How to avoid being hit by a falling star

Anthony Bolton © Getty Images
Anthony Bolton: trouble in China

Three ways to shield your portfolio from the fallout when a celebrity fund manager takes a tumble.

The trouble with celebrity fund managers is that it’s always hard to know if they’re good – or just plain lucky. Active managers who consistently beat the market over time are vanishingly rare, to the point where even those with lengthy records may simply be the equivalent of a lottery winner who imagines that their numerology “skills” have led them to the “right” numbers. Now that Neil Woodford’s winning streak has come to an end, here are three tips to help you avoid being struck by fallen stars.

1. Watch for style drift

Woodford made his name taking broadly contrarian bets on big blue chips, with the backing of a large institution to keep him in check. But when he launched his own funds, he decided to dabble in tiny, illiquid companies in exotic areas of the market. It was a major departure and not one that went terribly well, as his followers have learned to their cost. Another well-known British manager – Anthony Bolton – earned his reputation by taking contrarian bets on struggling UK companies. Similarly to Woodford, he made a fortune for his investors (turning £1,000 invested at launch in 1979 into £147,000 by 2007). But when he came out of retirement in 2010 to try to repeat his success in China, he failed to do so.

2. Don’t believe the hype

Once a fund manager has become a celebrity, their name becomes a bankable asset – one that can make a lot of money for any company associated with their brand. That means that regardless of the manager’s own integrity, the focus will almost inevitably turn to asset gathering, rather than asset nurturing. Bolton’s China fund is a classic example – it drew a lot of criticism at the time for charging higher-than-average fees for an investment trust, thus capitalising on Bolton’s appeal. And there’s no doubt that Hargreaves Lansdown in particular benefited from Woodford’s celebrity status.

3. Times change, so diversify

Even if a fund manager is able to stick to their knitting, and to avoid letting fame go to their head, it’s important for investors to remember that times change. Today’s big names, such as Nick Train and Terry Smith, have done very well by investing in “quality” stocks – big companies with reliable cash flows and strong brands. This has been an excellent strategy and we’ve long been fans of Train’s investment trusts in particular. That said, even good stocks can grow too expensive and at some point this style of investing will fall out of favour. So don’t put all your eggs in one basket. Diversify by style, as well as by asset class. And if you can’t find a promising active manager, remember that passively tracking the market is both cheaper and more reliable.


I wish I knew what an open-ended fund was, but I’m too embarrassed to ask

Investors in an open-ended fund give a fund manager their money to invest on a collective basis. The term “open-ended” means that new shares can be issued in accordance with demand for them. When an investor wants to put money into the fund, new shares are issued. When they sell, the shares are “redeemed”. The buying and selling price of an open-ended fund always reflects the value of the underlying portfolio (minus any costs involved).

One problem with using open-ended funds to invest in illiquid assets – such as commercial property, for example – is that if investors demand their money back in large numbers, then the fund will be unable to liquidate its holdings rapidly enough to satisfy redemption requests. This is why many commercial property funds had to halt redemptions during the panic that followed Britain’s vote to leave the European Union in 2016. It’s also the underlying problem behind the “gating” of Neil Woodford’s flagship fund.

This is not a pleasant experience for investors who rightly expect to be able to access their money as and when they want to. This is one reason why MoneyWeek prefers to use investment trusts – closed-end funds. An investment trust is simply a company whose business is investment. The trust lists on the stock exchange, and then uses the money raised to invest in a portfolio of assets. If an investor wants to invest in the trust, they simply buy the shares from another investor on the open market. As a result, the fund manager is never under pressure to sell out of the underlying portfolio purely to satisfy redemption requests.

This does mean that the share price of an investment trust will often trade at either a discount or a premium to the value of the underlying portfolio. But it also means that you can always get access to your money in a hurry if push comes to shove.