Editor's letter

Is capitalism doomed?

Unless the world’s multinational corporations get their act together, capitalism is heading for trouble, says Merryn Somerset Webb.

961-Greenland-634

Greenland for sale: several careful owners, great long-term investment

I'm currently presenting a show at Panmure House (Adam Smith's last and only surviving home) as part of Edinburgh's Fringe. There's no dancing, no acrobatics, no special effects and only a few jokes. It's just me and a couple of panellists (different every day through this Sunday) having a chat, Smith-salon style, about modern capitalism.

We cover a lot of ground. But the one thing that comes up again and again is the huge size, vast influence and often crappy behaviour of the world's multinational corporations. Unless this lot get their act together on executive pay, on treatment of suppliers, on tax and on consumer protections capitalism is doomed, say my panellists.

Read this week's newspapers, then, and you might think there is room for optimism. The Times points out that CEO pay in the UK has fallen 16% to a mere £4.7m, proof perhaps that "they are listening" to our discontent. They are now paid only 114 times as much as the average of other employees at their companies.

Better still, surely, is the news that one of America's biggest business groups (the Business Roundtable) has produced a new "statement of purpose". From now on shareholders are to be considered not as the prime beneficiary of a company's operations but just as one of five sets of stakeholders (the others are workers, customers, suppliers and communities). Isn't that nice?

Most of you will say yes. Very nice. We say no. It isn't nice. Big company CEOs have picked up today's political mood music. They know everyone's feeling a bit like my panels do. But they'd really like the status quo (the bit where they make fortunes running powerful oligopolies) to continue. So in order to head off real change being forced upon them, they are offering a little fiddling around the edges earning 114 times the average salary rather than 144 times, for example.

But this isn't enough. What we really need, if we want to return to a world of sustainable capitalism (the kind Adam Smith so believed in) is not a cabal of mega firms leading "reform", but a flood of competition forcing it. And that in turn means breaking down some of the barriers to entry (mostly regulatory) that have inhibited small-firm formation over the last decade.

Big firms love regulation because it creates barriers to entry (the Roundtable will be suggesting some new rules any day now). Governments love it too: all of them think more government is good government. But the truth is that if we want to dent the destructive power of very big business (and hence crony capitalism) we need to help smaller firms who hate it. Quite fast.

Outside these big macro discussions, I have been asking panellists what investmentthey would hold for ten years. So far no one has said Uber. But Tim Price of Price Value Partners has tipped gold. Russell Napier of ERICagrees over ten years, but suggests US Treasuries over two. James Ferguson of Macro Strategy Partners suggests oil and James Anderson of Baillie Gifford says disruptive innovations (you can short-cut this with his Scottish Mortgage Investment Trust). Otherwise, if you have an awful lot of cash to spare, you could make an offer for Greenland. That wouldn't be a bad thing to own long term.

Recommended

YouGov's Global Banking & Finance Report 2021

YouGov's Global Banking & Finance Report 2021

How COVID-19 is “changing finance” – a high-level overview of financial attitudes, preferences and habits in 17 global markets, encompassing payments,…
1 Mar 2021
What is “yield curve control” and why is it coming to a central bank near you?
Government bonds

What is “yield curve control” and why is it coming to a central bank near you?

Central banks around the world are determined not to let interest rates go up too quickly or by too much – a practice known as “yield curve control”. …
1 Mar 2021
The charts that matter: rising bond yields send markets into a tizz
Global Economy

The charts that matter: rising bond yields send markets into a tizz

Markets suffered a chaotic week as bond yields continued to climb. We look at how the week’s events have affected the charts that matter most to the g…
27 Feb 2021
How Big Tech was humbled Down Under
Tech stocks

How Big Tech was humbled Down Under

An Australian law forcing tech companies to share their profits with news organisations is a crucial test of the evolving power relations between gove…
27 Feb 2021

Most Popular

A beginner’s guide to bitcoin: what is bitcoin?
Bitcoin

A beginner’s guide to bitcoin: what is bitcoin?

As a completely novel concept for many people, bitcoin can take a little effort to get to grips with. In the first of a short series on the cryptocurr…
1 Mar 2021
A beginner’s guide to bitcoin: how to buy bitcoin
Bitcoin

A beginner’s guide to bitcoin: how to buy bitcoin

For the novice, buying bitcoin can be a daunting prospect. Here, Dominic Frisby outlines the process from start to finish.
2 Mar 2021
What is “yield curve control” and why is it coming to a central bank near you?
Government bonds

What is “yield curve control” and why is it coming to a central bank near you?

Central banks around the world are determined not to let interest rates go up too quickly or by too much – a practice known as “yield curve control”. …
1 Mar 2021