The far-right AfD win big in German elections. So what now?
The far-right AfD celebrate a troubling win in Germany. Should politicians treat this warning seriously?
The far-right, populist Alternative for Germany (AfD) party is celebrating a “historic success” in local elections in the east of the country, says the BBC. The party topped the polls in the state of Thuringia, with almost a third of the vote – nine points ahead of the centre-right Christian Democratic Union (CDU). It also came a close second to the CDU in Saxony. This gives the far right its first victory in a state election since World War II.
The AfD’s rise is “more troubling” than those of equivalents in France or Italy, says the Financial Times. While most hard-right parties in Europe have tried to moderate or at least downplay their most unsavoury elements, AfD members “openly espouse ethno-nationalist and xenophobic views”. The AfD leader in Thuringia, Björn Höcke, has previously been convicted of using banned Nazi slogans.
"That nearly a third of voters in Thuringia and Saxony voted for it is deeply unsettling."
Try 6 free issues of MoneyWeek today
Get unparalleled financial insight, analysis and expert opinion you can profit from.
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Can the AfD last?
Other parties refuse to cooperate with the AfD, so the far-right won’t end up in power, and state governments don’t have any direct input on foreign policy anyway, says The Economist. However, the “large chunk” of seats the AfD now occupies will force the other parties into “ideologically garbled coalitions”. These are likely to include the BSW, producing state governments that are “precision-engineered for chaos”.
Already, Sahra Wagenknecht, the BSW’s founder, is demanding that any coalitions that her party takes part in are committed to rejecting chancellor Olaf Scholz’s recent agreement to station long-range American missiles in Germany from 2026.
What does this mean for German elections?
These elections are an “emphatic slap around the chops” of the German political establishment, says Oliver Moody in The Times. The current coalition is deeply unpopular, while the established opposition has failed “to squeeze out the hard right”.
The fact that nearly half the voters in Thuringia and more than 40% in Saxony “have turned their backs on the established parties” suggests that “a large share of the electorate clearly feel that the political system no longer works for them”.
These elections have been an "emphatic slap around the chops"
Oliver Moody, The Times
While Germany “is not in any sense heading back to the early Thirties”, politicians of the mainstream parties urgently need to “treat this warning with the seriousness it deserves”.
At the very least, the mainstream German parties must stop telling voters, especially those in eastern states, that “their concerns aren’t real”, says Katja Hoyer in The Guardian. Particularly important issues include immigration, energy prices and the economy, as well as more generally “a deeper fear for the economic and political future of the country”. While such topics may be “uncomfortable” for centrists to discuss, ignoring them, or attempting to shut down discussion, effectively gives the AfD “a monopoly over those issues”. What’s more, it should be possible to have a “constructive debate” without “plunging into populism”.
This article was first published in MoneyWeek's magazine. Enjoy exclusive early access to news, opinion and analysis from our team of financial experts with a MoneyWeek subscription.
-
Do you face ‘double whammy’ inheritance tax blow? How to lessen the impactFrozen tax thresholds and pensions falling within the scope of inheritance tax will drag thousands more estates into losing their residence nil-rate band, analysis suggests
-
Has the market misjudged Relx?Relx shares fell on fears that AI was about to eat its lunch, but the firm remains well placed to thrive
-
In defence of GDP, the much-maligned measure of growthGDP doesn’t measure what we should care about, say critics. Is that true?
-
Reach for the stars to boost Britain's space industryopinion We can’t afford to neglect Britain's space industry. Unfortunately, the government is taking completely the wrong approach, says Matthew Lynn
-
"Botched" Brexit: should Britain rejoin the EU?Brexit did not go perfectly nor disastrously. It’s not worth continuing the fight over the issue, says Julian Jessop
-
'AI is the real deal – it will change our world in more ways than we can imagine'Interview Rob Arnott of Research Affiliates talks to Andrew Van Sickle about the AI bubble, the impact of tariffs on inflation and the outlook for gold and China
-
Tony Blair's terrible legacy sees Britain still sufferingOpinion Max King highlights ten ways in which Tony Blair's government sowed the seeds of Britain’s subsequent poor performance and many of its current problems
-
How a dovish Federal Reserve could affect youTrump’s pick for the US Federal Reserve is not so much of a yes-man as his rival, but interest rates will still come down quickly, says Cris Sholto Heaton
-
New Federal Reserve chair Kevin Warsh has his work cut outOpinion Kevin Warsh must make it clear that he, not Trump, is in charge at the Fed. If he doesn't, the US dollar and Treasury bills sell-off will start all over again
-
How Canada's Mark Carney is taking on Donald TrumpCanada has been in Donald Trump’s crosshairs ever since he took power and, under PM Mark Carney, is seeking strategies to cope and thrive. How’s he doing?
