Features

Target-date retirement funds miss the mark

Many popular target-date retirement funds might not suit the modern UK market, says David Prosser.

916_MW_P25_Pensions
Some financial products don't live up to their potential

The financial-services industry has a long history of inventing seemingly clever products that turn out to be anything but smart. Now it looks like target-date funds, aimed at millions of people saving for retirement, could be yet another example.

The premise is appealing. Target-date funds group together savers who plan on retiring at roughly the same time, and promise an asset-allocation strategy built accordingly. When people are younger, the fund invests in assets deemed higher risk, but potentially higher return predominantly shares.

As the group of investors nears its target retirement date, the fund is gradually shifted into bonds. These are supposed to be less risky, reducing the danger of investors' money plummeting in value shortly before retirement. They also pay a regular income, which may be useful for those considering withdrawing money direct from their pension funds, rather than cashing in to buy an annuity.

Problems across the pond

In America, assets invested in these funds have increased 15-fold over the past decade or so, to more than $1.1trn today, and they are now being aggressively marketed to savers in the UK. But there is a potential snag.

A team of researchers from Princeton University in the US and EDHEC, the French business school, have published a study warning that the bond portfolios that target-date funds use are riskier than widely thought. These portfolios are typically composed of short-term bonds that are exposed to market risks (eg, changes in interest rates) and do not offer the long-term certainty about income that many retirees expect.

It should be possible to manage this shortcoming by designing bond portfolios that are less exposed to market risks, say the researchers. However, there is little sign of the industry rethinking its current approach.

The suitability of target funds for today's retirees is also questionable. Many people don't want to set a specific date to take their benefits they'd prefer to leave that choice until later. And now that the requirement to buy an annuity has been removed, many savers see no need to shift all their money into low-risk assets as they near retirement they'd rather keep some invested for capital gains. An all-bonds portfolio will generate some income, but it won't deliver much growth. So a multi-asset portfolio that includes both shares and bonds may be better for people who want to take advantage of the flexibility that today's pensions rules can offer.

Recommended

The best investment trusts to buy for 2021
Investment trusts

The best investment trusts to buy for 2021

Sectors ranging from emerging markets to student accommodation look poised to do well this year, says David Stevenson, as he picks the best investment…
19 Jan 2021
Four of the best funds for mining profits in gold
Gold

Four of the best funds for mining profits in gold

The gold-price upswing is set to endure, says Max King. These funds look the most promising.
13 Jan 2021
Venture capital trusts that offer growth, income and tax relief
Share tips

Venture capital trusts that offer growth, income and tax relief

Professional investor Alex Davies, founder of high-net-worth investment service Wealth Club, is a fan of venture capital trusts (VCTs). Here, he picks…
8 Jan 2021
I wish I knew what an investment trust was, but I’m too embarrassed to ask
Too embarrassed to ask

I wish I knew what an investment trust was, but I’m too embarrassed to ask

“Active” investment funds come in two main varieties, one of which is investment trusts. But what exactly is an investment trust?
5 Jan 2021

Most Popular

Prepare for the end of the epic bubble in US stocks
US stockmarkets

Prepare for the end of the epic bubble in US stocks

US stocks are as expensive as they’ve ever been. How can you prepare your portfolio for a bubble bursting?
18 Jan 2021
Bitcoin: fool’s gold or the new gold?
Bitcoin

Bitcoin: fool’s gold or the new gold?

With bitcoin hitting new highs last week, and close to becoming a mainstream investment, is it really gold for the 21st century?
15 Jan 2021
It's not just the UK – we're seeing pandemic housing booms across the globe
Property

It's not just the UK – we're seeing pandemic housing booms across the globe

Soaring house prices aren’t just a UK thing, they’re a worldwide phenomenon. And it’s no coincidence – the underlying cause is much the same. John Ste…
18 Jan 2021