The MoneyWeek Wealth Summit is this Friday book now if you haven't already! You don't want to miss this.
As regular readers will know, I've been keeping an eye on the attempts to list Saudi Aramco.
The world's biggest oil company is having trouble getting enough interest from buyers.
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
And yet, it appears that the sale is going ahead.
That speaks volumes about the lack of interest in oil stocks right now.
Saudi Arabia is trying to flog off its golden goose
Saudi Aramco is the world's biggest oil producer. It's currently owned by the Saudi Arabian state.
Owning the world's biggest producer of one of the world's most precious resources should be a good thing. It's certainly made the Saudis rich.
Trouble is, when you have an easy source of riches, you tend not to look for other ones. Owning a golden goose can make you lazy.
How lazy? Well, oil comprises around 40% of the Saudi economy, brings in about 90% of government revenue, and accounts for 90% of exports.
This oil revenue funds a generous welfare state, which helps to pacify a population which might otherwise be prone to causing trouble (there are lots of young men with questionable skill levels and high levels of unemployment).
That's expensive though, even for a country with some of the lowest oil production costs in the world. To pay for it all, notes Tom Holland at research group Gavekal, Saudi Arabia needs an oil price of more than $80 a barrel. Right now, at $60-odd, the country is overspending by about 6% of GDP a year (ie, that's the deficit, which is pretty chunky by anyone's standards).
So, even at current oil prices, the goose isn't laying enough golden eggs. Moreover, when and if the goose stops laying altogether, the Saudi economy will be hugely exposed.
And that's where we are right now. Today, investors the world over are worrying that climate change legislation and the rise in ESG investing will kill off the golden geese in the fossil fuel business.
We've gone from the fear of "peak oil" on the supply side ("the oil is going to run out!"), to fear of "peak oil" on the demand side ("no one wants oil anymore!"). Greta Thunberg may be the latest public face of this movement but it's been bubbling under for several years now.
As Holland says, one factor in Saudi Arabia's decision to sell off Aramco is "the fear that come the 2030s or soon after, it could be left sitting on 300 billion barrels of 'stranded assets'".
In short, it needs money to diversify its economy according to a grandiose plan labelled Vision 2030. And all it's really got to fund that effort is oil.
Why Aramco's troubles are a good contrarian signal for oil investors
So the original plan was to offload about $100bn-worth of Saudi Aramco (5% of the company), which would have given the group a valuation of around $2trn.
That would have been punchy even in better times for oil. As it is, international investors have simply turned around and said: "No thanks".
Previous attempts to launch an IPO (initial public offering) the first came about four years ago have foundered at this stage. No $2trn, no deal.
But it seems Saudi Arabia is now keen enough to take what it can get. The decision has now been made simply to list Aramco locally, on the Saudi stock exchange, the Tadawul. On top of that, the company is now just looking to raise $25bn from the IPO the goal will be to sell 1.5% with a valuation of around $1.6trn$1.7trn.
This will mostly come from local investors, whose arms can be more easily twisted into demonstrating support. Indeed, as a few comedians have put it, it's starting to look less like an IPO and more like a Saudi wealth tax.
The thing is, to my eyes at least, the resistance to this listing is surprising. Sure, there are lots of elements that are unappealing, such as the fact that you'll be a minority shareholder alongside an authoritarian government, and the potential resulting reputational damage.
But these things have not put investors off buying non-voting shares in tech giants with poor reputations.
It's fair to say that the WeWork debacle won't have helped at a psychological level. Saudi Arabia is a big backer of SoftBank and a whiff of that failure will be hanging over Aramco.
But while Aramco would undoubtedly be expensive at $2trn, Saudi Arabia has made an effort to make it a bit more appealing offering a chunky dividend yield, for example.
I have to conclude that the real reason international investors don't want a piece of Aramco is simply because fossil fuels are unpopular right now. They've fallen victim to the "jam tomorrow" bubble. Oil is seen as the ultimate old-fashioned industry it throws off lots of cash, it's not remotely "woke", and most of its business is physical rather than intangible.
Now, to be clear, I don't think that Aramco itself warrants a contrarian "buy". As Holland points out, the Saudis face a real uphill battle to diversify and if they fail to do so then Aramco will be treated as even more of an emergency piggy bank.
But I do think that the failure to get this off the ground and Saudi Arabia's clear desperation to do so are indicative of deeply negative sentiment towards the sector. And that's usually a good sign for contrarians.
John is the executive editor of MoneyWeek and writes our daily investment email, Money Morning. John graduated from Strathclyde University with a degree in psychology in 1996 and has always been fascinated by the gap between the way the market works in theory and the way it works in practice, and by how our deep-rooted instincts work against our best interests as investors.
He started out in journalism by writing articles about the specific business challenges facing family firms. In 2003, he took a job on the finance desk of Teletext, where he spent two years covering the markets and breaking financial news. John joined MoneyWeek in 2005.
His work has been published in Families in Business, Shares magazine, Spear's Magazine, The Sunday Times, and The Spectator among others. He has also appeared as an expert commentator on BBC Radio 4's Today programme, BBC Radio Scotland, Newsnight, Daily Politics and Bloomberg. His first book, on contrarian investing, The Sceptical Investor, was released in March 2019. You can follow John on Twitter at @john_stepek.
King Charles banknotes to enter circulation in June
New banknotes featuring the King will enter circulation on 5 June – here’s what they will look like and what you need to know about your old notes.
By Katie Williams Published
Metro Bank to slash 5.22% savings rate for current customers- what’s the next best alternative?
Metro Bank is set to cut the rate on its best buy instant access saver for existing customers. Is there an alternative on the market and should you switch now?
By Vaishali Varu Published
As global powers fight it out, commodity prices are set to rocket
Analysis Commodity prices have been held down by globalisation. This trend is now rapidly reversing.
By Dominic Frisby Last updated
Is gold cheap relative to equities?
Analysis Dominic Frisby looks at the Dow-gold ratio and explains why gold is starting to appear inexpensive compared to equities.
By Dominic Frisby Published
Are UK house prices set to fall? It’s not so simple
Analysis Figures suggest UK house prices are starting to slide, but we shouldn’t take these numbers at face value, explains Rupert Hargreaves.
By Rupert Hargreaves Last updated
Are we heading for a commercial property crash?
Analysis The pandemic has reduced the demand for office spaces and permanently changed the office environment. But John Stepek says rising interest rates are a bigger threat to commercial property right now.
By John Stepek Published
Tesco looks well-placed to ride out the cost of living crisis – investors take note
Analysis Surging inflation is bad news for retailers. But supermarket giant Tesco looks better placed to cope than most, says Rupert Hargreaves.
By Rupert Hargreaves Published
It may not look like it, but the UK housing market is cooling off
Analysis Recent house price statistics show UK house prices rising. But John Stepek explains why the market is in fact slowing down and what this means for you.
By John Stepek Last updated
Think the oil price is high now? You ain’t seen nothing yet
Analysis The oil price has been on a tear in recent months. Dominic Frisby explains why oil in fact is still very cheap relative to other assets.
By Dominic Frisby Published
What can markets tell us about the economy and geopolitics?
Sponsored Markets have remained resilient despite Russia's war with Ukraine. Max King rounds up how reliable the stockmarket is in predicting economic outlooks.
By Max King Published