Great frauds in history: Richard Whitney and the White Knight’s pensions raid

Richard Whitney went from being the “White Knight” of Wall Street and president of the New York Stock Exchange to a convicted embezzler.

Richard Whitney © Alamy

Richard Whitney © Alamy

Richard Whitney was born in Massachusetts in 1888 and graduated from Harvard before founding his own brokerage in 1910 in New York, purchasing a seat on the New York Stock Exchange two years later. His role as J. P. Morgan's main broker helped him get elected to the NYSE's board of governors in 1919 and he eventually served four terms as the exchange's president, retiring in 1935. He played a role as the head of a pool of financiers that tried to halt the Wall Street Crash by buying large numbers of blue-chip stocks. The attempt proved unsuccessful, but it brought him widespread fame as the "White Knight" of Wall Street.

What was the scam?

Although a successful broker, Whitney was an awful speculator. His worst investment was in the Distilled Liquor Corporation, which manufactured applejack in the hope that the drink would benefit from the repeal of prohibition. It proved unpopular and shares in the company plummeted. Convinced that they would rebound, Whitney borrowed money in order to prop up the share price. As the price tumbled further and Whitney's credit line was exhausted, he turned to embezzlement, stealing money from various pension funds that he managed. Overall, he stole $1m ($17.8.m in today's money) from his clients, to add to the $27.4m ($488m) he had borrowed.

What happened next?

By 1938 rumours spread that Whitney's brokerage, Richard Whitney & Co, was insolvent. Eventually, the complaints grew so vociferous that the New York Stock Exchange demanded to inspect his books, a power it had that Whitney had unsurprisingly opposed while he was president. As a result, his company was suspended from the stock exchange and Whitney was quickly exposed as an embezzler. He attempted to use his status to get the charges discreetly dropped, but he was arrested, convicted and eventually sentenced to between five and ten years in jail. He was out in less than four.

Lessons for investors

Whitney's brother, George, stepped in and repaid all the lost money. But this took some time, so Richard's victims would have seen the value of their cash eroded by inflation. The lessons are obvious: first, steer clear of brokers or managers who aren't always prepared to be 100% transparent on their holdings; and second, think very carefully before putting more money into investments that have already turned out to be losers.

Recommended

The MoneyWeek Wealth Summit: silver linings for investors amid the global gloom
Investment strategy

The MoneyWeek Wealth Summit: silver linings for investors amid the global gloom

MoneyWeek’s annual conference featured plenty of optimism and investment ideas.
29 Nov 2022
The MoneyWeek Wealth Summit this Friday - everything you need to know.
Investment strategy

The MoneyWeek Wealth Summit this Friday - everything you need to know.

Andrew Van Sickle runs through the speakers and topics under discussion at the upcoming MoneyWeek Wealth Summit. Everything you need to know about inv…
24 Nov 2022
Investing in a recession: 5 moves investors should make now
Investment strategy

Investing in a recession: 5 moves investors should make now

As we enter a recession, here’s what investors should do with their portfolios.
23 Nov 2022
What is a deficit?
Too embarrassed to ask

What is a deficit?

When we talk about government spending and the public finances, we often hear the word ‘deficit’ being used. But what is a deficit, and why does it ma…
18 Nov 2022

Most Popular

Fan heater vs oil heater – which is cheaper?
Personal finance

Fan heater vs oil heater – which is cheaper?

Sales of portable heaters have soared, as households look to cut their energy costs. But which is better: a fan heater or an oil heater? We put them t…
21 Nov 2022
Stock market crash? This time it’s (slightly) different
Stockmarkets

Stock market crash? This time it’s (slightly) different

The bears expecting a stock market crash have got it wrong, says Max King.
30 Nov 2022
Is it cheaper to leave the heating on low all day?
Personal finance

Is it cheaper to leave the heating on low all day?

The weather is getting colder and energy bills are rising, but is it really cheaper to leave the heating on low all day or should you only turn it on …
1 Dec 2022