off. For the details of Mosaic property rights and debt, see Leviticus 25.
Did this actually happen?
Yes. Until recently, some historians doubted a debt jubilee would have been possible in practice, or that such proclamations could have been enforced, says Michael Hudson, a US academic and author, in The Washington Post. But research by Assyriologists has found that “from the beginning of recorded history in the Near East, it was normal for new rulers to proclaim a debt amnesty upon taking the throne”. Instead of blowing a trumpet, the ruler “raised the sacred torch” to signal the amnesty.
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Such jubilees were not utopian or altruistic: they were a clear-sighted recognition that to maintain social order and political stability – and protect the long-term sustainability of economic life, commerce and peaceful rule – it is necessary to stop credit systems degenerating into the enslavement of debtors by their creditors. That way lie anarchy and violence.
When was the first jubilee?
According to anthropologist David Graeber, the author of Debt: The First 5,000 Years, the first recorded jubilee declaration was made in 2,400 BC, when the Sumerian king Enmetena declared a general debt cancellation in his kingdom. What’s more, his declaration marks the first time that the word “freedom” – here, the freedom of formerly indebted slaves – appears in any political document.
Indeed, the first word for freedom known in any language is the Sumerian “amargi” meaning “return to mother”, presumably because enslaved children in particular were allowed to return home. In other words, a debt jubilee is a recognition that economic life must be socially rooted if it is to be sustainable. If debts can’t be paid off, they won’t be – and it might be better for everyone if that can be addressed peacefully.
Why are you telling me all this?
Because the idea of a debt jubilee, which enjoyed a flurry of interest after the great financial crisis of the late 2000s, is getting renewed attention given the current global emergency. Back then, versions of a jubilee were backed by orthodox voices (such as Morgan Stanley’s influential chief economic Stephen Roach) as well as radical ones.
Roach argued for a grand out-of-court settlement between bond investors, banks and consumer groups – what he called a “great haircut” – to fix the underlying problem of excessive debt and jump-start the economy. Obviously, the idea is resurfacing now because the world is facing two simultaneous and overlapping crises, says the US legal scholar Katharina Pistor in The Guardian – namely, the coronavirus pandemic and the “economic threat it poses to our debt-fuelled economy”.
What is to be done?
We urgently need measures that keep financial markets working and protect businesses, conceivably in the form of government write-offs of corporate bonds bought with printed money to get through the crisis. But we also need debt relief, especially for households at the lower end of the income and wealth spectrum, says Pistor. Without that, the world faces a prolonged spiral of depression driven by corporate collapses and rapidly falling demand for goods and service. “To treat the economic fallout of coronavirus, governments should directly assume the debt of high-risk households,” she argues. Trying to get lenders to soften the terms of existing loans, as the US government did after the 2008 crisis, for example, “will be too slow to meet the current challenge”.
What’s the case in favour?
The same as it was in Sumeria and Babylonia: pragmatism and long-term stability. What the economic and social consequences of the current emergency will be are unknowable, but in a crashing global economy, “any demand that newly massive debts be paid to a financial class that has already absorbed most of the wealth gained since 2008 will only split our society further”, says Hudson.
Or we could take a lesson from 20th century history. After World War I, war debts and reparations bankrupted and further traumatised Germany, contributing to the global financial collapse of 1929-1931, the rise of fascism and ensuing horrors. By contrast, Germany’s “modern debt jubilee” of 1948, when the Allied Powers replaced the reichsmark with the Deutsche mark, wiped out 90% of government and private debt and paved the way for West Germany’s economic miracle.
What’s the case against?
Debts must be repaid, or credit would dry up and commerce would be impossible. Writing it off encourages future recklessness. And there’s no guarantee writing off debts would stimulate a recovery, since every liability is also an asset: every extra pound saved on debt repayments is also a pound cut off a lender’s capital or net worth, draining future confidence and investment. In addition, any country instituting a jubilee unilaterally risks capital flight.
For all these reasons, a debt jubilee would appear unthinkable – were it not for the fact that the current pandemic and economic meltdown involves all kinds of previously unthinkable state actions being announced every other day.
Simon Wilson’s first career was in book publishing, as an economics editor at Routledge, and as a publisher of non-fiction at Random House, specialising in popular business and management books. While there, he published Customers.com, a bestselling classic of the early days of e-commerce, and The Money or Your Life: Reuniting Work and Joy, an inspirational book that helped inspire its publisher towards a post-corporate, portfolio life.
Since 2001, he has been a writer for MoneyWeek, a financial copywriter, and a long-time contributing editor at The Week. Simon also works as an actor and corporate trainer; current and past clients include investment banks, the Bank of England, the UK government, several Magic Circle law firms and all of the Big Four accountancy firms. He has a degree in languages (German and Spanish) and social and political sciences from the University of Cambridge.
December 2023 NS&I Premium Bond winners - check now to see what you’ve won
If you hold money in NS&I Premium Bonds, you can check from today (2 December) to see if you have won in the December prize draw. Here’s how to check.
By Vaishali Varu Published
OpenAI – corporate drama unleashed
OpenAI, the firm behind ChatGPT, was in uproar as its boss was booted out, briefly snapped up by Microsoft and then brought back again.
By Dr Matthew Partridge Published
UK wages grow at a record pace
The latest UK wages data will add pressure on the BoE to push interest rates even higher.
By Nicole García Mérida Published
Trapped in a time of zombie government
It’s not just companies that are eking out an existence, says Max King. The state is in the twilight zone too.
By Max King Published
America is in deep denial over debt
The downgrade in America’s credit rating was much criticised by the US government, says Alex Rankine. But was it a long time coming?
By Alex Rankine Published
UK economy avoids stagnation with surprise growth
Gross domestic product increased by 0.2% in the second quarter and by 0.5% in June
By Pedro Gonçalves Published
Bank of England raises interest rates to 5.25%
The Bank has hiked rates from 5% to 5.25%, marking the 14th increase in a row. We explain what it means for savers and homeowners - and whether more rate rises are on the horizon
By Ruth Emery Published
UK wage growth hits a record high
Stubborn inflation fuels wage growth, hitting a 20-year record high. But unemployment jumps
By Vaishali Varu Published
UK inflation remains at 8.7% ‒ what it means for your money
Inflation was unmoved at 8.7% in the 12 months to May. What does this ‘sticky’ rate of inflation mean for your money?
By John Fitzsimons Published
VICE bankruptcy: how did it happen?
Was the VICE bankruptcy inevitable? We look into how the once multibillion-dollar came crashing down.
By Jane Lewis Published