Donald Trump is portrayed as a clown, but his policies are more scary than amusing, says Matthew Lynn.
Since Jeremy Corbyn's unexpected triumph as Labour leader in the summer, we have become used to worrying, at least a little bit, about "Corbynomics" his madcap policy combination of printing lots of money, forgetting about the budget deficit, pushing up taxes and government spending, and trying to control industries from Whitehall. But there is, if it were possible, something even more scary than this out there. It's Trumponomics. Trump's plans are every bit as bonkers as Corbyn's even if you discount his recent proposal for a blanket ban on all Muslims coming into the country.
The Donald, as he is known to hisfans, is way out in front in the racefor the Republican presidential nomination in America, with the first primaries only weeks away. The first votes will be cast on 1 February, with the Iowa caucus swiftly followed by primaries in New Hampshire, then Nevada and South Carolina. Despite expectations that his campaign would quickly implode under the weight of its own ridiculousness, Trump maintains a solid lead. Indeed, it is getting wider. Polls last weekend showed himcollecting 36% of Republican votes,20 points ahead of his closest challenger, Ted Cruz. Extraordinarily, a majorityof his party's supporters trust him more on the economy than any other candidate.
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Half-baked populism
How so? Admittedly, it is quite hard to make a great deal of detailed sense of his plans. Even so, a few proposals have emerged from the barnstorming rhetoric. First, he seems determined to start a trade war with China ("Listen, you motherf***ers, we're going to tax you 25%!" was how he pithily put forward the idea in one speech). His number-one priority appears to be to curb the trade deficit the US runs with China. That ignores the fact that buying lots of cheap stuff from abroad makes everyone richer, not poorer as Trump seems to think. And it also leaves open the question of what happens to the economy after China's exports are banned from America it is hard to see how a Chinese crash could be good for the rest of the global economy.
More broadly, Trump wants to rip up most of the trade agreements the US has signed in the past two decades, returning to the kind of America-first policies that were last in fashionin the 1980s. The North American Free Trade Agreement (Nafta) would be toast, as would the new Pacific free-trade deal (TPP). We could forget about the proposed trade deal with Europe (TTIP), although there are enough protectionists on this side of the Atlantic to scupper that anyway. Global trade has already stagnated, and badly needs to be revived, not curbed, if the global economy is to start growing at a healthy rate again.
On tax, he has an equally scatter-gun approach. He wants to repeal the estate tax their version of inheritance tax as well as slash corporate tax rates and set a 25% upper limit on income tax. At the same time, he has proposed a wealth tax on people much like himself: he wants to impose a one-off levy of 14.25% on all individuals and trusts worth more then $10m, which he estimates would pay off the national debt in one fell swoop.
The trouble with that, of course, is the very rich don't usually keep 14.25% of their assets sitting around in cash. They would have to sell off stocks, bonds, property and whole companies to pay that tax bill. The result? The mother of all financial crashes and we all know what they do to the economy. Given how little it costs to service the national debt with interest rates so low, it is, to put it mildly, a very weird idea.
Is Donald Trump a genuine threat
Even if he does not make it that far, some very bad ideas are taking centre stage in the debate. Every other candidate will be forced to take account of his ideas and shift their positions to capture some of his supporters. If nothing else, the uncertainty and nervousness that would create will make an already fragile economy and stockmarket even weaker.
-
British Airways revamps Avios scheme bringing down flight prices to £1With the new Avios part-payments scheme you can now bag a British Airways flight for as little as £1
-
RBS to close a fifth of branchesRoyal Bank of Scotland plans to shut 18 branches across Scotland, resulting in the loss of 105 jobs. We have the full list of closures.
